Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Feelin’ Saucy | Sherman NY – Facebook
Bill Piazza and Kelly Becker are the duo that is Feelin’ Saucy! Stop in to see their delicious menu. Pizza place · $.
Feelin’ Saucy, 111 W Main St, Sherman, NY 14781, US – MapQuest
We area family-owned Pizza Shop that makes homemade pizza dough throughout the day. We have many pizzas, subs, salads, and more. We offer sit-down, take-out …
Feelin’ Saucy Pizzeria Menu (Updated 2026) – Wheree
Feelin’ Saucy Pizzeria stands out as a delightful destination for pizza lovers, situated conveniently at 111 W Main St in Sherman, NY.
Reviews
Terry Miller
Confused as it was listed at the same address as Mama’s Pizza. Didn’t ask. Typical small town pizza shop but had a rather large menu with wings, burgers, calzones, fries and more. Ordered a supreme pizza which I felt had skimpy toppings for a supreme. Maybe should have tried a burger or something to get a better sample of what they offered. Staff was pleasant. They had about 4 booths, maybe 6,for on site dining. We were coming from the Mayville Ice Fest. That was worth the trip.
… moreKelly Ross
Well to start with, the woman who took my order was extremely friendly and she was actually quite humorous. The building itself or should say the restaurant, is nestled in a little town that seems to be historic as well. We ordered a small supreme pizza and when it was delivered to the table, it appeared to be a large supreme pizza. I’ve enclosed photographs. it was a beautiful Pizza pie and it was one of the most tastiest Pizza pies that I think I’ve eaten in quite a while. Service was well-mannered and they were very courteous. If you’re ever in or around Clymer New York, you must check this out. it’s a great place to eat, it’s very casual and it is absolutely delicious.
… moreScorched Cat
Staff very nice and efficient. Pizza was ok, not the best Ive had but not the worst either. The toppings a little sparce for paying extra as you can see in the pics, but the crust had a good chew.
The wings smelled amazing all the way home, nearly had me drooling as I haven’t had good nys wings in years they didnt dissatisfy, the sauce was good the wings were tender, meaty and sticky. I would have liked some celery with the the carrots and def needed the extra blue cheeses I requested but I like dipping pizza crust in it too.
Not a bad dinner and their macadamia cookies topped it off perfectly.
… moreThe wings smelled amazing all the way home, nearly had me drooling as I haven’t had good nys wings in years they didnt dissatisfy, the sauce was good the wings were tender, meaty and sticky. I would have liked some celery with the the carrots and def needed the extra blue cheeses I requested but I like dipping pizza crust in it too.
Not a bad dinner and their macadamia cookies topped it off perfectly.
Peggy Savoir
Super friendly & small town pizza place. The pizza was great. The crust tasted like fresh baked garlic bread. Not heavy on the garlic, but very good! We will definitely stop again on our travels.
… moreIan Anderson
We stopped by looking for a place to eat. The staff are extremely friendly and the food was outstanding. Very reasonable as well. We will definitely be coming back!
… moreRachel Haines
Delicious food! Super hot, fresh out of the oven! Can’t get better!
… moreAlly
Overall this is a good pizza place. The inside is clean and looks great. The prices are good. I absolutely love the wings and would make the drive from Jamestown for them. However I found the pizza to be only okay. It’s hard to put my finger on it, but it tastes similar to the pizza I used to have at school. The flavor if the pizza is forgettable compared to some other pizza I’ve eaten before.
… moreCee V.
Absolutely delicious! The very best pizza and wings in town. This quaint, humble place will not disappoint! They are serious about their food, and their service. No mistakes about it, everything I’ve ever ordered here over the years has been amazing. Definitely recommend!
… moreTina Pruitt
Absolutely love the place. Pizza was the best I had in years. Wings were great but pricey compared to neighboring places. Staff were friendly. I definitely recommend checking this place out if you like the way things were before the 20th century, it’s just got a good vibe and the food reminds you of a simpler and better point in time.
… moreDaniel
Great very fresh veggie hoagie and the homemade lemon pie was amazing!
… more