Rosanna Panagakos
Found this great spot by “accident”. The ice cream is outrageous & the butter cookies are homemade, I wanted to eat the whole box in the dark alone & not share at all. Better than any other bakery i have been to, Great local business to support!!
… moreDawn Ann Applegate
Sweet treats for sure! The ice cream is delicious and the baked goods are to die for. Great service and the place is SPOTLESS!! Love the Buy 1 Get 1 coupon for cups and cones.
… moreBeth Quinn
Have been there before and enjoyed the ice cream and experience. Our visit yesterday started out great but when I presume it was the Owner began smoking in the back and we could clearly smell it while eating our ice cream in the store because of the cold – RUDE, completely inconsiderate, disgusting and highly illegal to smoke indoors in an eating establishment – NO THANK YOU.
… moreBrittany Kurinsky-Riley
Best homemade ice cream! Variety, of course, but the unique seasonal flavors are always my favorite. Pecan cinnamon roll and goat cheese & cherry (just try it!) have been my favorite.
Milkshakes are hand-spun old school style. The banana split weighs about 3lbs; fruit is always fresh. And it’s not just ice cream, there’s cookies, cakes, and other sweet treats (hence the name).
We ordered cupcakes for a celebration & they were the best, soft, fluffy, flavorful cupcakes (we ordered strawberry & red velvet) piled high with brightly colored delicious frosting that was just the right about of sweet. This place is hard to beat!
… moreGiGibee
We were looking for a bakery and came upon this place. They have vegan ice cream and gluten-free made to order bakery selections (not a huge selection but maybe will change once more people request it) . Ice cream is home made and very good. We tried the blueberry chocolate chip vegan ice cream and she offers gluten-free cones. It’s hard to find places that cater to allergies. We will be back!
… moreCarly Taublib
I ordered a custom cake and cupcakes (with a design of Chappell Roan) for my mom’s birthday. The cake and cupcakes were absolutely delicious and thoughtfully made. The screen print of Chappell Roan also came out beautiful. 10/10 would order again. Thank you, Sweet Treats & Ice Cream.
… moreDanielle Hoover
My family and I love coming to this icecream shop! We especially love the fresh hand piped cannolis. We have ordered custom cakes and pastries the owner never disappoints.
… moreEllen Henderson
Delicious and highly recommend this establishment. My husband was craving chocolate covered strawberries and I surprised him with a dozen for our Anniversary! As well as a Lobster Claw I seen there. He said it’s the best he has ever tasted from growing up in Newark with ALL bakeries. The fruit is juicy and fresh, and the Lobster Claw Pastry was out of this world. Thank you Crystal for helping making our special day amazing. I will be back soon. Can’t wait to try more baked goods and the ice cream!
… moreAngela Bird
The peanut butter cup brownie is delicious! We also got chocolate covered strawberries and really enjoyed them. However, the bottoms of our cupcakes were soggy and damp for some reason. They would have been very good otherwise!
… moreCourtney Liszcz
1st time checking it out and they had a great selection of ice cream as well as desserts. They need more than one person working the counter though. There’s quite a bit of a wait because they can only make one item at a time. Some seating inside and a few tables outside. We’d go back
… more