Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 462 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: (845) 791-7200
Website: https://www.broadwaypizzamonticello.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Broadway Pizza – Monticello, NY – 462 Broadway – Hours, Menu, Order
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-8:30 PM; Shop address is 462 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701462 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701; (845) 412-9061.
Broadway Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
462 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701 Deals and Coupons Deal Buy Two Large Cheese Pizzas & Get Free 2 Liter Soda $30
Broadway pizza Monticello ny – Facebook
Broadway pizza Monticello ny, Monticello. 547 likes · 1 was here. Pizza pasta heroes wraps wings dinner.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jeremy Hilden
Pretty nice place, and the food is very good. I was pleased they have a delicious veggie pizza.
Our server recommended the thin crust which is kind of Broadway’s signature.
It was very good.
… moreOur server recommended the thin crust which is kind of Broadway’s signature.
It was very good.
Samantha Sears
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had the pleasure of eating! It’s a small and no frills pizza shop with very limited seating. The prices were unbelievably reasonable, a medium cheese pizza was only $13 and it was huge! I highly recommend it and would definitely eat there again when in the area.
… moreChairman Emeritus Augustine
Called for the first time because a friend door dash me a pizza from them in a crisis not knowing. I said please don’t burn it. He said it’s kind of burned. I said don’t send me burned pizza. He send me the burned pie to the poor door dash guy and I got a black pizza pie from this garbage establishment. When I noted this cost us $20 plus delivery he laughed at me. Totally unprofessional. Won’t ever shop here again
… moreHarsh Kelawala
New management has messed up everything their buffalo chicken pizza is now worst in the area and also prices are higher now NEVER TRY THEIR BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA.(This is my old review when there was a old managment they have really good Buffalo chicken pizza and they deliver on the time.) They don’t know how much buffalo sauce and cheese to put in.
… moreBrian
Has great pizza and always at the ready. They usually have some sort of special, as I write this, 2 slices and a can of soda for $5.50. That’s a great price for a great slice of pizza. This is definitely a pizza place you get to go, very minimal seating, very old fashion, been around for years. My favorite slice in Monticello.
… morebryan calarino
Keep up the great work. You’ve improved so much especially your pizza. I use to only get pizza from Colosseo but they have declined so much they don’t even season it anymore ans just throw handfuls of topping on its horrible. Glad you guys can provide a real NY pizza experience
… morekatie schmidt (The potato)
I ordered fettuccine alfredo and garlic knots for delivery. I could taste how fresh it was. The bread was nice and soft with the outside having a good crunch, the garlic knots were superb with the fluffiest texture and the garlic on top was heavenly , and the fettuccine was so smooth and savory and just pulled all the other flavors and textures together to create the perfect Symphony of flavors!!!
… moreC S
First pizzeria choice was closed, so I searched for a another one and I am so glad I found Broadway Pizza, because I am completely sold. Crust is thin and delicious, honest price, place owned by a family. We Ordered mozzarella with fresh garlic, mushroom and tomatoes and I wish I had ordered a large one instead! I don’t normally post reviews but they deserve every star above!
… moreErika Feagles
Honestly I’ve had better at dominos
We had a calzone that looked like an oversized soggy empanada.
Just really gross.
The garlic knots were burnt to a crisp.
The marinara sauce was absolutely disgusting.
… moreWe had a calzone that looked like an oversized soggy empanada.
Just really gross.
The garlic knots were burnt to a crisp.
The marinara sauce was absolutely disgusting.
Shane Rios
Pizza is pretty good. Sauce is sweeter than normal, crust is good, and cheese is well, cheese. Overall I enjoyed the pizza. I would buy from there again. Also purchased some breadsticks which weren’t what I expected and the “marinara sauce” actually tasted like salsa, very odd.
… more