Matthew Neubeck
Classic Pizza Hut feel. What a blast from the past! We enjoyed our visit and the pizza was delicious as well. Lunch Buffet is M-F and Sunday.
… moreAndrew Meador
This was well worth the side trip. This is a Pizza Hut Classic location, so it’s like the Pizza Huts I remember from childhood. The decor inside is classic, and there is even an arcade machine! Inevery way this was like stepping back in time. The music was even classics from the 90s. They did an excellent job recreating the feel of days gone by. The food, additionally, was up to the quality of the Pizza Hut of back when as well. Would come back more often if this weren’t so far away. Thanks for the memories!
… moreMatt McDonald
This was JUST like the Pizza Huts we grew up with in the 1980s and ’90s. They even accepted our Book-It pizza coupon from the Book-It app. It had all the old highlights with the red cups, stained-glass lights over the booths with red and white checkered tablecloths. It was everything we had hoped it would be and it was well worth the side trip for the flashbacks and yummy pizza.
My 7-year old son has his own review: “9.9 out of 10. Best pizza ever. Everyone in the family had a great time. I wish we had a Pizza Hut Classic close to us in Connecticut!”
… moreAunt Nessie
Edit: Paid about $42 for 2 large pizzas (meat lovers + green peppers, 1 was struffed crust the other a pan pizza), 3 drinks & 1 salad bar on Sunday 7 pm. Pretty good deal. Whoever makes the ice tea deserves a raise! I dine out at least once a week and NEVER have ice tea that good anywhere! It was homemade and tasted the way IT SHOULD. Its been decades since I tasted ice tea like that in a restaurant (and I’m a young middle-aged person), almost like a sun tea. Absolutely perfect 🙂 I would come back just for the tea if I didn’t live 1.5 hrs. away. Very clean inside and bathroom. I don’t even see dust in the lights above our heads. Whomever is cleaning is doing a fabulous job. Waitress was great, always checked on us. I had no problems or compliants. Not that many customers dine in. Maybe like 5, so it’s empty and quiet. If the owner could just buy the Pizza Hut in New Castle, PA and remodel to look THIS GOOD on this inside that would be amazing 🙂 and business would be booming 🙂
Came here after seeing the reviews and pics as it looked nice, it was definitely the nicest Pizza Hut I’ve ever been to. I wish New Castles could look this nice! Sunday lunch wasn’t too busy dining in only 1/3 room was filled. One girl running the whole front alone: waitressing, seating guests, answering calls, and cashier. I hope she get paid a decent wage because she was awesome. Kind, attentive, busy doing 3 different peoples jobs and we could hear whomever in the kitchen loudly calling her to get this or do that, which she did with a positive attitude. Paid $58 for 1 large stuffed crust, 1 medium meat lovers and 6 bbq wings (3 drinks). If I’m in the area again, I would go back. Bathroom was clean, dining area was clean, I didn’t even see dust on the iconic glass lamps hanging above us, super clean which I love. We may have arrived after the lunch rush and after they cleaned though. Very bright and sunny atmosphere, loved the food. It was exactly how it should be.
… moreanthony raspantini
This place is a GEM. The Classic pizza hut you remember from your childhood. Staff is awesome, food is great. Everything tastes just like you remember. They should go back to this for every pizza hut!
… moreWarren area society of paranormal
First time at a “Retro” pizza hut and I was very happy. Food was fresh and hot. Original recipe and the dinning room was clean and nostalgic. Waitstaff was very energetic and pleasant. Will take the hour and half trip again!!
… moreManny Quacioua
5 years later and This Pizza Hut is still the BEST! The establishment is clean and friendly! The atmosphere is warm and bring your appetite! The Wings are phenomenal especially the Garlic part wings! They keep it classic with TVs where you can watch sports! If your in the area I suggest you stop by! The tables are unique and the service is friendly with a smile! Very reasonable prices as well and you will leave stuffed!
… moreKristan Barnhart
This is THE WORST PIZZA HUT EVER!! Got my order and it was completely wrong! I called there and they said they would re make it but I had to pick it up TONIGHT! Was just there and NOT going back! No customer Service help at all!! THEY JUST DIDNT CARE AT ALL! AND IT WAS THEIR SCREW UP!! MY PIZZA WASNT EVEN COOKED ALL THE WAY THROUGH. PAN PIZZAS USED TO BE GREAT!
… moreAmanda Bunker
We had a lovely dinner tonight at the Elm Road Pizza Hut! My husband and I decided to take our teenage boys to where we went for our first date 31 years ago. We enjoyed our dinner but what we enjoyed the most was our wonderful waitress, April! She was so welcoming, kind and attentive. We haven’t had a waitress this good in years! She is the gem of the restaurant! I can’t wait to come back and April is our waitress again!
… moreSlacking Packing
This Pizza Hut location is classic location, and it’s awesome. I wish more restaurants/stores would do this. They have a lot of vintage Pizza Hut aesthetics inside. The service here is top notch and the food was fantastic! I’ll definitely be back.
… more