Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1710 Lincoln Way E, Chambersburg, PA 17202
Phone: (717) 264-3390
Website: https://www.carettisrestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Caretti’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant: Home
Located in the Lincoln Way Shopping Center in Chambersburg, PA – Caretti’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant has been a local favorite for over 8 years.
Caretti’s Pizza Norland – (717) 263-9553 | Pizzeria & Fine Italian …
Family Owned and Operated Since 1979. Located at the North Pointe Business Center at 2625 Philadelphia Avenue, since the 1970’s, still owned and operated by the …
Chambersburg, PA 17202 (Menu & Order Online)
Online ordering menu for Caretti’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant. Located in the Lincoln Way Shopping Center in Chambersburg, PA – Caretti’s Pizza & Italian …
Reviews
Cystal Garrett
My family and I had dinner here and were blown away with the authentic flavor. From the complimentary amazingly fresh bruschetta, generously packed meat lovers Stromboli all the way down to the homemade tiramisu and made in house real gelato! Everything was amazing and our teenagers said they were transported to Italy. If you haven’t been here you must stop in and try them. We will definitely be back. And the owners are so welcoming and kind.
… moreT Whit
Advertised prices don’t match what you’re charged…
Ordered by phone and picked up in person.
There are three different prices for the same special, depending on how you order:
• Window sign advertises: 2 large, one-topping pizzas for $24.99
• Their own website lists the same special at $25.99
• Phone/in-store order charged $27.98 for the two pizzas (before tax/fees)
At pickup, I was told extra cheese is a “topping that costs more,” but on their own website ordering page, extra cheese is included the same way other toppings are for this special. That explanation still doesn’t account for the higher price and directly contradicts how the deal is presented online.
Even assuming both pizzas were simply one-topping pizzas, the price charged was still higher than both advertised prices.
Receipt, website pricing, and window signage all show different amounts.
The pizza itself was fine, but pricing transparency matters. Based on this experience, I won’t be returning or recommending this place.
Update: The owner’s response cites competitors, gift cards, credit card fees, and taxes. Those points are unrelated to the base price of the pizzas. The receipt clearly shows a $27.98 subtotal for the two pizzas, compared to the $24.99 window price and $25.99 website price. The photos accurately reflect both the advertised pricing and the amount charged.
… moreOrdered by phone and picked up in person.
There are three different prices for the same special, depending on how you order:
• Window sign advertises: 2 large, one-topping pizzas for $24.99
• Their own website lists the same special at $25.99
• Phone/in-store order charged $27.98 for the two pizzas (before tax/fees)
At pickup, I was told extra cheese is a “topping that costs more,” but on their own website ordering page, extra cheese is included the same way other toppings are for this special. That explanation still doesn’t account for the higher price and directly contradicts how the deal is presented online.
Even assuming both pizzas were simply one-topping pizzas, the price charged was still higher than both advertised prices.
Receipt, website pricing, and window signage all show different amounts.
The pizza itself was fine, but pricing transparency matters. Based on this experience, I won’t be returning or recommending this place.
Update: The owner’s response cites competitors, gift cards, credit card fees, and taxes. Those points are unrelated to the base price of the pizzas. The receipt clearly shows a $27.98 subtotal for the two pizzas, compared to the $24.99 window price and $25.99 website price. The photos accurately reflect both the advertised pricing and the amount charged.
Eric “Live Life Now” Hart
This gem is excellent!! The Italian style food is so well done, and we live near the great restaurants of Boston and Providence! They have HUGE PIZZAS! And home made gelato! We just happened to be in the area and were so lucky to find this place! thank you so much and how wonderful to meet your family! Gos bless you and your family and business!
Debbie and Eric
Boston, MA
… moreDebbie and Eric
Boston, MA
Marshay Ryan
This restaurant is the best in Chambersburg and the best Italian restaurant I’ve been to in the country!! The experience, food presentation, the freshness, authenticity, and service are top tier! The owner and staff were super nice and welcoming. Everything from top to bottom was delicious. They go the extra mile to make sure you have the best time! This is a true Italian restaurant experience! I was in town to visit and wish I could take this place with me back home. I can not say enough great things about here!! Thank you so much for making my family and I’s time the best!
… morePeggy White
My sister and I eat here regularly. This is the only place she will eat pizza. We usually get the Bambino pizzas which are the right size for one person. The last time we got pizzas the crust was very thin, burnt and not edible. There was very little sauce on them and they did not have the usual mouth watering satisfaction. Weren’t fit too eat. The only thing good were the pepperonis and black olives. I don’t know what changed, but we were very disappointed.
… moreMegan Short
Ordered a Friday night pizza, simple just cheese. Arrives and already looks horrible as the cheese shifted so much you couldn’t see where it was cut. Upon pulling it apart there was nothing but doughy crust and unmelted cheese under the sloppy top. I’ve heard this place is awful and I know it isn’t affiliated with the other one but this was one of the only options for where I am. I thought before I go to Google or another platform let me reach out to them, so I called. Told them the issue…they said nothing, absolutely nothing in response. They put the phone down and I could still hear background noise but eventually the line went dead. Tried calling back and not shocked but no answer. What a way to run a business ♀️ Don’t go here, save your time, money, and appetite. Go to the one on Philadelphia Ave. or just don’t go at all.
… moreViolet Hill
We ordered delivery while vacationing from out of town—a garden salad and a cheese pizza. The garden salad was fresh and enjoyable, served with Ken’s salad dressing packets. The pizza had a nice thin, chewy New York–style crust and plenty of mozzarella cheese.
However, there was a downside which is why I gave the food rating a 3 star. The pizza was lacking in overall flavor and leaned salty, almost as if extra salt was added to make up for the pizza’s shortcomings. A richer sauce made with tomato paste, green peppers, garlic and basil would add much needed depth and balance.
The service was prompt and friendly.
… moreHowever, there was a downside which is why I gave the food rating a 3 star. The pizza was lacking in overall flavor and leaned salty, almost as if extra salt was added to make up for the pizza’s shortcomings. A richer sauce made with tomato paste, green peppers, garlic and basil would add much needed depth and balance.
The service was prompt and friendly.
Lindy Hackman
Even though this place was not busy when I stopped here for supper with my friends, that was not a testament to the quality of the food. I paid about $20 for the Chicken Marsala dinner.
I initially thought that was a bit overpriced until I tasted the dish. Delicious and well prepared. The penne was tender with just enough chew, the chicken was still moist, the mushrooms added good flavor – so good. Added bonus was that I can get about two meals worth out of my leftovers.
All of that added up together? Yeah, I would come back here again. I can’t wait to come back and try more of their menu.
… moreI initially thought that was a bit overpriced until I tasted the dish. Delicious and well prepared. The penne was tender with just enough chew, the chicken was still moist, the mushrooms added good flavor – so good. Added bonus was that I can get about two meals worth out of my leftovers.
All of that added up together? Yeah, I would come back here again. I can’t wait to come back and try more of their menu.
Bruce
The pizza and steak stromboli was absolutely the best in the Chambersburg/Fayetteville area! I have ate at all of them, this is the best. The owner and his staff are great customer service representatives.
I have eaten some of the best pizza in Staten Island NY, and steak stromboli in South Philadelphia, this place is right up there with them.
… moreI have eaten some of the best pizza in Staten Island NY, and steak stromboli in South Philadelphia, this place is right up there with them.
Michael Abrams
Had chicken Parm sub. Bread was good, however disappointed with the chicken, it looked like chicken fingers versus chicken cutlets.
Restaurant was clean, good people there I would order something else next time.
Also wasn’t aware of service fee on top of credit card surcharge.
… moreRestaurant was clean, good people there I would order something else next time.
Also wasn’t aware of service fee on top of credit card surcharge.