Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5860 E Main St, Olcott, NY 14126
Website: https://olcottlobsterscompany.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Olcott Lobster Co.
was founded with one mission in mind: to bring the taste of the coast to the heart of Western New York. As a locally owned and operated gem, we pride ourselves …
Olcott Lobster Company | Olcott NY – Facebook
Get ready for good vibes, great food, and historic charm in the heart of the village. Located at 755 Center Street, the home of the Lewiston Stonehouse, we will …
Olcott Lobster Co (@olcottlobster) – Instagram
2110 Followers, 81 Following, 27 Posts – Olcott Lobster Co (@olcottlobster) on Instagram: “Roll In and Chill NOW OPEN!”
Reviews
Joseph Mineo
I’ve had lobster all up and down the maine coast, stood in line for two hours at one of the most popular spots for lobster rolls, but the lobster rolls at Olcott Lobster were every bit as good and worth the wait. The location near the lake is pleasant and scenic especially on a sunny day. The staff were friendly and generous making the whole visit worth while. The lobster roll flight was excellent. I really liked the spicy roll, but the other 2 were just as good. The lobster bisque was to die for. Large chunks of real honest to goodness claw meat, not some shaved down and minced replica of lobster that other places serve. I will be back many times.
… moreCorianPens24
I heard the hype and had to check it out. They were an hour late opening due to equipment issues so I waited. It was worth it. I ordered the Lobster Roll Flight for me and the Connecticut Roll to take home to my wife. I wanted to try the different varieties. The New England Roll was excellent with just a little of the chive mayo. The Olcott Fire Roll was very spicy which is great on chicken wings but I wanted to taste lobster. I’ve had Duff’s Death wings so spicy is not an issue. To me the clear winner was the Connecticut Roll. Just sweet lobster meat with a little melted butter. I’ll be back to try some of their other dishes.
… moreSue Schwartz
A hidden gem…. very friendly staff, DELICIOUS food and a wonderful laid back atmosphere!!
Staff: friendly, patient, informative and oh for the service!! ♥️
Food: NO words, just go and try it! You will enjoy!! (and leave full) Bartender knows how to mix a slushie!!
Atmosphere: outdoor casual, soft music and a wonderful vibe!!
SO worth the enjoyable drive to get here! Do it!!!
… moreStaff: friendly, patient, informative and oh for the service!! ♥️
Food: NO words, just go and try it! You will enjoy!! (and leave full) Bartender knows how to mix a slushie!!
Atmosphere: outdoor casual, soft music and a wonderful vibe!!
SO worth the enjoyable drive to get here! Do it!!!
Leandra Collesano
Couldn’t wait to try the lobster rolls here! My first visit was on a Friday, just after noon to try to beat the line. Walked right in and ordered and had my lunch within 10 minutes. I got the flight, minus the spicy Olcott Fire Roll (took two Connecticut’s instead), and loved every bite. Had a side of Old Bay chips and a Ryl and it was a perfect meal. 9 ounces is a lot of lobster! Service was friendly and with a smile. Limited wait time and fantastic lunch. I recommend the flight, and going on a weekday to beat the crowds. Truly looking forward to a second visit next week.
… moreRobert Hausrath
My wife, daughter, and I drove up to Olcott Lobster Company for the first time yesterday. It was a nice 40 minute ride up there on a beautiful late summer day!
We found parking and joined the very active line which moved along steadily. A pleasant young staff member brought out copies of the menu for us to look over prior to ordering.
We waited in line for 30-35 minutes before placing our order. We were given “beeper” device and found a table on the back patio area.
The 15-20 minutes for our order to come out passed quickly as we chatted and listened to a really nice pane that was playing on the corner, so visitors on both patios could hear.
Our food was delivered to our table by a friendly young lady who was eager for us to try it.
My wife and daughter enjoyed their Connecticut Rolls as much as I loved my Lobster Roll Flight (New England Style (cold with mayo), Connecticut Roll (warm and buttery), and Olcott Fire Roll (warm and buttery with Calabrian peppers)). We also enjoyed their Connecticut Rolls sides that we tried which included the House Made Chips with Old Bay Dusting, the Hawaiian Slaw (SO GOOD!), and the Tator Tots (deep fried with a nice crunch and tender potato center).
Thank you, Olcott Lobster Co., for bringing a little bit of New England to this beautiful area. You have done an incredible job in your debut year for absolutely nailing the feel and flavor that I would expect to find in a coastal New England hot spot.
We will be back before you close for the season!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreWe found parking and joined the very active line which moved along steadily. A pleasant young staff member brought out copies of the menu for us to look over prior to ordering.
We waited in line for 30-35 minutes before placing our order. We were given “beeper” device and found a table on the back patio area.
The 15-20 minutes for our order to come out passed quickly as we chatted and listened to a really nice pane that was playing on the corner, so visitors on both patios could hear.
Our food was delivered to our table by a friendly young lady who was eager for us to try it.
My wife and daughter enjoyed their Connecticut Rolls as much as I loved my Lobster Roll Flight (New England Style (cold with mayo), Connecticut Roll (warm and buttery), and Olcott Fire Roll (warm and buttery with Calabrian peppers)). We also enjoyed their Connecticut Rolls sides that we tried which included the House Made Chips with Old Bay Dusting, the Hawaiian Slaw (SO GOOD!), and the Tator Tots (deep fried with a nice crunch and tender potato center).
Thank you, Olcott Lobster Co., for bringing a little bit of New England to this beautiful area. You have done an incredible job in your debut year for absolutely nailing the feel and flavor that I would expect to find in a coastal New England hot spot.
We will be back before you close for the season!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Stephanie Proulx
Was so happy I got to check out this new spot! We lucked out on Sunday and there wasn’t a line! From the moment we walked in each team member was welcoming and kind despite the heat of the day! They were closing early (sign was outside but not posted on socials) so I was glad we made it in time since we drove out just to go there.
Our order was taken quickly and we grabbed a spot out on their patio which was nice! It didn’t take long for our food (maybe 15 mins?) and we were checked on a few times by team member which was so helpful! They made sure we had extra napkins and were even asked if we needed additional butter, lemon, etc which was super thoughtful!
Each of the rolls were super delicious and had a good amount of lobster meat that made the price a good value! The chips are a must try and I’d also recommend putting the chips on your lobster roll for an extra crunch!
Would definitely recommend trying this new spot out!
… moreOur order was taken quickly and we grabbed a spot out on their patio which was nice! It didn’t take long for our food (maybe 15 mins?) and we were checked on a few times by team member which was so helpful! They made sure we had extra napkins and were even asked if we needed additional butter, lemon, etc which was super thoughtful!
Each of the rolls were super delicious and had a good amount of lobster meat that made the price a good value! The chips are a must try and I’d also recommend putting the chips on your lobster roll for an extra crunch!
Would definitely recommend trying this new spot out!
Mikala Brucker
The lobster rolls were some of the best I’ve ever had. My friend and I each got a lobster roll flight and the portion sizes were generous. The price was fair for the amount of lobster you got. The whole staff was so friendly. We will be back very very soon!
… moreMatt Fricano
My wife and I are huge lobster roll lovers so you can imagine our excitement when we heard about this place! We went on a Wednesday evening and it did not disappoint! We got the New England rolls and a side of Greek orzo and were blown away with the portion size ! We will be returning again and again trying all the other things on the menu!
… moreDavid Comstock
Cute place tucked in among other small business right at the head of entrance to Olcott. You can park along the main street, a small lot in front, the row of parking on Lockport St or park in the village and walk over.
I arrived right around noon, the line was out the door and the patio full already…the doors had just opened!
My goal for this mission was the lobster BLT I saw on their menu posted on Instagram. So far there doesnt appear to be a website, so following their social media is the way to go.
Right now the process is fairly simple, the main entrance is the door between the other shops. Upon entry you’ll walk up to the open kitchen and ordering counter. After placing your order your name will be taken and the food will be brought out to you.
Currently there is only patio seating, most likely due to the seasonal nature of the area.
After what seemed like a short wait, my food was nearly brought out to me. Although I would devour so many things, being a lobster lover I ordered only the lobster BLT.
The lobster BLT is magic. Iceberg lettuce, tomato, bacon (perfect balance of crisp and fatty) between two well toasted slices of bread. This sandwich is magical. (The only thing to make it more magical would be a spread of Miracle Whip. I know! Im a salad dressing gurlie). But really, this sandwich needs nothing but a hungry person to consume it.
… moreI arrived right around noon, the line was out the door and the patio full already…the doors had just opened!
My goal for this mission was the lobster BLT I saw on their menu posted on Instagram. So far there doesnt appear to be a website, so following their social media is the way to go.
Right now the process is fairly simple, the main entrance is the door between the other shops. Upon entry you’ll walk up to the open kitchen and ordering counter. After placing your order your name will be taken and the food will be brought out to you.
Currently there is only patio seating, most likely due to the seasonal nature of the area.
After what seemed like a short wait, my food was nearly brought out to me. Although I would devour so many things, being a lobster lover I ordered only the lobster BLT.
The lobster BLT is magic. Iceberg lettuce, tomato, bacon (perfect balance of crisp and fatty) between two well toasted slices of bread. This sandwich is magical. (The only thing to make it more magical would be a spread of Miracle Whip. I know! Im a salad dressing gurlie). But really, this sandwich needs nothing but a hungry person to consume it.
Blake Lemoi
Olcott Lobster Company is a great new addition to Niagara County! Fresh, delicious seafood, friendly staff, and a great vibe right in Olcott. It’s exciting to see a local business thriving and bringing more energy to the waterfront. Highly recommend stopping in!
… more