Randall Myers, Jr.
I’m telling you, they make the best fruit and cream cheese turnovers in the world. May need to call a day ahead to order them if you have your heart set on having them the next day. What they have on hand in the morning go quickly. The staff are ridiculously kind and attentive. Love this place!
… moreDavid Trisel
I have had three different pies from the bakery, and I am a fan! I really like their crust. And the two cream pies were well set without being too artificially firm. My wish list includes the gooseberry and butterscotch. Looking forward to see what my niece brings to Ohio next.
… moreMike Price
Daughter ordered 3 dozen chocolate chip cookies and cake for graduation party. The cookies I thought were sugar cookies. Didn’t look brown and baked. Didn’t taste good at all. Nobody ate any so she gave me some to take home. I went to try another one and I’m thinking these do not look baked hardly. So I put it in my hot air oven and baked it brown. Good cookie when it’s baked. The cookies were not even half done. That’s why they didn’t taste right. Raw dough.
… moreLeesa Metzger
Absolutely outstanding bakery! Friendly service, great atmosophere. Cute place to have a cup of coffee and a muffin in the morning. I buy cookies here often to take to family carry-ins (my family greatly appreciates that since I burn everything!). We own a venue in town and they have catered the cupcakes at many weddings, grad parties and other events as well–they always look so nice!
… moreJoel Kritenbrink
Stopped here yesterday and picked up some cookies. Chocolate chip. Multi Chip cookies. Sugar cookies. Sugar cream pie. OH my goodness. Delicious and priced very fair. Wish I lived closer.
… moreRuth Neufeld
Absolutely LOVE this adorable bakery! The cookies, cinnamon and caramel rolls, and scotcheroos are totally addictive; and the atmosphere is so cozy. Staff are super friendly and more than willing to help! Hope to be back soon!!!
… moreCrystal Slusher
Amazing place! Wonderful desserts and beautiful furniture and other decor items. Price was also good.
… moreBrandon Morgan
I stopped in here as part of my quest to try as many different sugar cream pies as I possibly can, and while I can’t quite say Nordmann’s were the absolute best sugar cream pies I’ve ever had, the 2 “mini” pies I got were both quite yummy and an amazing value compared to what you get at a lot of other places. I also like that they offer different varieties of sugar cream + fruit combinations, and I look forward to trying some others next time. The pies alone would have been worthy of 5 stars, but what REALLY surprised me were the cookies I tacked on on a whim. Even a few days later (cause first I had pies to eat), my cookies were moist and just absolutely packed with delicious flavor. I will definitely be picking up a lot more of those next time around (when I make my way back to try some of the other sugar cream pie flavors). So good!
… moreDavid Wion
Quaint and phenomenal pies/cookies/cake…all their baked goods are amazing!!
… moreMala Day
They were so helpful in helping me customise my order so that I was sure about what I was getting and that I had the flavors that I was trying to gift to 4 co-workers. They were very busy with orders yet never made me feel rushed. Prices are very reasonable for such homemade baked goods. Every flavor imaginable in pies, cookies, muffins and the cinnamon rolls are amazing. Definitely a place to check out if you have a sweet tooth and a palette for delicious!!! And if you’re on a diet….it’s eye candy as well. Each item is just beautiful to look at
… more