Losha Lopez
If you’re looking for one of the best tasting pizzas around, you’ve got to check out Rutherford Family Pizza. The slices are perfectly cooked with just the right balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings—the pepperoni slice I had was absolutely delicious. The owner is a really cool guy, making the place feel welcoming and special. This isn’t just another pizza joint; it’s a spot with character and flavor that you won’t forget. Definitely worth stopping by! And a plus it looks freaking beautiful Instagram ready. Make sure to take your family here and take some pictures for the gram
… morePablo Djblitz
Was in Napa for a service…. Nice, local surprise. Friendly service and didn’t bat an eye when I asked for pineapple on my pizza! I did not dare ask for ranch! I do have some class.
… moreWilliam Huffman
Ok, I gotta tell ya! Cory was telling us about his mom’s homemade Alfredo sauce that they use. So we got a white sauce and a red sauce pizza and this stuff is fantastic! Organic flour organic produce organic everything and this place brings the flavor! They also have a seller gluten free pizza. We had both crusts! This is an absolute must and I am a complete food snob!
… moreKairi
Best pizza in town! If you sit at the bar you can watch them make it. The only downside is that takeout VERY slow. Dining in is faster. Everything else is perfect though. Staff are very nice, and atmosphere is chill. Overall a great restaurant.
… moreAlyssa myers
EXCELLENT PIZZA!! Incredibly nice staff. We are so excited to go back again. They made us feel like family with such a joyful kindness. There was just an all around ambiance of comfort. From the delicious pizza to the people we will most certainly go back soon! The kids didn’t even make it to the car before asking when we’d be back 🙂
… moreY. S rants
Man that pizza is really tasty personally I would call it the best pizza In napa. Atmosphere was great service was great food was amazing.
… moreJim Napier
Our first time in to set up a pizza order for a party the next day. The staff was very helpful with guiding me through their selections and choosing the right size pizzas for our guest list. Everyone loved the food and I think it’s one of the best pizza values for the price on Napa. Also local owned and we like to support local family businesses
… moreNorm P
Stopped by this place yesterday about 6ish after a dentist appointment. I have been looking for a New York style pizza joint for a long time. They did not disappoint. I ordered 3 slices. Hawaiian, Pepperoni, and plain.
I took mine to-go because I don’t live in the area and wanted to get on with my day.
The dough was amazing! It was simple, by-the-slice, medium-thin, crusty, and lightly chewy also with crispiness at the bottom.
The sauce was bright yet balanced with sweetness and acidity along with the perfect ratio of herbs.
The cheese was briny and salty and you can taste the milkiness of it. I’m guessing they’re using full fat Mozz.
At the first bite, my mind went back to 1994 and all I could hear were the ambient sights and sounds of New York. Great job and kudos to the staff.
I will be coming back!
… moreNik Barr
We have enjoyed coming here since it opened and it seems like the proprietors are taking time off for themselves and left it in the hands of people that don’t care. Asked for a margarita pizza with olives and mushrooms got a cheese pizza with mushrooms and olives. Quite honestly was the worst pizza I’ve ever had. (See photo)
… moreShawna Bynum
Tried for the first time tonight. DELICIOUS Piza.
We had the Margareta, Shady Lady, mushroom and olive and Hawian. All were fabulous. The crust is so delicious!
Service was super friendly.
Highly recommended!
… more