Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Batavia, OH, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Batavia pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Batavia or stop by 2234 BAUER RD for carryout to order the best pizza in Batavia, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Pizza Bauer Rd – Batavia
Call Papa Johns Bauer Rd at (513) 685-0744 for more information or to place a catering order today. How do I join Papa Johns Rewards? Earn Papa Dough to use …
papa johns stores in batavia, oh
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Batavia, Ohio to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa John’s Batavia | Batavia OH – Facebook
Make sure you order from Papa Johns. Available for carry-out and delivery. Call (513) 685-0744 or order online at: https: //www.papajohns.com/ Better …
Last Updates
Reviews
Carol Jordan
Worse pizza I ever had, delivered cold and overcooked. I’d been better off to by a frozen pizza and bake it at home. Second time I’ve ordered here and both experiences were terrible, never aggain.
… moreLindsey Perkins
Papa John’s in Batavia is the best place around to get your pizza. Very nice workers!!
… moreConnie Horn
Great pizza. Good deals. Large pizza just over $15
… moreJames Poloso
The staff here is always friendly.
It is Papa Johns, so taste wise you should know what you are in store for. For chain pizza I like it.
The place is small with no seating but it is always clean.
… moreIt is Papa Johns, so taste wise you should know what you are in store for. For chain pizza I like it.
The place is small with no seating but it is always clean.
Shannon Bernardi
Better Ingredients. Better pizza. Better employees. Better manager. Better everything.
… moreAndrea P
This papa johns is in Milford. On the bypass. Between a bakery and a nail salon.
I ordered a couple pizzas in the app. Then I proceeded to the store.
The guys at the counter, once they acknowledged my presence, said my food wasn’t ready yet. Did not even ask the name of the order. I guess I have “idiot” written somewhere on my forehead. The app said it was ready to be picked up. He said come back in ten mins.
I came back in six minutes later, because my patience were already gone. My pizzas were on the counter already waiting. I’m quite certain it’s the same pizzas that were already up there when I came in the first time.
Luke warm, yep that’s mine! Thanks!
I love Papa John’s but this location I will BYPASS from now on.
… moreI ordered a couple pizzas in the app. Then I proceeded to the store.
The guys at the counter, once they acknowledged my presence, said my food wasn’t ready yet. Did not even ask the name of the order. I guess I have “idiot” written somewhere on my forehead. The app said it was ready to be picked up. He said come back in ten mins.
I came back in six minutes later, because my patience were already gone. My pizzas were on the counter already waiting. I’m quite certain it’s the same pizzas that were already up there when I came in the first time.
Luke warm, yep that’s mine! Thanks!
I love Papa John’s but this location I will BYPASS from now on.
Brandi Williams
I love this Pappa Johns! They’re so nice here, rarely have any problems with orders, and when you do, they’re happy to fix the problem without any questions! Love the prices and location!
… moreGreg
Update: an issue we have noticed the last couple of years is how skimpy they are with cheese. We have ordered extra cheese, double extra cheese, triple extra cheese. It doesn’t matter how many extra cheese toppings you add. You still get the same amount as regular cheese. And the regular amount of cheese they put on is half as much as most other locations. I’ve been thoroughly disappointed with this location. When I want extra cheese and a well topped pizza I stop at a different location on my way home from work rather than stop at this place which is less than 5 minutes from my house. What a shame. The Salem road location does a pretty good job with cheese and toppings. Avoid the Bauer road Papa John’s they are the worst I’ve ever been to.
Quality control is the biggest issue at this place. You never know what you’ll get. Pizza could be poorly made in every way, dough, toppings, etc. I ordered extra cheese and got half the regular amount. Adding extra toppings makes no difference. Anyone else experience the same? Also, the crust was paper thin on original crust pizzas. Sending an email to Papa John’s. This place needs training.
… moreQuality control is the biggest issue at this place. You never know what you’ll get. Pizza could be poorly made in every way, dough, toppings, etc. I ordered extra cheese and got half the regular amount. Adding extra toppings makes no difference. Anyone else experience the same? Also, the crust was paper thin on original crust pizzas. Sending an email to Papa John’s. This place needs training.
Brian Smith
Stopped in to give them a try tonight. Pizza was very good. Cheesy bread as tough and dry.
… more