Francisco S
New York Pizza To-Go on Padre Island came highly recommended by my boss, so I was excited to give it a try. When I arrived, the place smelled amazing and the pizza looked fresh and well-made. The staff had it ready quickly, and it was clear that the pizza had just come out of the oven.
However, this is strictly a carry-out location with no dine-in option, which meant I had to take my order back to my hotel about 20 minutes away. By the time I arrived, the pizza had already lost most of its warmth. I expected the flavor to really stand out, especially given the price, but I found it to be underwhelming. In my opinion, chain restaurants like Pizza Hut or Peter Piper Pizza offer better flavor and value for a lower price.
While it was a new place to try and the service was friendly enough, the pizza just didn’t live up to the hype for me. With so many other options nearby, I probably wouldn’t return.
… moreCissy Turcotte
We ordered pizza and wings from New York Pizza To-Go Padre Island and it did not disappoint! Cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers, chicken Alfredo…all delicious! The lemon pepper wings were fire!! Definitely going to make this our go to when we’re on the island!! We also had the sweetest note in our order from the restaurant staff!! Such great service!!
… moreRon Judson
Sorry, didn’t try the pizza, but got some wings. Definitely not recommended. Maybe it was just the staff on hand. Super bowl Sunday. They should have been on the top of there game!
… moreChantale Larocque
I ordered a thin crust meat lover pizza. It was amazing !! The ingredients were fresh. Generous portion of meat! Pizza sauce was just the way I like it not too much and well seasoned. Great price! Very friendly, welcoming and professional staff. Clean environment. I would definitely go back and recommend it!
… moreSuzieQ
I had high hopes for another place claiming to offer NY style/quality pizza. This place may have potential but we ordered on a Friday night and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. This seemed like a red flag and it was. Our order hadn’t even been started when we arrived for pickup. It’s totally understandable to be busy on a Friday night. The experience really fell apart when we had to wait there over an hour for the order in the chaos with employees yelling at each other with phone ringing off the hook with the ringtone screaming “pizza” every time it rang. Pizza felt very slapped together and the crust could have used a few more minutes to crisp up. Crust tasted good as well as the ingredients on the pizza but it just was a miss.
… moreMicah Thompson
Pizza is average. Asked for crispy, not crispy at all. Good flavor and heavy on the toppings. Cheese sticks were frozen, no biggie, still good. Calamari was a let down. Very over cooked, could barely taste the actual calamari. No homemade ranch, served in a little to-go packet.
… moreJennifer Hargraves
This is a mom & pop pizza shop! Yay for small business doing it right. The pizza (12” – 6 slices- 1/2 meat lovers & 1/2 supreme!!) & stuffed garlic bread was SOOOOOOOOOO good that I didn’t even get a picture. The garlic butter was so good I wanted to drink it.
This is a to go pizza place with no in shop seating but that was great because we took dinner back to the hotel & enjoyed the sound of the waves while enjoying this pizza!
… moreApollo
The pizza isn’t horrible, but it’s not NY style by any means (part of my reason for such a low score… As someone who lived on the east coast and knows real new york pizza, it is frustrating to have all of these different places say “NY PIZZA” and then not actually make the pizza resemble NY style) The doe was not fully cooked all the way in the center, which is a big turn off for me. The cheese had a good flavor. Last complaint is that I paid $5 for 2 premade ranche packets which is crazy to me.
… moreBee
This place is amazing . I came here looking for something different other then seafood. The pizza is one the best I’ve had. Definitely give this place a try it won’t disappoint you
… moreChe Onufriuk
Like it, Love it, Want some more of it. Best pizza North Padre. We ordered the 18 in Supreme. It was loaded, ingredients were fresh. The leftover are going to be even better after all the flavors merry together. Go get yourself a pizza today . Love the Pizza Queen
… more