Address and Contact Information
Address: 114 E Lincoln Ave, McDonald, PA 15057
Phone: (724) 926-8100
Website: https://www.orderjayspizzamenu.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Jay’s Pizza – McDonald, PA – 114 E Lincoln Ave – Hours, Menu, Order
Jay’s Original Pizza · Best Seller. Cheese Pizza. Classic cheese or create own pizza. $8.89 · White Pizza. Shelby’s white sauce olive oil, garlic, house spices, …
Jay’s Pizza | McDonald PA – Facebook
Jay’s Pizza, McDonald. 2763 likes · 57 talking about this · 70 were here. Michele, previous owner of Shelbys Station (Bridgeville,Pa) is bringing back…
Jay’s Pizza – 114 E Lincoln Ave, McDonald, PA 15057 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in McDonald, PA! Jay’s Pizza is a … These are the shop recommendations for a great meal experience. Fish …
Reviews
Joshua Wade
I visited Jay’s Pizza Shop and had a good experience. The pepperoni roll was impressively sized and very flavorful, and the crinkle fries were seasoned and prepared perfectly. Service was nice, though the wait for the food was 40 minutes. While the main items were excellent, the cookie was unfortunately a disappointment. It is worth noting there is only one table available for dining in.
… moreStephen Zerbe
We ordered 4 pizzas and chicken wings from here, and waited 8 minutes after the time they said. Their facility was a little dirty and the cooler they keep the wings in was in the waiting area. We drove 1 minute home and half the pizzas were cold. The pizza toppings also just slid right off the pizzas too. The pizza is just ok. I could forgive it all if the pizza was good but it was not.
… morePam
I ate Jaya pizza for years. This was nothing like it was. I was very disappointed. Crust was over baked, sauce and cheese have changed. I think Jay should try the pizza and make his own decision. I know they bought receipts for pizza and was not to change anything. Also place is very cluttered and not too clean,
… moreRobert Cook
One of my top 3 best pizza places in Pittsburgh. The OG pepperoni pizza is Devine. Been eating this pizza for 30+ years and it’s always been this good. Would highly recommend. Just got 6 slices and the wife got a steak hoagie.
… moreRegan Adamski
Ordered delivery, all the food arrived cold, inedible like cardboard. Chuck E. Cheese has better food. Then they basically steal your money & won’t issue a refund for the garbage they delivered.
… moreShannon Mohler
I just started working in the area and I’m really glad I found my spot because everything I ever ordered has been really good the food is amazing and so is the service I highly recommend
… moreDon Richards
28.50 for cheesy garlic bread and a hoagie. Last time they’ll get me. At least the food was decent, but I feel like I’ve been robbed. Never again.
… moreTonya Wisor
Just ordered lunch from here today, it was delicious! I got a slice of pepperoni deep dish pizza and a 1/2 club sub, both delicious. The sub had so much meat on it that i could only eat less than half of it!
I would definitely recommend coming here.
… moreI would definitely recommend coming here.
Bill Greer
I recently tried Jay’s Pizza in McDonald, PA, after a friend highly recommended it, and wow, I’m so glad they did! The pizza was absolutely phenomenal, with fresh ingredients that made every bite incredible. The hoagie was huge and delicious, and the pasta brought back memories of home-cooked meals—it was that good! While it’s a bit of a drive for me, the quality of the food makes it completely worth it. The service was excellent, and I even had the pleasure of meeting the owner, who was incredibly kind and welcoming. I can’t recommend Jay’s Pizza enough—it’s a must-try!
… moreRay Raymond
Never again. We tried it once more after a previous mediocre experience, because places have not so great days. This time, almost $30 for a 12 cut pizza with just pepperoni. I get that they want to minimize costs but the pepperoni was so paper thin that you could not even taste it. Crust was doughy, sauce too sweet. No thanks.
… more