Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Sunsets, Florida Bay Views And Great Food Can Be Found All In One Place at Mile Marker 54 Bayside, Marathon. This Is What You Came To The Keys For! The Island Fish Co. invites you to sit back and relax while enjoying locally inspired dishes, fresh seafood and cool tiki favorites that will quench your thirst. Our spectacular sunset views and tropical waters will make your breakfast, lunch, dinner, drinks and desserts that much more pleasurable. After eating, mosey through our gift shop where you will find Island apparel with original artwork and our exclusive logo on quality tank tops, t-shirts and sweaters.
Waterside tiki bar/eatery pairing seafood classics such as coconut shrimp with frozen drinks.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050
Phone: (305) 743-4191
Website: https://islandfishco.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Island Fish Co. Tiki Bar and Restaurant – Marathon Fl – Offering …
The Island Fish Co. invites you to sit back and relax while enjoying locally inspired dishes, fresh seafood and cool tiki favorites that will quench your …
The Island Fish Co. | Marathon FL – Facebook
What you came to the Keys for!Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.Come by car, boat, or hel… See more. Seafood Restaurant · $$.
The Island Fish Co (@islandfishco) · Islamorada, FL – Instagram
6.9K+ followers · 83 following · 627 posts · @islandfishco: “What you came to the Keys for! We are a waterfront restaurant and tiki bar located in the heart …
Reviews
Adventure Krewe
Parking can be difficult when busy at lunch and dinner, but not sure why?
Food: was ok but not much spice or flavor, I guess if you like bland food and expensive drinks this is your place. Don’t get me wrong the food was fine just not much taste.
Service was good, got drinks quickly, food came in a reasonable time, waiter checked back a couple of times.
Sitting right out next to the water with some shade is classic keys, and if you plan to camp out for the afternoon maybe that makes the food better. But we had things to do and it was in, easy lunch, and then put again.
Give this review a like or mark as helpful❤️ if you are still reading.
Our hint is to order drinks and an app and hang out by the water but go eat dinner someplace else. Unless you had enough drinks them order here and the food will be amazing. We got the inside scoop from the locals.
… moreFood: was ok but not much spice or flavor, I guess if you like bland food and expensive drinks this is your place. Don’t get me wrong the food was fine just not much taste.
Service was good, got drinks quickly, food came in a reasonable time, waiter checked back a couple of times.
Sitting right out next to the water with some shade is classic keys, and if you plan to camp out for the afternoon maybe that makes the food better. But we had things to do and it was in, easy lunch, and then put again.
Give this review a like or mark as helpful❤️ if you are still reading.
Our hint is to order drinks and an app and hang out by the water but go eat dinner someplace else. Unless you had enough drinks them order here and the food will be amazing. We got the inside scoop from the locals.
HolyMoly
A popular spot for food and drinks in Marathon and just cross the street from the Fairfield by Marriott. We came in just past noon and didn’t have to wait but it does get busier and if you want to sit next to the water, you should try to avoid rush hours.
Food was decent and my kids enjoyed it. We tried the fried key lime pie, but it was way too sweet and we all agree that a normal key lime pie would be better – in case you are curious about fired key lime pie on the menu!
The atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel like i was swimming in the ocean and drinking a margarita – very refreshing decorations, very coastal and casual.
Plenty of parking and decent food – I would recommend this place!
… moreFood was decent and my kids enjoyed it. We tried the fried key lime pie, but it was way too sweet and we all agree that a normal key lime pie would be better – in case you are curious about fired key lime pie on the menu!
The atmosphere of the restaurant made me feel like i was swimming in the ocean and drinking a margarita – very refreshing decorations, very coastal and casual.
Plenty of parking and decent food – I would recommend this place!
jennifer donkle
I want to start with our server…she was at our table seconds after we sat dawn to take our drink order, super attentive, and very friendly! Conch fritters were tasty and not heavy with filler. I was pleasantly surprised by the She Crab soup…it was chock full of delicious crab and the surprise factor was the coconut flavor. Main courses, fried shrimp & a grouper sandwich, were tasty! You get plenty of food, you will not leave hungry.
… moreAn American Patriot
We enjoyed all aspects of our first visit here. Was a little to chilly to sit outside by the water and see the marine life, but seating inside was cozy and pleasant and not overly loud.
We had read that it can get very busy and long waits can happen. We had a early big breakfast and so got here about 4:30 with easy parking and seating.
Our waitress was friendly and very knowledgeable about the food and gave great suggestions.
We started with the shrimp and lobster egg rolls. They were lightly fired and not greasy or heavy at all. Lots of meat in them and the mango chutney dip sauce was the perfect sweet with savory.
The clam chowder had a lot of clam meat in it and was incredibly creamy and perfect for the chill in the air. It comes with bread, which we try not to eat, but we did clean out the chowda bowl with a piece and it was amazing as well.
I went with the lobster roll and it reminded me of the ones I used to get in Boston. Nice buttery toast on the roll, plenty of large pieces of Maine lobster and a wonderful butter sauce on the side if you want to dip. French fries were hot and crisp and plentiful. Coleslaw was amazing, I don’t like it sweet and this one was perfection. Just wish it was a larger side of it 🙂
Hubby went with the blackened mahi and it was cook to perfection, not dried out. Good variety of veggies in the steamed side.
Key lime pie was good, not the best in the Keys and it was a little thin on crust in some places, but overall a solid 7 of 10.
Looking forward to eating here again.
… moreWe had read that it can get very busy and long waits can happen. We had a early big breakfast and so got here about 4:30 with easy parking and seating.
Our waitress was friendly and very knowledgeable about the food and gave great suggestions.
We started with the shrimp and lobster egg rolls. They were lightly fired and not greasy or heavy at all. Lots of meat in them and the mango chutney dip sauce was the perfect sweet with savory.
The clam chowder had a lot of clam meat in it and was incredibly creamy and perfect for the chill in the air. It comes with bread, which we try not to eat, but we did clean out the chowda bowl with a piece and it was amazing as well.
I went with the lobster roll and it reminded me of the ones I used to get in Boston. Nice buttery toast on the roll, plenty of large pieces of Maine lobster and a wonderful butter sauce on the side if you want to dip. French fries were hot and crisp and plentiful. Coleslaw was amazing, I don’t like it sweet and this one was perfection. Just wish it was a larger side of it 🙂
Hubby went with the blackened mahi and it was cook to perfection, not dried out. Good variety of veggies in the steamed side.
Key lime pie was good, not the best in the Keys and it was a little thin on crust in some places, but overall a solid 7 of 10.
Looking forward to eating here again.
Roy Block
Had a great dinner with my family. The customer service was kick ass and the facility is super cool with lots of local decorations. If you get a seat on the water you get to watch the fish.
The facility was very clean but parking can be tricky to get so be patience.
Now to the food – it is awesome on our visit, the drinks we just right and the key lime pies were both delicious. My pan-seared mahi mahi was spot on. The French fries were some of the best I had!
Nice job to the workers and establishment!
… moreThe facility was very clean but parking can be tricky to get so be patience.
Now to the food – it is awesome on our visit, the drinks we just right and the key lime pies were both delicious. My pan-seared mahi mahi was spot on. The French fries were some of the best I had!
Nice job to the workers and establishment!
Amy Kang
We’ve been dining here over 10 years and our recent visit surprised us. Ambience by the water is so magical and food quality became superb!
Conch fritter is the best one we had in the Keys. Lots of conch and less breading.
Salad was fresh and Mahi fish was well fried.
Variety of menus and pricing was reasonable.
Gift shop had many cute items. Restaurant is dog friendly.
… moreConch fritter is the best one we had in the Keys. Lots of conch and less breading.
Salad was fresh and Mahi fish was well fried.
Variety of menus and pricing was reasonable.
Gift shop had many cute items. Restaurant is dog friendly.
Adventure and Food
Stopped in for brunch, got the calamari, steak and lobster, baked mahi mahi, chicken linguine bowl. Definitely come before the rush. Wait staff was polite and attentive, food presentation and taste was good. Vegetables a little on the harder side but ok. Parking is tight and limited.
… moreSonja Ostendorf
Gonna make this spot my Go-to satellite office! Fish tacos are good. What’s even better?!? Fried plantains AND a Candy Cane Martini — Yes, Please and Thank you. The views are spectacular and a few manatee popped their heads up to say Hi. Great service (Thank you David!!) and great food and atmosphere.
… moreTim Enright
Good food but the service was lacking. We ordered a Lobster Roll and Chef Salad. Both dishes were good. Our waitress dropped off our food was was never to be seen again.
… moreCharlene Hicks
We had the platters with fries and coleslaw. I had the grilled shrimp and Rob had Mahi mahi blackened with shrimp. Water and iced tea. Key lime pie for dessert. Our waitress was polite and quick with our order. The restaurant was across the street from where we stayed. Good food and wait time was short for a Friday night.
… more