Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
19 Prime Cast Iron Steakhouse & 19 Raw Oyster Bar have merged to offer the best of both land and sea! Enjoy inside and outside dining right off Main Street in downtown Edgartown. Open April through October, there is an expansive menu to please all palates. From freshly shucked oysters, crudos, and ceviches, to prime, dry aged meats and decadent shareable sides, everybody wins here. We have 2 full bars (with craft cocktails, an impressive wine list, and local Wash Ashore Beer) and a beautiful private dining space as well. Join us to eat fresh, eat local, and MEAT the difference.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 19 Church St, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: (774) 224-0550
Website: https://www.19primesteak.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu | 19 Prime Steak House
… a brief description. $9. Gluten free. Mild. Organic. 19 Church St. Edgartown, MA. Instagram; Facebook. ©2024 by 19 Prime Cast Iron Steakhouse. bottom of page.
19 Prime Steak House: Home
top of page. 19 Church St,. Edgartown, MA. (774) 224-0550 · Instagram … 19 Prime Cast Iron Steakhouse is the only true steakhouse on Martha’s Vineyard.
Contact Us & Hours | 19 Prime Steak House
Thank you! Submit. Your Application was Submitted! 19 Church St. Edgartown, MA. Instagram · Facebook. ©2024 by 19 Prime Cast Iron Steakhouse. bottom of page.
Reviews
Nataliya Podlozhnyuk
Place is overhyped for food.
Ordered pork chops, the catch of the day which was fluke and the snapper. The best dish was by far the pork chops. Couldn’t eat the entire pork chop though because it was pretty undercooked by the bone (which I’m not complaining about because it’s hard to cook a pork chop through fully)
The fluke tasted not fresh. We just had fluke at a different restaurant the day prior which was incredible so we were highly disappointed in their preparation as well as the taste of it. And the snapper was overly salty and lacked any flavor besides the salt.
For how expensive this place is and hyped up we expected higher quality food.
Also ordered the fried rice to try and all you could taste was soy sauce. Truffle potatoes were delicious and the mushrooms were okay.
… moreOrdered pork chops, the catch of the day which was fluke and the snapper. The best dish was by far the pork chops. Couldn’t eat the entire pork chop though because it was pretty undercooked by the bone (which I’m not complaining about because it’s hard to cook a pork chop through fully)
The fluke tasted not fresh. We just had fluke at a different restaurant the day prior which was incredible so we were highly disappointed in their preparation as well as the taste of it. And the snapper was overly salty and lacked any flavor besides the salt.
For how expensive this place is and hyped up we expected higher quality food.
Also ordered the fried rice to try and all you could taste was soy sauce. Truffle potatoes were delicious and the mushrooms were okay.
Carman Carter
Our first night on the Vineyard we had dinner here. Everyone including the owner were very friendly and accommodating. Our bartenders were fun and friendly. They have lots to choose from on the menu. If you leave hungry it’s your fault.
… moreAlexandre St-Amour
What an insanely fantastic gem on the Vineyard!
This was hands one of our best meals ever had…like ever! From the local oysters to the cauliflower carbonara and the fantastic scallop crudo; there was nothing on the menu that was not impressive.
On top of the memorable food, the service went further than expected and was impeccable. Cherry, our fantastic server set the stage for the wonderful birthday meal we were there to have.
Thank you so much 19 Oysters/Prime Steakhouse for this memorable meal! We’ll be back soon, no doubt!
… moreThis was hands one of our best meals ever had…like ever! From the local oysters to the cauliflower carbonara and the fantastic scallop crudo; there was nothing on the menu that was not impressive.
On top of the memorable food, the service went further than expected and was impeccable. Cherry, our fantastic server set the stage for the wonderful birthday meal we were there to have.
Thank you so much 19 Oysters/Prime Steakhouse for this memorable meal! We’ll be back soon, no doubt!
Denise Moore
While vacationing at Martha’s Vineyard with my sister, we dined at 19 Prime. The service was excellent. Our waiter, Ion, provided outstanding service. He was knowledgeable, kind, and amusing. His meal recommendations were excellent. He made our visit to 19 Prime a beautiful experience. Now let’s talk about the food! Superb, Outstanding, Simply Delicious. The best meal we had while visiting the island. Thank you 19 Prime for an amazing experience.
… moreJohn M
Excellent steakhouse. Every once in a while, I’ll venture to a steakhouse. Most of the time I am underwhelmed but not here. The 9oz Filet was cooked to perfection. The French onion soup and Caesar salad were both very good. The side of asparagus was also cooked perfectly – a little crunch but still cooked.
… moreLindsey Shanck
We sat inside right by the door to the patio, it was beautiful. The food and service were top tear, we loved everything we had! Will definitely return.
… moreDan Kellett
Wagyu flat iron steak was delicious. I was surprised at how flavorful and tender the cut was. Lobster tail was incredibly tender and not too fishy. Also had the loaded potato that was soo big I couldn’t finish it. And I always finish my meals.
Top notch service and great ambiance on the back deck.
… moreTop notch service and great ambiance on the back deck.
Mary Kay Marino
Been going to this restaurant for the past 3 years. Meat was fattier than usual. We alway buy a cowboy steak. When the busboy came to our table to take away things, we asked him to pack everything up including the sauce for our steak. He didn’t follow our instructions . He left the bone out which had meat on it out of our box. The sauce out of our box. The tomato’s and garlic pieces out. I don’t understand why this happened. I am so dissatisfied with our dinning experience and what’s worse you don’t even have a phone number that goes directly to anyone at the restaurant. Instead I have to write here. I would have preferred to talk to a manager so you would know your team needs better training when boxing up people’s dinners.
… moreCinda Bea
Absolutely delicious! 10/10 would recommend
I was in a group of 9, we all loved our food! Didn’t have to wait long and service was exceptional
… moreI was in a group of 9, we all loved our food! Didn’t have to wait long and service was exceptional
Kyle T
Tough to get in but trick is to go an hour or two before you plan on eating, putting your name on the list and they’ll text you when your table is ready. We stopped at another spot for drinks until they texted us. Food was really good. Octopus was by far the best thing we’ve eaten in MV. I read that most restaurants are awful on the Vinyard but this place is phenomenal.
… more