Social Profile: 
… View more
Established in 2019, Papa Gelateria specializes in authentic Italian gelato, coffee, and pastries, serving as the premier destination for Italian-inspired treats in the Lawrence and Mercer County area. Open seasonally from April through October, the gelateria provides a welcoming atmosphere with indoor seating, an outdoor deck, and convenient takeout options. As the only authentic Italian gelato shop in the region, Papa Gelateria combines tradition and quality to offer an unparalleled experience. Payment options include cash, all major credit and debit cards, as well as Apple Pay and Google Pay.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 318 Highland Ave, New Castle, PA 16101
Phone: (724) 576-9133
Website: https://www.papagelateria.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Gelateria
welcome to Papa Gelateria · Visit Us 318 Highland Ave, New Castle, PA 16101 Hours: Noon–9 PM, Tuesday–Sunday (Closed Mondays) Seasonal: Open April through …
Papa Gelateria | New Castle PA – Facebook
Papa Gelateria, New Castle. 1285 likes · 108 talking about this. Authentic Italian Gelato, Espresso, and More! We will open for the season this year on…
Papa Gelateria (@papagelateria) • Instagram photos and videos
And join us for our final day open in 2025 with a special evening featuring Cousins Maine Lobster! 318 Highland Avenue, New Castle, PA 16101 Thursday, …
Reviews
Kim
We drove into New Castle on Sunday for chili dogs at Bill’s but they were closed. We decided to go directly to dessert: two scoops of luscious gelato, two pieces of baklava, a large Americano and a breath of fresh air in and around Papa Gelateria. It was a perfect spring day.
I do have one suggestion: is there any way you could add crepes to the menu?
… moreI do have one suggestion: is there any way you could add crepes to the menu?
Joyce Ross
I love the Italian sodas and my favorite gelato flavors so far are vanilla and mango. This is my go-to hide-away spot on Sunday afternoons. It’s relaxing and quiet, great for daydreaming or reading a book while enjoying a refreshing Italian soda or a creamy gelato on the porch. I walk here, but there is plenty of parking space available for those who drive. The service is excellent by the way; be sure to tip your server; Colin does a great job. He always makes me feel welcome and makes the best Italian sodas ever!! He is definitely an 11 on a scale of 1-10
… moreP G
Amazing Gelato! This is such a gem. Great atmosphere, decor, and beautiful patio shaded by trees and with a great view.
The pistachio is very authentic, ans one of the best I’ve had-nice chunks of chewy pistachio.
… moreThe pistachio is very authentic, ans one of the best I’ve had-nice chunks of chewy pistachio.
Mel C
This place is super cute and has amazing Gelato! Friendly shop staff and tucked away from the main street. The outdoor deck is lovely. I want to go every day. Also had a latte which was tasty. Mango, blood orange, chocolate, pistachio and black cherry I’ve tried so far. All were delicious!
… moreAlex D
The best in the area!
My kids love it. Ever flavor is fantastic. Nice and friendly staff. Beautiful outdoor area to sit.
… moreMy kids love it. Ever flavor is fantastic. Nice and friendly staff. Beautiful outdoor area to sit.
Ken Breetz
Nestled in and around a grove of tall oak trees sits this little Gelato haven. After ordering the creamiest dessert I’ve probably ever had, we sat on their deck overlooking New Castle in the shade of these oak giants. I felt at peace just being there.
… moreDeborah Hatchell
We love this little treat-stop here in New Castle. They have about 8 to 10 flavors each week, some which change. I always sample before I pick and the staff is friendly. Sometimes the place is packed with customers, and other times we’re the only ones. If you like coffee, try their Afrigatto…espresso over a couple scoops of gelato. So good!
… moreMichael A Dely
As one of the very few Italians left in New Castle; The last of a dying breed of people, if you will, I would like to tell you all that this gelato tastes of my people, of our culture, of our rich, silky history. Pictured is the Tiramisu gelato in regular size. The gelato is excellent. The location is well appointed and very casual and relaxing. The staff and owner are very friendly. Support a local business and have a delicious treat!
… moreNancy Affinito
Maybe I went at an off time. Thursday at 3 pm. No one in the business, but the person taking the order. I ordered a panini, the veggie option. They were out of the greens.
The inside along with the outside was not tidy. I did try the gelato, which was delicious. But with the atmosphere and lack of attention from young man behind the counter I won’t be going back anytime soon. At least the had a poster explaining the process.
… moreThe inside along with the outside was not tidy. I did try the gelato, which was delicious. But with the atmosphere and lack of attention from young man behind the counter I won’t be going back anytime soon. At least the had a poster explaining the process.
Rick Lehtonen
Papa was quiet at @3:30 Thursday. Flavors were a bit low. The strawberry was great! Like it here because it’s really a great location that is pretty country. But it overlooks downtown New Castle. A very nice spot to have a couple scoops of gelato.
… more