Yuri Huta
Great selection of pickles. The three of us each got to select what we liked best… what more can you ask for. Easy to walk to if you are visiting the book shops just up the road. Some paid parking spots along the road, but also free parking just off the main road. There is a generously large parking lot behind the shops closer to the main intersection – just a few minutes walk from this place.
… moreJyoti Makhijani
We checked out Brine Barrel today and had a great experience. We had a rather complicated and large order but the owner was really attentive and friendly. The subs were very fresh tasting but the highlight was certainly the pickles. We tried both the dill and sour pickles – personally I was a dill pickle fan but both were so good. I recommend giving them a try!
P.S. unfortunately no pictures since we gobnled the food quickly
… moreSissi Lu
Me and my friend were so pleasantly surprised by this sandwich shop in Saugerties! The photos don’t do the sandwich justice. Everything is so fresh, cut and assembled right in front of us by the owner We wish that we got a few more to go for the rest of our drive!
… moreJason Bover
Brine Barrel special $15.
He made sure to tell me this sandwich is 2 sandwiches in 1. Got half way thru when I realized he forgot my onion, hot peppers, and vinegar. He also forgot my pickle which I asked for on the way out the door and is included with every sandwich. The place is empty and non inspiring. You really need to be on your game for a $15 sandwich in an empty store with no customers. With all that being said this sandwich was excellent but you pay for it. If this is a double I’m scared to see a single ✌️
***found 2 banana pepper rings in the last bite
… moreHeather Gleason
Brine Barrel a must try. Park right in front of the shop. Matt is really nice. He keeps busy makin those sandwiches!! The sandwiches are top noche!! Highest quality meats and cheeses. The pickles and olives are amazing , half sours are my favorite. Matt the owner also has Sweet hot Horsradish which tastes amazing on homemade Burgers!! I drive 45 minutes to eat lunch at this place when I can. I usually get the Pastrami on Rye, with swiss and thousand island dressing lightly toasted. Ohhh man it is to die for!! Matt also has a menu filled with specialty sandwiches. Including the old world. The old World is my husbands favorite!! The italian sub is both my daughters favorites and he makes a mean plain Bolgna and cheese sandwich for my little guy 5yrs old. He doesn’t skimp on the meats. Garlic Stuffed olives and olive Tapenade a kind of Olive salad that is great on a lot of things including plain ritz crackers. When ever we host parties or picnics we get party platters from Brine Barrel including the Pickle/ Olive platters!! The Pickles EVERYONE LOVES!! Gotta try Brine Barrel if you are in the area. Check out the website for dates and times the shop is open. Seasonal hours and dates change. Just go!!!
… moreRache Mendez
What a charming place, with delicious food, that felt like it was from the past! I got subs, and three containers of fresh pickles. Great homemade pickles (I got the dill, the sour, and the sweet horseradish). Extremely fresh sub sandwiches on delicious non-squishy bread. Felt like a blast from the past, in a good way!
… moreMicky
Best sandwiches in town! The owner is a nice man who makes one hell of a sandwich. 10/10 definitely recommend 🙂
… moreBulut Calisir
We were in town for the weekend & found this shop on google maps – Popped in and tried Old world and Pastrami sandwich and both were amazing. Great sandwiches and pickles!
… moreNivetha Saravanan
Delicious subs, pickles, and potato salad.
Price per person: …
… moreJillian Purdy
such a cute little shop! very friendly man working i presume was the owner. slices the meats and makes the sandwich right there, kinda cool to see lol. good prices, delicious pickles. i got “the godfather” sub and i HORKED IT DOWN. i am normally a slow eater but it was so good! excellent ratio of meat & other ingredients to the amount of bread. only in town for a bit but plan on returning before i leave! YUM!
… more