Robert Robbins
The lady behind the counter was super nice, and the place was very clean. I ordered the strawberry banana smoothie but was disappointed because I really couldn’t taste anything besides the yogurt. It’s a cool place, and I will definitely give this place another chance.
… moreAlexander Karasinski
I was in the area and decided to stop in for coffee after seeing the high reviews. The staff was very friendly, and I appreciated the spacious seating area — plenty of room to relax or get some work done.
I ordered an oat milk latte, and while it was decent, I found the flavor a bit underwhelming. It may have been the brand of oat milk used, but it just didn’t quite hit the mark for me. I was also a little disappointed that there wasn’t an option to have the drink served in a “for-here” mug.
That said, for the area, the drink was solid and the price was fair. Overall, still a good spot to check out if you’re nearby.
… moreShelby Johnson
First time ordering here. Ordered a Sugar Cookie cold brew. Was expecting the cold brew to be smoother, not so bitter. Should have ordered it without ice as a little less than half the cup was filled with coffee and the rest with ice. The price for the coffee was reasonable but $2 for a snack bag of chips is too much. The employee was extremely nice and helpful.
… moreStormie
I just stopped to get a coffee before starting my day. I walked out with a wonderful vanilla caramel iced coffee and 3 muffins. Specifically the double chocolate, blueberry creme, and vanilla chocolate chip. The coffee was some of the best i’ve had for a hot minute and the muffins were a hit! I’ll definitely be back for some of the tea!
… moreMiss Eddie
My hubby loves this coffee shop. He loves the atmosphere lol. I love the mocha iced coffee! The owner/manager? was really nice! We’ll be back, ‘The press Coffee Co’, don’t you worry none!!
… moreJamie Ward
A regular favorite of mine! The seasonal lattes are always great, but their daily brew, Americanos, matcha lattes, and cold brews are good too! I appreciate the latte art <3
… moreJayanna Volle
I’ve been to The Press a few times now, and I’m always impressed! I love this place. I live in Seattle, but whenever I’m in the area visiting family I go to this coffee shop as much as possible. There’s plenty of seating and a nice atmosphere. People are friendly. The coffee and tea are excellent. Reasonably priced. The pastries are good as well. New Castle needed this.
… moreMissy Kerkhoff
I’ve experienced many mochas all over Indiana. This is one of the best. Distinct coffee flavor paired well with the proper amount of sweetness. Perfect foam on my latte. To top it off, the customer service is exceptional.
… moreLarry Fye
Friendly service from the owner. Great Americana coffee. Come and see for your self. Clean and crisp seating area and really neat use of the news building.
… moreMatthew Smith
First time ever even coming to New Castle. Just searched Google for local coffee found this place. Nice staff great atmosphere and delicious coffee. Will definitely be back next time I drive through!
… more