Jo Kur
I tried May’s bakery in AP for the 1st time this month. I was getting a cake for my great nephew 15th birthday, he wanted a yellow cake with fresh fruit filling. It was 4 layers with fresh fruit between each layer and fresh fruit on the top. He said it was the best cake he ever had. In fact his father text me and said “That cake was INSANELY GOOD “.Followed by a picture showing it was almost gone.
I will definitely be returning to purchase future cakes.
… morejanindu samaraweera
If I can give 10 stars, I will give 10 stars all day. We got a cake for my daughter’s birthday. It was just like we wanted and on top of that the cake was soooo delicious. The best cake I had in my whole life. It was a butter cake with butter filling. Cake was so moist
Everybody loved the cake and it was done within minutes
Highly recommend them for cakes
… moreAlexis McGuffin
My husband got my birthday cake here made to surprise me and it’s SO beautiful. Not only does it look amazing, the cake flavor tastes So good. The cake has a really good texture and isn’t dry! Cheetah is my favorite print and they made it happen
… moreRae Monroe
OMG the cake was amazing. The flavor was amazing. The taste was amazing. The cake melted in my mouth. It taste so good. May made my son’s 12th cake. It was a soccer thing. It was so beautiful. I sent you an image of what I wanted The cake to look like the cake look exactly like the image I sent her. It was perfect. I will be coming to her for all of my cakes.
… moreAnn Marie
Color of the writing is wrong. I am very unhappy. This cake was to celebrate a heavenly bday for my beloved Mother who passed away from ovarian cancer. I personally went into the bakery to order it many weeks in advance. I was specific about the color for the writing. To the point i spoke to the lady at the counter AND the owner who came out of the back. I googled photos and showed her the ribbon color. Its supposed to be aqua. She made it green. Like st pattys day green. I said it was the wrong color when i picked it up and the lady at the counter said “i think it looks beautiful” well thats nice for her, but my Grandma didn’t like it at all. I prepaid for the cake and wish i hadn’t because i wouldn’t have paid for it at pick up. I don’t understand how they can mess up the most important detail of the cake and tell you THEY think its fine. I won’t go back. My Grams don’t even want a piece of this cake. I’m sad. Real sad.
… moreApril Garner
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The cupcakes were absolutely delicious! Each one was moist, flavorful, and beautifully made — not too sweet, just perfectly balanced. You can truly taste the quality and care that went into every bite.
The service was just as impressive. From start to finish, everything was handled with professionalism, kindness, and great attention to detail. Communication was smooth, and the entire experience felt effortless.
I highly recommend them and will definitely be ordering again! ✨
… moreMona E
I ordered a cake from them with only 4 days notice and they made it happen for me! The cake was delicious and moist, everyone at the birthday party was asking me where i got it from. They were also very kind and accomodating, I would definitely order again!
… moreKatie
I absolutely love May’s bakery (formerly sweet tooth). The previous bakery was always the family go-to for every family function! I’m so happy that May’s uses their recipe and reopened! I had my baby shower over the weekend. We ordered cupcakes and a cake! It turned out beautiful and delicious!!!! I can’t thank them enough.
… moreCarlton Devot
I wanted to try doing a custom cake for a birthday. This bakery went above and beyond for me. They took me step by step through the ordering process. I provided a photo for example. When the day came to pickup the cake I was left in awe. It was too beautiful to eat, let alone cut open. They masterfully carried out the task and exceeded my expectations. I will always do custom cakes with them moving forward 10/10 highly recommend
… moreDaniel Brown
We were at a bitlrthday party and ate cake, we were blown away by not only the design and look of the cake, but the flavor… fast forward a few weeks and we needed a cake for my son’s 5th Birthday. May’s KNOCKED IT OUT OF THE PARK! My wife dropped off a few decorations for the cake, and they took it from there. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!
… more