Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 6840 Logan Dr Suite A, Evansville, IN 47715
Phone: (812) 401-2660
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Mary & Martha’s Place | Evansville IN – Facebook
Just call on us at (812)760-8557, and continue following our page. We love you ❤. GOD bless and keep you. Have a Blessed CHRISTmas! Mary and Martha, Kimberly …
mary and martha’s, 220 NW 4th St, Evansville, IN 47708, US …
The friendly staff and inviting decor make it a perfect spot for casual dining with family and friends. Generated from this place’s information. More. Hours.
Mary & Martha’s Place | Evansville IN – Facebook
Mary & Martha’s Place, Evansville. 3207 likes · 867 were here. Mary & Martha’s provides catering services of all kinds from a small family gathering to…
Reviews
Nick Messer
Visited on a weekend date lunch with the wife. Passed many times, but never stopped by until now. Was not disappointed in the slightest!
I ordered the Shrimp Po Boy. Bread, lettuce, tomato, and onion were perfectly fine and well balanced on quantity, but the shrimp! The shrimp were large, fresh, perfectly fried, and pouring out of the sandwich! The sauce was spot on. 10/10
Wife ordered Shrimp & Grits, which was a perfect portion and balance of ingredients.
A side of pan fried Okra, Homemade Mac & Cheese with perfectly crusted cheese, and spot on cornbread?
We’ll definitely be returning.
… moreI ordered the Shrimp Po Boy. Bread, lettuce, tomato, and onion were perfectly fine and well balanced on quantity, but the shrimp! The shrimp were large, fresh, perfectly fried, and pouring out of the sandwich! The sauce was spot on. 10/10
Wife ordered Shrimp & Grits, which was a perfect portion and balance of ingredients.
A side of pan fried Okra, Homemade Mac & Cheese with perfectly crusted cheese, and spot on cornbread?
We’ll definitely be returning.
Pete Stubbs
Awesome Southern, Cajun, Caribbean, Seafood Comfort Food! Gracious, accommodating staff! Some of the best Evansville has to offer in regards to restaurants. Don’t miss!
… moreIdena Browning
New favorite place to get good real whole food! Friendly welcoming service. Food was delicious!!
… moreAaliyah Jordan
Nice little place to eat. My 1st time there. Really enjoyed te food. Catfish dinner was very good and tender. Coleslaw good. My first time I ever ate grits with mushrooms cheese bacon green peppers or something it was awesome and the portions was so big not one person to eat the whole thing by themselves. I recommend this place
… moreJordan Huneycutt
Seriously the best shrimp and grits I have had in a long time!! Perfect portion and the bacon on top is absolute perfection. I tried the fried catfish, and it’s the best fish breading I’ve ever eaten. If you haven’t, please try this place asap. It will not disappoint.
… moreKathy Richardson
What a hidden gem! The cornbread is the best we ever ate…. anywhere. I had shrimp and grits and my husband had fried oysters. Everything was outstanding. The staff are extremely friendly. We bought key lime pie and chess pie to go. We’re planning to go back soon to try the oxtail and shrimp boil.
… moreGeneva Johnson
Today was the first time my husband and myself came to eat here at Mary’s and Martha’s and I must say that the hospitality was great and the food was DELICIOUS!!! We tried the smothered pork chop dinner and the chess pie, and it was great! If you haven’t been here to eat yet, please make it your next place to dine. You will not be disappointed!! Thanks so much for such great service and fantastic food.
… moreB B
Nice atmosphere, but the real prize is the food. The shrimp and grits is absolute perfection. The corn pudding is heaven in your mouth. They are pricy, but the flavor and serving sizes more than make up for it. They definitely earned a repeat customer today!
… moreTheresa Brauser
Oh my goodness, that food and the friendly staff are perfect. There was 8 of us, had everything catfish fillets, meatloaf, salmon croquettes, shrimp and sides galore. My favorite besides the catfish was the corn pudding. Loved the place and nice place to visit with loved ones.
… moreJason Fildes
I give it 3 3/4 stars actually
There were 4 in our party. 2 of us ordered the fried shrimp platter (cajun style), one ordered the fried red snapper platter, and the other ordered the shrimp and grits.
Let me start by saying their cornbread…..is off the hook!!!! The perfect combination of the savory/sweet styles of cornbread. Me and another guy thought it was so good, you didn’t even need butter on it.
The 2 guys that ordered the shrimp and grits and the fried red snapper platter received their food first. I can’t tell you how long it took for me and the other guy to get our fried shrimp platters, but lets just say the other 2 were done with their food WELL before the other guy and I received ours.
When my other friend who also ordered the fried shrimp asked for some more cornbread, since our food still wasn’t there, he was met with somewhat of a poor response when he was told, “we don’t usually give it out free, but we’ll make an exception” Well, I sure would hope you’d make an exception when 2 other people in the party are already done with their food. A guest shouldn’t have to ask for something to hold them over when an inconvenience like that occurs. And to top it off, she only brought 1 piece….when there was still another person waiting on food.
As far as the fried shrimp goes, the flavor was AWESOME, but….you couldn’t pick it up without all the breading falling off. Poor execution in my opinion.
The reason for the hold up was, “the cook didn’t like the first batch she cooked so she re-made it”. That’s awesome, but you should inform the waiting guests of the inconvenience and not make it sound like it’s an inconvenience yourself to offer something to hold them over.
I’ll go back, simply because I was a chef for 14 years and realize things happen. Hopefully my next visit will garner them a 4+ star rating next time.
… moreThere were 4 in our party. 2 of us ordered the fried shrimp platter (cajun style), one ordered the fried red snapper platter, and the other ordered the shrimp and grits.
Let me start by saying their cornbread…..is off the hook!!!! The perfect combination of the savory/sweet styles of cornbread. Me and another guy thought it was so good, you didn’t even need butter on it.
The 2 guys that ordered the shrimp and grits and the fried red snapper platter received their food first. I can’t tell you how long it took for me and the other guy to get our fried shrimp platters, but lets just say the other 2 were done with their food WELL before the other guy and I received ours.
When my other friend who also ordered the fried shrimp asked for some more cornbread, since our food still wasn’t there, he was met with somewhat of a poor response when he was told, “we don’t usually give it out free, but we’ll make an exception” Well, I sure would hope you’d make an exception when 2 other people in the party are already done with their food. A guest shouldn’t have to ask for something to hold them over when an inconvenience like that occurs. And to top it off, she only brought 1 piece….when there was still another person waiting on food.
As far as the fried shrimp goes, the flavor was AWESOME, but….you couldn’t pick it up without all the breading falling off. Poor execution in my opinion.
The reason for the hold up was, “the cook didn’t like the first batch she cooked so she re-made it”. That’s awesome, but you should inform the waiting guests of the inconvenience and not make it sound like it’s an inconvenience yourself to offer something to hold them over.
I’ll go back, simply because I was a chef for 14 years and realize things happen. Hopefully my next visit will garner them a 4+ star rating next time.