4.4 – 110 reviews • Pizza delivery
Social Profile: 
Experience the taste of Sheridan with MrJims.Pizza, your local destination for delicious, handcrafted pizza. Opened in 2021, we specialize in making our fresh dough in-house daily. Our menu features a range of options, from our loaded hand-stretched crust to thin and crispy creations and gluten-free alternatives. For a lighter choice, explore our large Pizza D’Lish line. We also cater to large groups with generous portions of wings, pasta, breadsticks, and salads, making us the perfect choice for any event. Call us directly at 307-218-0888 for large pizza pricing discounts. Enjoy the convenience of delivery directly to your door, including hotels.
Counter-serve chain offering pizza with lots of toppings in original or thinner-crust versions.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
mrjims.pizza
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
MrJims.Pizza of Sheridan Menu
MrJims.Pizza # 40. Address: 856 Coffeen Ave, Sheridan, WY 82801. Phone: 307-218-0888. Sun: 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Mon: 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM
Reviews
Jill Chafitz
Solid neighborhood pizza that doesn’t overthink it. I ordered the thin crust with mushrooms and olives, the sauce-to-cheese ratio was spot on, not drowning in red like some places do. Crust had a nice crisp to it, toppings were generous. Paired it with a glass of cab and called it a perfect low-key night in. For under $20, this is exactly what you want when the pizza craving hits. Would order again.
… moreA Cahill
Mr. Jim’s delivers. That was so cool to hear. The delivery drivers were clean, respectful, and very nice. The pizzas were huge and super yummy. The crust is well seasoned. I am looking forward to having their pizza again.
… moreMr J
The pizza toppings and sauce tasted cheap, and I didn’t enjoy the grease on the pizza. I ordered a thin crust, but this was unlike any thin crust I’ve experienced before. I recommend saving your money and ordering from Domino’s, Pizza Hut, or Little Caesars instead.
… moreChristian Fleenor
This was me and my family’s first time going and it was absolutely amazing. The people are extremely nice and helpful. They allowed me to use a coupon on top of 2 free small pizzas. It was a great experience and a great price. Very helpful at a time like this. We couldn’t be more grateful.
… moreMike Bolle
Definitely the best pizza in Sheridan Wyoming!! Quite possibly the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. All employees were friendly and helpful. My Pizza was made quickly. Hot and delicious! Half and half was executed perfectly!!
… moreJesse L
I was hoping for a better pizza. They gave it to us burnt as you can see in the pictures, the Canadian bacon looks like ham pieces and the crust was only alright. It just has your selected sauce spread over the crust edge. I was hoping for great pizza but ended up being just a little better than little Cesar but a lot more expensive.
… moreBryan Moore
Extremely polite and professional crew. Made my pizza dead on time. The pizza was 100% worth the price!
… moreTim Graham
From out of town and after a long day of riding we were too tired to go out. Local sounded better than the Big Chain store and it was. The pizza was excellent delivery was fast and it showed up very hot. I don’t get here often but when I’m here again I’m definitely ordering from Mr Jim’s
… moreBenjamin Nugent
Fast delivery, food was hot and fresh , driver was polite. Ordering online was easy thank you for a pleasant food delivery experience in a world of bad ones
… moreAustin
Good pizza. Better than the other delivery chains in town.
… more