Taya B
The food here is great! We ordered the Grampa Meat Lover pizza, loaded fries, and Italian ice, it was all delicious. You can order online, they cater, you can go in (order and sit inside or take a flashing light to notify you when your food is ready), and call. The restaurant states they are from NY and it shows.
… moreMary Villa
Great place! I ordered a sausage calzone. Fast, friendly service. Food was delicious. Lots of sausage and cheese filling and the dough was perfect. Not soggy like I’ve gotten elsewhere. Well priced.
… moreBebe
Pizza was ok, but very, very thin. I don’t know if it’s always supposed to be this thin, or something just went wrong today. The grease leaked out the side of the box on the way home, so they got that part of NY pizza right. I’d come back if slices this thin are not the norm.
… moreJohn Brundige
The young lady that took care of us was very nice! However, they only have Coke products and it was very warm (we stayed to eat). The guy from the kitchen came out (very nice young man), he also took time to interact with us. I have had pizza many times in New York, this is pretty authentic. I expected to pay more, so that’s a plus. I would go again and I would encourage others to give them a visit. Next time we will try the Italian Ice.
… moreAnna Pechacek
Tonight we decided to be brave enough to try pizza from the “place by the Texaco”. OH MY GOODNESS!!! BEST decision ever!! As long as they keep their pizza as tasty as this, we will never go anywhere else. They only have one size (gigantic) or by the slice. We got a pepperoni and sausage. It was so damn good! They are a little pricey. But, I don’t care…it was so worth it!!
… morestacey smithpratt
I have been driving past this eatery for quite some time. I thought hmm a pizza joint off the corner if a local highway probably isn’t so great. Today I was hungry I stopped and decided to get a slice…check it out. It was delicious. I wish I would have tried more food. I am going back soon. I’m glad that I avoid the interstate and happened upon this spot! They need to be recognized as a good local spot for pizza1
… moresoen Pollard
The first time I went I ordered curly fries with cheese ands slice of cheese pizza. Coming from NY myself I just knew the pizza was going to be bomb. Boy was I wrong. The pizza was dry I don’t know if it was because of the kids back there working but there was no love put into that slice it was dry and old. I was also disappointed when I realized I paid for the cheese and there was none on or with my fries. No big deal I was like they are down the street I will take a menu and try again. We ordered lemon pepper wings 15 of them with fries. They ran out of fries I had to get onion rings. How do you go wrong with wings. The wings were terrible just fried wings with a sprinkle of lemon pepper and a whole bunch of feathers. My husband got sick soon after. I asked for a chicken philly egg roll I was adamant it wasn’t beef. Got home guess what it was beef. I threw the menu away. My family and I won’t go back. I wanted to support this business but I can’t do 3 strikes your out.
… moreKatie Beck
Authentic NY style pizza right in the middle of BFE! Nice huge slice of pie & folds perfectly. Big fat mozzarella sticks that leave you satisfied. The knish is amazing!!!! And I don’t know of anywhere else that makes them around here. One dip of it in the mustard brought me back to New York’s hustling and bustling streets, sights, sounds and smells. It was really surreal! Didn’t try the Italian ice but it looked good. Friendly customer service. Highly recommend!
… moreMr. Oliver
I’ve been passing by this establishment for about an year – and finally decided to try it out today! Absolutely phenomenal. Great customer service! Quality pizza with fresh ingredients! This place is a-must try!
“Treat yourself, don’t cheat yourself”
… moreColette G.
Well I’ve been trying to try out this pizza spot. I walked in ordered 2 slices upon my waiting I notice on the table Brooklyn. I said to myself well this has got to be good. Then I noticed one of the doors decorated with the surrounding City’s from up North. Well I am sorry I don’t have that good review on the two cheese slices I obtained. First the crust was paper thin and now cheese was not at all Gooey but burnt.
… more