Steve H
It’s really a shame. I think they’ve managed to nail down the recipe for a delicious pizza. I think they’ve done very well on all their recipes. However, I think the owners are cheap in all the wrong places. They leave the front door wide open to save on air conditioning which explains the insects in my food. I once would have recommended them as the best pie in town, but over time, I’ve had to change my opinion because the place just doesn’t seem clean. In addition, the people taking my order on the phone were outright rude and while in the store, I heard the owner on the phone with another customer. She was telling the customer that they weren’t “allowed” to cancel an order.
That was enough for me. I paid for my order (lest I be yelled at) left with it and had my last slice from them.
… moreJohn Goldsmith
Waited 1 1/2 hours for Order placed on slice. When I called to find out where it was, they said it is leaving now. Showed up 20 moneys later. I live 5 minutes away.
I ordered chicken Florentine, but got chicken Marsala. The other meal was lobster ravioli in vodka sauce. It was just a plain red sauce. It was supposed to come with bread but none in the bag.
Will not be ordering from there again.
… moreJoel Mazariego
The spot is okay, I went in for a regular cheese slice and first off it was cold even though I asked them to warm it up they said it was straight out of the oven which it was not. The space does the clean and there were a couple people eating there on a Friday night. if you’re looking for a quick bite I recommend this spot if you looking for a more fancier pizza restaurant I would look at other locations.
… moreKimberli Sullivan
My order was set to be delivered at 7:15 pm. It did not come until 8:35. After calling several times to get a refund, they refused. At 8:35 a man was at my door banging very loudly considering my 2 of children (both under the age of 3) were in bed at that point. When I answered the door he was shoving a pizza box in the door saying “why aren’t you answering the door?”, as if the delivery was not an hour and half behind schedule. I told him that the email stated delivery would be at 7:15, to which he called me a liar. When I showed him the email, he stated that next time he will make sure that the email states the correct time. There was no apology. There was no refund.
… moreDavid Yourman
Second time I order a pizza and got a mess. Very tasty but a total disappointment had to use a fork and knife call website I used to order to complain. Restaurant refused to do anything wouldn’t even refund me the 3 bucks I payed for delivery ontop of tip. You can’t charge a delivery fee if the product shows up damaged. Discussed with the customer service!
… moreLouto LaGuerre
Very good veggies pizza. It is made as requested. When I stopped eating meat I thought I’d have to stop eating pizza all together. Since they make good regular pizza, I decided to give their veggies pizza try. Best pizza ever. Now that’s the norm once a month for my family. Thanks guys
… moreYamilé Boisrond
They have a good meatball parm sandwich.I loved their French fries and salad. Amicable and respectful staff.
I was disappointed when I placed a delivery for 6pm which was paid for since 3pm. Somehow food was delivered at 7pm. (Would have appreciated a call informing us they would be running late.) Ever since I pre-order for pickup.
… moreJulio Cotto
I have been eating at Milanos of years. The food is great, but recently the alleged manager James (who he claimed to be) with his bare hands picked a piece of chicken from a pan used to make a Florentine slice and ate. Did not wash and proceeded to handle more food. Never washed no gloves. I will never eat here again until the owner remove this gross embarrassment of a manager. I have been a regular for years. They just lost my business and I will be sharing my experience with my colleagues at the Nanuet School district and PTA of Pearl River schools. I want this “James” out. I asked for contact information for the owner and “James” refused. The owner never mismanaged this place like this. I was told he is in Florida and would not be returning. I really hope the owners return and remove this kid and his disgusting habits from this restaurant which should be one of the finest in Pearl River.
… moreKevin Joyce
First order at this pizzeria. Staff was to distracted and there was no good will offered on call back after complaining. I run a successful bness in Pearl River. I’m very customer consentic . #disenchanted
I have subsequently ordered many times since from this restaurant and have found that their level of food & professionalism is outstanding.
… more