Becky Paul
I recently threw my husband a surprise 50th birthday party at Pins, and instead of getting a cake, I asked Mikey’s if they could make the number 50 in pepperoni and they totally made it happen!! It was a hit! They made it so easy for me to order a party pack of pizzas in advance and it was ready on time and made my life so much easier! Thanks to them for helping me celebrate my husband! The staff were also so helpful and nice and I so appreciated their help!
… moreDan Bradley
First time here. I got the spicy pepperoni slice. The crust was perfect. Thin and crunchy, but not too thin. Crust was seasoned great. Chewy and soft. Sauce was just the right spices. Great combinations. They offer 4 different dipping sauces. Something for everyone. I will be back
… moreTessa Landry
It actually breaks my heart to write a bad review for this place, but the quality has really gone downhill. I used to love Mikey’s and wanted to bring my son for a fun dinner after a night of shopping. The person working was VERY nice and pleasant, so no hate to them at all, and the reason they get an extra star. But the pizza was stale even after being reheated. Half the drinks (including Coke!) on the fountain were out. They were out of cheesy breadsticks. And the final blow to my heart, they were fully out of the unicorn sauce. I’m hoping it was just a really bad night, but it definitely put me off for a while. Such a Bummer!
… moreChris Bright
Food quality has gotten worse. Worst part here is service. Only spicy pizza on a weekend night is ridiculous. Employee also scrolled the gram for 5 minutes before acknowledging my presence. Could have made a pep or cheese pizza in this time. Worst part is it’s only Pins food option. Ownership red flag anyone? Chapter 13 lawyer reference?
… moreMarilyn Downing
We went here while at Pins. My mother in law asked if I wanted a slice and I mentioned that I was allergic. The cashier asked what I was allergic to and noted that they have dairy free and vegan options. I have never been to a pizza place with dairy free options! I had the barbecue dairy free pizza and it was amazing.
… moreChristopher Kozar
Been eating Mikey’s for many years but first time at this location for take out. Quality remains amazing. Introduced my 90 year old parents, ex-wife and son to it and they agreed it’s in their top 3 pizzas. Super fan here!!!
… moreJeremy Traegner
I seen someone post this earlier and I wish I knew they had LGBT sauce when I went in on Sunday. Even without the LGBT sauce, the food was good! Lillie and Trista made the atmosphere much more enjoyable! This place made my night, and I’m eager to swing by again and try the LGBT sauce.
… moreSonny
Awesome spot for a quality slice late at night. Mikey’s really hits the spot when not much else is open. The pizza slices are huge, with a great crust and plenty of toppings. The atmosphere is cool and perfect for capping off a night out.
It can get pretty busy, so there might be a bit of a wait, but it’s totally worth it. A go-to spot for a delicious, satisfying late-night meal. Will definitely be back!
… moreJoshua Ralston
Went in was completely respectful, asked server what the best pizza was, she had no answer or clue, father stated, “she prob doesn’t eat it she’s skinny”.(nicely gave her a compliment) Payed 170 dollars for 4 pizzas 25 percent tip, we left. Came back 45 minutes later. Manager canceled the order b.c. my father “commented on her body”. Never let us know, no text no anything. Stay away from this pizza place. UPDATE TO THE OWNER COMMENT. at what point did the word anorexic get used? Your employee couldn’t tell us what her favorite pizza was or what’s good, thus assumption being she doesn’t eat it. Did not happen, making things up to make your insane ideology seem better is beyond inappropriate. Embarrassing for your company that your stance is all skinny people are anorexic
… moreGary Peters
Awesome late night food spot, only downside is ordering a full pie takes almost 20minutes.
The food itself was awesome, really loved the chicken finger French fry pizza.
Also it is connected to both Pins and 16-bit, which gives you a a lot to do while waiting
… more