Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Nancy’s Pizza New Lenox, we’re all about delivering unforgettable flavors and warm, hometown vibes. Since 1971, we’ve been delighting pizza lovers with our iconic Original Stuffed Pizza, crispy thin crusts, savory pastas, fresh salads, and crave-worthy appetizers. Whether you’re ordering carryout, delivery, or catering for your next gathering, we make every meal special. Sign up for Nancy’s Rewards and treat yourself to tasty perks and exclusive offers — because you deserve it!
Chicago-style stuffed pizza is the draw at this restaurant also offering thin-crust pies & pastas.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1840 E Lincoln Hwy, New Lenox, IL 60451
Phone: (815) 485-9700
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Discover Nancy’s Pizza in New Lenox, IL – Visit Today!
Welcome to Nancy’s Pizza in New Lenox, where our legacy of serving Chicago’s iconic pizza is just a phone call away. At Nancy’s, we specialize in bringing …
Nancys-Menu-IL-New-Lenox.pdf
This little guy indicates a Nancy’s favorite! A 2,000 calorie … While we offer a gluten-free pizza crust, our kitchen is not a gluten-free environment.
Nancy’s Pizza: Home of the Original Stuffed Pizza
Stop by and cut into the crispy crust of a stuffed pizza to unleash the melted mozzarella magma and other delicious fillings! Or try our classic thin crust, the …
Reviews
Kathleen B
Love their pizzas-they are always piping hot at pick up with plenty of toppings. The cannoli are fantastic!
… moreLauren M
Best pizza in town, fastest and best service, love Cathy she always takes orders late and I am so grateful for that!! Lol and the pizza is hot when it gets there.
… moreM B
Nancy’s has always been our got to for pizza very fresh ingredients and also hot and delicious. Thought only in Alsip, but there’s one in New Lenox. Omg far down the best pizza.
… moreWes Ketcham
Good service but the bbq chicken pizza wasn’t very good
… moreCory McIntyre
The pizza is so good, and so is the service, but they are so much more expensive than anywhere else. Can no longer feed our family of 5 for under $90 :(. Will have to find another go to for our pizza nights. We can order the same exact thing most other places in town and spend at least $20 less if not more.
… moreNatalie Garcia
Our first time ordering from here and WOW!!! Pizza was delicious! We ordered the Nana’s Special and it was beyond flavorful. Not greasy at all. I will be looking for an excuse to be back in the area just so I can order again!
… moreJoe Bakr
Haven’t had Nancy’s in about 25 years, and it brought back some amazing memories! Ordered a Family yesterday and between 2 of us it was gone in 15 minutes!! Zero complaints!! Very good pizza, and I’m definitely coming back!!
… moreShirl Boatman
The stuffed pizza is always good. We did have to wait a little longer than normal for our pizza; however, when picking it up, it was explained that when they took it out of the oven, it didn’t meet their expectations for being fully cooked. They placed it back in the over for more cooking thereby allowing us to have an amazing pizza.
… moreD S
I’ve been ordering Nancy’s for years. Love their stuffed pizza, which I order at least once a month. Minor issue with the last order…my extra sauce was forgotten. When I called back to inquire about stopping in the next day to get my sauce, the young man on the phone informed me they were closed the next day due to short staffing. Completely understandable. The ‘older’ delivery person is always courteous. He even thanked me for my generous tip a couple of months ago. I believe in tipping generously…especially during the pandemic. I will continue to order Nancy’s. I should try the thin crust more often. Perhaps next time.
… moreClaudia Patti
Hands down the best pizza! My favorite is the Northern Italian Veggie pizza. Recently tried the Chicago Beef; it’s become my family’s favorite! Nancy’s crispy pizza crust is so delicious!!! The owners are the nicest people providing outstanding customer service! If you’re looking for great food and a pleasant dining experience, I highly recommend Nancy’s Pizza!!!
… more