Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Black Sheep Bagels Where bagels are just the beginning We are a fun spot to grab delicious bagels with a large variety of spreads and sandwiches. A lunch spot favorite for wraps, sandwiches heros and more. We have beautiful catering options for any size party. Out door seating with a large front yard for lawn games
Address and Contact Information
Address: 31000 Main Rd, Cutchogue, NY 11935
Phone: (631) 735-9998
Website: https://blacksheepbagelsnf.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Black Sheep Bagels
Black Sheep Bagels. Where Bagels Are Just The Beginning. About Us. Serving Long Island NY at Two Locations, Jamesport and Cutchogue. View our Online Menu …
Black Sheep Bagels (@blacksheepbagelsnf) – Instagram
Where Bagels Are Just the Beginning… Find us at: 1451 Main Road, Jamesport NY 11947 631-779-2914 31000 Main Road, Cutchogue NY 11935 631-735-9998 …
Order Black Sheep Bagels | Cutchogue – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Black Sheep Bagels at 31000 Main Road in Cutchogue. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first …
Reviews
Kaitlyn Baldwin
Delicious bagels!!!! We had the asiago and cheddar jalapeño and both were delicious. They don’t skimp on the cheese on top! Asiago almost tasted like grilled cheese!
… moreStephanie Coughlan
Best bagels on the North Fork. Fresh warm and cooked to perfection in house. The flavored cream cheese are excellent. All the sandwiches are really good too. They never disappoint!
… moreTina H
Great spot for yummy bagels and such. Everything u need for breakfast! The quiche is no crust . There are tables outside if u want to sit.
… morecharles F.
Second time having Black Sheep Bagels and both times was very impressed. The iced coffee is served with coffee iced cubes! Won’t get watered down, I love it! The bagels are also great! Definitely give it a try! Also the have bagel cannolis! They’re pretty good
… moreMillie Kwan
Continuing on our search for the best NY style bagel on the North Fork brought us to Black Sheep Bagels. Somewhere out there I think what is the right NY style bagel had changed since one review said this bagel store had the quintessential NY bagel that was soft and pillowy. I like mine with a nice crisp crust and even dense crumb. While the bagels were good they are not fundamentally NY style bagels as I described. They were soft and pillowy. So good but not great. Would go again but I think a sandwich would be better than a plain bagel or one with cream cheese. Very bready bagels.
… moreMeghan Sponheimer
As a native Long Islander, I always look forward to stopping in for breakfast at the Black Sheep when passing through. These are without a doubt the best bagels I have ever had on the island, or anywhere else for that matter. From the flavor to the texture and the amount of seeds, these bagels are always consistent. Next time you are in Cutchogue, make sure you stop in and try their staple breakfast sandwich, “The Black Sheep.” I can confidently say it is the absolute best egg sandwich I have ever had!
… moreginagina121
So yummy the French Toast bagel was super tasty! LALALALOVED it!
… moreNicole Edmonds
I always forget about this location, and shame on me! It’s slightly less hectic than Jamesport, but it’s the same quality all around and a tad easier to get in/out of. Staff is also amazing!!!
… moreJack Kalish
Hands down the best bagel spot around! Every time I come to Black Sheep Bagels, the service is top-notch, but I have to give a special major shoutout aka the bagel goat. This guy takes customer service to another level. Whether he’s remembering your order, cracking a joke, or making sure your bagel is toasted just right, Julian brings the kind of energy that makes you want to come back every morning. The bagels are always fresh, the coffee hits perfectly, and the vibe is warm and welcoming. If you want great food and the kind of service that makes your day better, Black Sheep Bagels is it.
… moreChristen Schade
Black Sheep Bagels in Cutchogue has the best bagels and egg sandwiches! The owner is so nice. He came outside, greeted and chatted with us for a bit, and gave us water for our dogs. We’ve been to their Jamesport location many times and are so excited they’ve expanded.
… more