Analia Gerard
This is my third time visiting, and it Vitalia never disappoints. I loved the caramel martini, one of the many choices from an eclectic cocktail menu. Tonight they participated in NYC restaurant week, had nightly specials and entertainment – singer and sax player. Service was wonderful as always but the highlight is the wonderful food. We were two couples and shared fried calamari and a pot of mussels in red sauce – yummy and plentiful. For dinner, we had delicious tender gnocchi, pork chop with apple, short rib and chicken. Everything was amazing. We came for an early dinner and by the time we left, the place was packed. Make reservations- you won’t be disappointed.
… moreK.D. Montesano
Wonderful little Italian spot nestled in the Charleston plaza. We went on a Saturday afternoon and had a great meal from the lunch menu at very reasonable prices. Atmosphere was lovely, including the art on the walls. Our food was delicious and just filling enough, especially the arancini starter with marinara and vodka sauce. The olive oil that they bring for the table along with fresh bread was incredible. Will definitely be back to try more of their menu.
… moreThomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE
What an amazing spot. First time here and treated like a king and queen. The staff was super knowledgeable and friendly. The food was excellent. Was fresh and top tier ingredients. You can taste heart and soul put into the food. Bonus live music Thursday, Friday, Saturday! Who doesn’t like live music? And not only live but extremely good. I would put this place in the top 10 for Staten Island. Glad i went and will certainly be back again.
… moreRosalina Romano
What a fantastic hidden gem!! The food is absolutely delicious- try the gnocchi!! Christina our waitress is one of the best I’ve ever had. We felt at home right away. Atmosphere, drinks were on point ! We found our new spot ❤️
… moreJoseph Roginkin
What an amazing experience! First off I want to say that Stephanie was one of the best waitresses I’ve ever had the pleasure of meeting. Her charisma and character were truly spectacular. The tuna tartar was probably the best I’ve ever had. The mix of flavors were phenomenal. I had the braised short rib which fell off the bone and melts in your mouth while my fiancé had the gnocchi which was packed with flavor. I only wish they had a more expansive desert menu but I’m sure they’ll improve on that as time goes on. Thank you for an awesome night!
… moreNick Pinto
Very good food and service. The short ribs were amazing, highly recommend giving them a try. I love how it’s like a hidden gem. The only thing I can say is I just wish they had a little bigger dessert selection. Not even a big deal. Me and my wife loved it! Will be back!
… moreJoe
What a Gem! This place was incredible from soup to nuts! A nice decor, great friendly staff! Dynamite wines! We ate like absolute animals, but animals with class! Mario and Joe were gracious hosts! One of the best if not the best meal I’ve ever eaten in Staten Island and I’m
A big fat Italian guy!!! 10/10 ⭐️ I can’t wait to get there again!!!! PHENOMENAL
… moreSara Cascio
Had my 21st birthday party at Vitalia, it was reservation for 15.
Staff was great, food was amazing! I had the tuna tar tar, crispy salmon, and tried some calamari. Everyone loved it! I can’t wait to go again and try more things on the menu.
… moreLenny Burden
Food was awesome. Stephanie my waitress was very attentive and amazing. My New Go Too for Excellent Italian.
… moreMichael Cascone
I didn’t know what to expect here as we stopped by and wanted to support a local business so I really could have went either way… I just want to say my expectations were shattered this place was amazing the food was absolutely incredible, the prices were reasonable, and my waitress gave me some of the best service I’ve ever had we decided to make this our Monday spot to go have lunch from now on please if you’re in the area stop by and support this amazing business!
… more