Liza
The staff were super friendly and efficient, getting my food to me quickly while still maintaining the quality of the sandwich! love it here.
… moreAhmad Day
Im typically more of a subway guy, but i consider this jersey mikes to be a hidden gem of peachtree city. Clean, polite staff, fresh ingredients, and the Manager, Tamar, all blended together to create an amazing experience, time and time again.
Would rate it six stars if I could!
… moreYolonda Boston
Worst sandwich place ever, my sandwich was not cooked properly. I spent $17 on a Philly cheesesteak that I had to throw in the trash. Meat was raw/pink, I noticed immediately after the 2nd bite. Keep your money!!
… morenoah
I’ve been eating here ever since I lived in peachtree city. The food is delicious, and the service is excellent. The workers are always polite and welcoming, I’ve never had a bad experience at Jersey Mike’s.
… morePresley James
love this place so much! amy’s the best and has always been so nice and always perfects my order when i come in. my sandwiches are always made 10/10
… moreMarian
I visited 12/14 around noon. I placed a carry out order of a regular #56. The staff was courteous and inviting upon entering. Hands down the best Jersey Mike’s sandwich I have had in years. I don’t know the name of the young lady who fixed my sandwich (my receipt says Juwan), but she deserves everything on her Christmas list.
… moreWHO.IS.DARIUS
WISH I COULD GIVE IT ZERO STARS !!!! BOTH EMPLOYEES WERE INCOMPETENT !! They rung my order up wrong and then said they’d refund it 2 days later so I’d have to wait for those funds to return and then they charged me again… only for my sandwich to be completely wrong, when I can back to tell them it’s wrong, they want to tell me that’s what I ordered… I don’t eat red meat and the chicken Philly don’t even come with bacon so why the hell wold I say add bacon?!?! Spent over $50 on one damn sandwich and 30 mins waiting for them to mess up. This my second bad Jersey mikes experience. I think I’ll just go to other sub spots until they train their employees to be respectful and actually listen to customers. HORRIBLE SERVICE!!! They were sitting at the tables on their phones when I walked and and acted like I was ruining their day when I walked in to order. I’m Never coming to this location again.
… morehaley
Jersey Mike’s is consistently great, and today’s visit was no exception. I was especially impressed with Amy. She was incredibly nice and made my sub perfectly. Her friendly demeanor and attention to detail made me feel really welcome. It’s clear she’s a quick learner and a great addition to the team. Definitely a positive experience.
… moreGrace Kieffer
The worker Amy was so kind. Food was great! Overall an enjoyable experience.
… moreAlex Rop
I hate to give a one star but I got a giant #13 (11:15 on 1/22/26) and split it with my wife. The end had almost no meat on it, and the lightest amount of lettuce, pickles, banana peppers you could imagine. Then the half closer to the middle was where some of the meat actually was and it had a chemical taste to it. So unfortunate and you can check my other reviews, I’m not a negative person but this was not good at all.
… more