Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Sunset Sunset Pizzeria is where fresh ingredients meat real New York-style pizza. We make our dough fresh, use quality cheeses and premium toppings, rich home-made sauces. From classic Favorites to custom creation, we are proud to serve Brewster NY, with rich flavors,friendly service. Stop by for dine -in, take out or delivery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 983 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509
Phone: (845) 363-1024
Website: https://sunsetpizzeriany.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sunset Pizzeria – Brewster, NY
We are located at 983 Route 22, Brewster, NY 10509.
sunset pizzeria – 983 Route 22, Brewster, NY, 10509 – MapQuest
Their pizza, made with the finest ingredients, including San Marzano tomato sauce and a family-recipe dough perfected over 30 years, embodies the true New York …
Sunset-pizzeria | Brewster Heights NY – Facebook
We are ready for lunch at sunset pizzeria 983 ny 22 Brewster ny 10509. … Sunset-pizzeria is with Jeyber Garcia. Aug 30, 2025 . …
Reviews
Michael Orlandi
Hands down the best pizza around. I have been going here every week for nearly 4 years and not once have I had a complaint. Not only is the pizza fantastic but the staff are all very friendly and welcoming. Would recommend to any pizza lover near & far.
… moreRadele
I started going to sunset pizzeria when I moved into the area . I love pasta faggioli soup and was searching for a place that made it well. Their soup was great and is made from real fresh beans not canned . Their other food is also great. The service is great and the people are always friendly and welcoming. Highly recommended.
… moreNora Haziraj
This pizzeria never disappoints! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with amazing aromas and friendly service. The pizzas are perfectly cooked with a great balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Every bite is full of flavor, and you can tell real care goes into the food. Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the quality is outstanding. Easily a go-to spot for pizza lovers—highly recommended!
… moreJoe R
I used to get a slice at this pizzeria after I got off work, and on the way to my car, when I worked in that area. It was always after lunch and I just got a slice of whatever they had on the counter.
Today, my wife picked up slices of white pizza with tomatoes, and I did not even wait to heat it up.
Really good crust, high quality cheese and the tomatoes tasted like tomatoes, not mealy,.middle.of the winter tomatoes.
There is plenty of parking, but you have to pay attention to turn into the right parking lot, on Rte 6, 202, 22 just opposite the Mobil station.
… moreToday, my wife picked up slices of white pizza with tomatoes, and I did not even wait to heat it up.
Really good crust, high quality cheese and the tomatoes tasted like tomatoes, not mealy,.middle.of the winter tomatoes.
There is plenty of parking, but you have to pay attention to turn into the right parking lot, on Rte 6, 202, 22 just opposite the Mobil station.
James Diaz
Horrible experience. I ordered a large pie with extra cheese and when it was delivered it had what could hardly pass as one layer of cheese, it definetly was not extra cheese. I called to let them know and the person I spoke to tried to say they watched the person who made it put an extra layer on. To be fair they offered to make another pie but it wasn’t worth the hassle. Wont be getting pizza here anymore. $30 dollars plus $5 tip for cardboard pie, no thanks.
… morebesjana krasniqi
Such a great spot! The pizza was really good — flavorful, fresh, and cooked just right. You can tell they care about what they serve. The staff was so friendly and made the whole experience even better. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to!
… moreValerian
Sunset Pizzeria in Brewster is easily the best spot in the area. The pizza is always fresh, hot, and full of flavor — you can tell they use good ingredients and take pride in their food. The slices are perfectly balanced, not too greasy, and the crust has that ideal crisp without being overdone.
The staff is friendly, quick, and the place is always clean and welcoming. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie for the family, they’re consistent every time.
If you’re in Brewster and want great pizza without any hassle, Sunset Pizzeria is definitely worth stopping by. Highly recommend!
… moreThe staff is friendly, quick, and the place is always clean and welcoming. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering a full pie for the family, they’re consistent every time.
If you’re in Brewster and want great pizza without any hassle, Sunset Pizzeria is definitely worth stopping by. Highly recommend!
Jeyber García
Just had some pizza at Sunset pizzeria and wow—this one’s a winner. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside, soft on the inside. The sauce had real depth (you can tell it’s made in-house), and the cheese? Stretchy, melty, and just the right amount. Toppings were fresh and generously loaded.
10/10 would order again.
… more10/10 would order again.
Matthew Albano
Sunset Pizzeria is one of my local favorites and absolute go-to spots. The food is always fresh, consistent, and made with care. If you go, you have to try their sausage and broccoli rabe specialty pizza — it’s incredible and truly one of a kind. Highly recommend!
… moreLucia Regalbuto
Loved the service, and the pizza and other meals were really good! I’ll definitely be coming here for my pizza from now on!
… more