Lisa Mackertich
Do you love a fabulous bakery? I know I do. In fact, I’ll go 45 minutes out of my way to find a bakery that makes phenomenal pastries. I love gooey caramel, decadent, rich chocolate, and macarons that melt in your mouth. Despite the name of this bakery, I don’t feel a bit guilty savoring their succulent treats. They made the best chocolate chip cookie I have ever tasted in my life. That is saying a lot since I am 60 years young! Do yourself a favor, and give yourself a treat. Of course, you deserve it!
… moreAnonymous
I received these very stunningly decorated custom ordered cupcakes for my birthday.
I am both a vegan and gluten free.
Most products are one or the other, rarely do you find them both together.
As someone who worked in food beverage, as well sold my own vegan and gluten free products.. rarely do I find a product I consider stellar.
I give them 5 stars for presentation and quality
I found both superb, as did my family members who are neither gluten free or vegan.
… moreKelly Mitchell
We couldn’t be happier with the wedding cake and cupcakes from Guilty Bakery! From the moment we had our tasting session, we knew we were in good hands. The cake was a true masterpiece—beautifully designed and exactly what we envisioned for our special day. The flavors were incredible; each bite was moist, rich, and perfectly balanced. The cupcakes were a big hit with our guests, who are still raving about how delicious they were. We highly recommend Guilty Bakery for any special occasion. Thank you for making our wedding day even more memorable!
… moreJen H
Bought a sugar cookie from Fruitcenter marketplace in Milton. The date on the cookie said March 13. Wow, I couldn’t even bite into it or break it with my fingers! Had to put it in the microwave so I could bite into it. Thats not the norm with other sugar cookies I have had. For the price point for one cookie, I would’ve hoped it’s a little more palatable!!
… moreStef Mamakos
We went here for a wedding cake tasting and the samples were excellent. Cake had wonderful soft texture and the frosting was packed with flavor. The employees and the owner were a pleasure to speak to. I couldn’t be more excited to work with their team to create our dream wedding cake!
… moreAlexis Gardiner Agostino
We used Guilty for our wedding cake and dessert display. They were so professional, answering all our questions at our cake tasting and taking the time to explain what was/was not included in our package. We chose carrot cake for our cutting cake and it was delicious! We received so many compliments on our dessert bar, too.
… moreJessica Donahue
We used guilty bakery for our wedding cake/cupcakes and can’t recommend them enough. The carrot cake was incredible. We will be returning for our anniversary each year to get another carrot cake to celebrate because it was that good!!
… moreMishaliz Melo
AMAZING!! Exactly what I asked for and the carrot cake was 100/10! Everyone love it and it was the highlight of my baby shower. I highly recommend ❤️
… moreSydney Sherrell
We had a desert table from guilty bakery at our wedding reception. They were our first and only choice. We dreamed and still dream about their deserts. Every single desert we ordered was amazing. They’re the only bakery we’ll ever use.
… moreKayla Stravin
My husband and I found Guilty Bakery through the preferred vendors list at our reception venue and they did not disappoint! The team was so friendly at the initial tasting and all of the cake options were delicious! We knew from the moment that we met Amy that we wanted to give Guilty Bakery our business. They are a growing team so they definitely seem busy, but when I called to check in a week ahead of the event they had everything in line (right in the Christmas rush too!) and the execution for the day of our wedding was 10/10. Thank you to the Guilty Bakery team for baking and designing our beautiful floral pattern cake and being so fantastic to work with!!
… more