Hartman’s Bakery Plymouth

by

  4.8 – 121 reviews   • Bakery

Social Profile:

Hartman's Bakery Plymouth 53073

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Hartman’s Bakery Plymouth WI

Let us bake for you! Contact us today. Loading… 433 E Mill Street Ste. A, Plymouth, WI 53073 / 920-449-5425.

Hartman’s Bakery of Plymouth – Facebook

Hartman’s Bakery of Plymouth, Plymouth. 8083 likes · 555 talking about this · 270 were here. We’re more than just a bakery; we’re a part of the…

Hartman’s Bakery: Home

“Hartman’s is a lovely little neighborhood bakery. Their crullers, frosted cinnamon rolls, and apple fritters are FANTASTIC! Fresh baked breads, rolls, …

Reviews

Skye
A lovely small town bakery that offers tons of fresh bakery treats and icecream!! Today we got a custard filled white frosted long John, that was so moist and filled to the brim with custard!! We also chose to try the birthday cake icecream!! It had actual pieces of cake in it!! We frequent here often and still are surprised by how delicious their bakery is!
… more
Carissa DeZwarte
Hartman’s made our wedding cutting cake! They absolutely killed it with the decorating, and gave me exactly what I wanted! The flavor was also amazing as well! I will be using them for all our future cakes.
… more
Valerie Meissner
We chose Hartman’s Bakery Plymouth to make our wedding favor cookies and boy were we pleased with our choice (and so were our guests)! We asked for very specific designs and they came through with every one. Delicate, buttery, and down right delicious cookies! We will be back to try more of their bakery products 🙂
… more
Deborah Dos Santos
We got 3 pastry items for less than $5! I was shoved. They were tasty. Giving one less star, because your cashier was rude and I don’t enjoy her. But your treats were good ❤️
… more
Mandi Pfeifer
Hartman’s Bakery has incredibly talented staff and everything they create is delicious! They made our daughter’s dream come true by putting her design on cookies for her 6th birthday. So awesome!
… more
J. Garty
Adorable bakery in downtown Plymouth. Newer, very clean facilities with a lot of options in baked goods and coffees. Gone in several times now, and the service is always very welcoming and quick. They have a variety of donuts, bars (lemon, apple, etc), cookies, breads, coffee cakes (and preorder cakes), and other items such as cake pops. Really good coffee selections as well such as mochas (awesome white chocolate mocha!), ice drinks, and coffee. The several times there have been small lines, but they move very quickly. The employees are very kind, helpful, and welcoming. They also have different daily bread’s specials which is kind of neat to try the different kinds. At this time, there’s no place to sit and eat, but you can watch through the window the employees making the baked goods which is really cool. Occasionally they also sell a little bit of bakery merchandising such as shirts.

I absolutely love that they have a window where you can watch them make the bakery. It’s really fun to see!

Side note- really like the white chocolate mocha! Delicious! ❤
… more
Donna Robinson
I got a wonderful chocolate layer birthday cake with buttercream frosting last Friday. It reminded me of the delicious ones my mom got me growing up in Illinois. It took many years to find cake even close to being as good.
… more
Dawn Gregoire
The best customer service and the Ultimate Cookies! The decorator is precise, the designs are always fun and the taste is amazing! The other sweets and donuts are good too!
… more
Debbie Hayes
Wow, the best freshest baked goods ever! We bought a cream cheese coffee cake that was out of this world delicious, a pack of peanut butter cookies, so good & some chocolate frosted long Johns! Absolutely all delicious! Loved seeing a real bakery, not just fast food commercial stuff. Excellent!
… more
Todd Stark
Small bakery nice place opens early mornings. Good cookies,Fresh donuts.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact