

Gunselman’s Tavern has been The Public House in Fairview Park for 83 years. Recent renovations include new floor and ceiling in the bar, refurbished 100 year old mahoghany bartop, a brick patio, refurbished original barstools, updated air conditioning and clean, new bathrooms. Gunselman’s Kitchen has reopened for the first time since 1959 serving a classic bar menu and comfort food recipes. All inspired by American big family home cooking.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 21800 Center Ridge Rd, Rocky River, OH 44116
Phone: (440) 589-7828
Website: https://www.gunselmanstogo.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gunselman’s TO>GO
Gunselman’s Tavern
Gunselman’s To Go | Rocky River OH – Facebook
Reviews
When picking up my food initially I had also doubled checked for my extra side of sauce which was not there. The cook in the back insisted twice he put it in there after I stated twice that it is NOT in there and had to pull it out again to show them. Also upgraded fries to the garlic parm fries and there was basically nothing added to them. Poor customer service, poor quality. This is not the first time I’ve had a problem here. Won’t be wasting my time here anymore after this experience. If they had just said sorry and owned up to them putting rotten food on my burger and offered me my money back then I’d give them another chance but didt happen.
Our takeout order on Thursday, December 11 had a few issues. I ordered the breakfast burger cooked medium well, but it came out quite rare (photo attached). I also ordered a Smashburger with the sauce on the side, but it arrived already dressed, which meant my child would not eat it. On top of that, the butter cup for the sweet potato tots opened and spilled over the burger and tots. I understand spills can happen during transport, but combined with the other issues, it made for a frustrating dinner.
My boyfriend usually places our orders and we typically have great luck, which is why this felt like an off night. We genuinely enjoy Gunselman’s and order often, so I wanted to share the feedback in hopes of better experiences going forward.
I ordered the chicken paprikash over pierogis, the Philly cheese steak, the chicken philly, mozzarella logs, and a burger. Firstly, the pierogis were on top of the paprikash, instead of underneath. Which is an odd choice to me. You would think the pierogis would be better underneath so they can absorb the paprikash flavor. Regardless, the pierogi was bland. I’m sure it has some seasoning, but none of it was detectable, and it really needed salt. It was well constructed, and wasn’t dry, if it had more seasoning it could have been really good. The chicken paprikash was also extremely bland, desperately needing salt, and the chicken was a little dry as well.
I also ordered a chicken Philly. It had no cheese. That’s an employee forgetting something, a mistake that is inevitably going to happen sometimes. However, the chicken was also bland. Again, no detectable seasoning, and it was extremely dry.
The Philly cheese steak, also had no cheese. And again, the steak was extremely dry. Dry to the point that it was crusty. but it did have a little more flavor than the other items.
As with everything else we had, the mozzarella logs had no detectable seasoning in the breading and there was no cheese pull, which means the cheese wasn’t nice and melty. That’s probably because it was a to go order, so I wouldn’t hold that against them, but it really needs some seasoning.
The fries, once again, needed salt, and was not particularly crispy.
I did not taste the burger so I can’t comment on that.
The only positive was the employee at the register, who was very friendly.