Kristine Grady
Just had a large event with 80 plus guests. Shelly and Marlo were great to work with from start to finish. Very knowledgeable, experienced and most importantly the food was delicious. Guests kept commenting on how great everything was. Everything arrived hot and perfectly cooked. Salads were so fresh and beautifully prepared. Great guidance on menu selections and amounts to order. A truly professional duo!
… moreCJ
This place is phenomenal!! Found it by accident in the plaza! We ordered a chicken parm sandwich and a cheeseburger dinner. The portions are great for the price and they were good!! We went back the next day, superbowl sunday, and ordered wings and a Sicilian buff chicken pizza. Omg they just get better. We will definitely be regulars!!
… moreSean Keith
Shelly’s is a go to for a quick and tasty lunch or dinner. A slice of pizza is large enough to be a good lunch on its own. The paninis are delicious, as are the burgers, and salads, I have yet to try something here that I did not like! The owners are awesome and it’s always a pleasure chatting with them. Overall 10/10!
… moreScott Harmer
Had the pulled pork sandwich which is currently the special. Was absolutely delicious couldn’t have been any better. Everything I’ve ever eaten here has been excellent so not a big surprise. If you’ve never been to this place and want some really excellent completely unpretentious food you definitely need to stop by.
… moreAnthony Bezeredy
I was in search for good Sicilian style Pizza in New Hampshire. Came across Shelly’s looked delicious from the pictures. I was happy I went, this is a gem!
The best Sicilian style pizza I ever had. They have 2 different sauces. A sweet sauce and a traditional sauce. The nice lady I ordered with allowed me experience both by 3 slice having sweet and 3 having traditional
Pizza Sicilian Style Peperoni
Crust: Crisp on the edges nice soft center.
Flop: Barley any
Grease: very little
Ingredients: Good quality and delicious. Wish they added a few more Peperoni
Sauce: Plenty of sauce on every slice sweet sauce slight sweetness with an after tang.
Traditional sauce nice tang not sweet And robust flavor
I like them both so I think I would order both again.
1 to 10 Pizza rating: 9.5 Sicilian style will definitely go again!
… moreCharlene Vasapolli-Bryan
Shelly’s doesn’t mess around when it comes to catering! We ordered a catered salad & wrap sandwich platter for Christmas and it was HUGE!! Tell your guests to come hungry because their food is delicious and ready for a crowd! I feel bad I forgot to get pictures but we will definitely be back for catering as well as afternoons/nights we don’t want to cook! Thank you & Merry Christmas!
… moreRob G
I have been going here for a while and I can tell you hands down it is the best pizza you will find. In addition, the staff are caring and funny. I can’t say enough good things about Shelly’s Kitchen. You need to try the sweet sauce!
… moreLily
Shelly’s has quickly became one of my favorites in the area!! Staff is always so friendly and the food never misses 🙂 my go to is a slice with sweet sauce, they are so filling! The Sicilian pizza is a nice change of pace compared to our other options in the area… went with the Caesar wrap with the tenders today, so filling as always and packed full with flavor! I ❤️ Shelly’s
… moreSkyler Judkins
Was out for a drive and wanted just a slice of pizza. Looked up a few places and figured why not try this one since it was right around the corner. You could get any of their pizzas in just a slice. Which was a big slice! My boyfriend ended up getting a large cheese for himself with the sweet sauce and it was delicious. My spinach, feta, tomato was probably one of the best I’ve had. Definitely will be returning! Owners were also very kind. Good atmosphere and great pizza!
… moreEmily Round
Great Sicilian pizza. Loved the thick dough and the sweet sauce. Pepperonis were cooked to beautiful crisp discs. Try the coxinha! They are like a crunchy fried mashed potato ball with a bit of tasty seasoned meat inside. Clean establishment, friendly staff. Will be ordering from here again and again!!
… more