Since 1991, Pizza Brothers has been serving New Jersey with fresh, delicious food. What began as a single family-owned pizzeria has grown to six locations, all rooted in the same principles: quality ingredients, careful preparation, and genuine hospitality. We continue to make everything the way it should be — fresh, consistent, and crafted with care.
Branch of a local chain offering pies, hot & cold subs & Italian entrees for eat-in or delivery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1982 Washington Valley Rd, Martinsville, NJ 08836
Phone: (732) 469-6611
Website: http://www.mypizzabrothers.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Pizza Brothers | Family Owned Pizzeria in NJ Since 1991
Pizza Brothers has been serving New Jersey since 1991. What started as a single family-owned pizzeria has grown into six locations, all built on the same …
Pizza Brothers Martinsville – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Pizza Brothers Martinsville · Pizza Brothers Martinsville – View Menu & Order Online – 1982 Washington Valley Rd, Martinsville, NJ 08836 – Slice.
NJ Pizza Brothers | Martinsville NJ – Facebook
Pizza Brothers is a New Jersey family owned pizza restaurant serving the Somerset Hills area since 1991. Serving pizza, subs, pasta dinners, appetizers, and …
Reviews
Alexander Mizeu
Cool..! I ordered pizza here on Sunday
September 17, 2023 for the first time. What can I say: 1. The pizza was delicious.
Fried bacon, cheese, mushrooms, cheese and tomato, plus onions. I ordered a large pizza. 2. The price is also absolutely reasonable and corresponds to the market price. 3. The service and attitude of the staff, including a guy named Grant, was great! They offered me different pizza options and gave me good advice. 4. Overall I had a good to excellent experience ordering pizza here.
Second time I ordered pizza here January 27, 2024. I also ordered a pizza with extra bacon onion pineapples. And it was great. It was very tasty.
… moreSeptember 17, 2023 for the first time. What can I say: 1. The pizza was delicious.
Fried bacon, cheese, mushrooms, cheese and tomato, plus onions. I ordered a large pizza. 2. The price is also absolutely reasonable and corresponds to the market price. 3. The service and attitude of the staff, including a guy named Grant, was great! They offered me different pizza options and gave me good advice. 4. Overall I had a good to excellent experience ordering pizza here.
Second time I ordered pizza here January 27, 2024. I also ordered a pizza with extra bacon onion pineapples. And it was great. It was very tasty.
Greg Friedman
Average pizza but didn’t live up to my expectations for NJ. I am traveling for work and got a pizza through Uber eats. It showed up on time but the pizza and topics were basic. The crust lacked flavor and the consistency I expect for NJ pizza. I had no desire to eat the crust at all. The rest of the toppings and sauce also just lacked seasoning and flavor. It was just ok at best. I wasn’t compelled to eat more. My pizza place in Raleigh NC much better.
… moreCody Obropta
I’ve been to several Pizza Brothers locations in my hunt for good pizza and have never been disappointed. This spot has the same cripsy, thin base that cracks when you fold it but still maintains a good structure. The sauce and cheese are excellent and the crust is bready and delicious. The peppers and onions were clearly fresh and tasted great. I would definitely recommend Pizza Brothers.
-@BoroPizzaHunter on Instagram.
… more-@BoroPizzaHunter on Instagram.
Ken Jinks
EDIT: The owner of the pizzeria reached out to me and worked with me to fix the problem – they were diligent in providing quality food which I was glad to see. Will continue ordering here every week.
Original Review: I used to order from Pizza Brothers every week. Over the last 2-3 weeks they must have changed their recipe – the pizza crust/dough literally tastes and smells like mildew and the entire pizza is different. Maybe a new cook but it’s terrible – will have to find a new regular pizzeria unfortunately.
… moreOriginal Review: I used to order from Pizza Brothers every week. Over the last 2-3 weeks they must have changed their recipe – the pizza crust/dough literally tastes and smells like mildew and the entire pizza is different. Maybe a new cook but it’s terrible – will have to find a new regular pizzeria unfortunately.
Joan Carrino
Got a chicken parm dinner. Apparently they put the spaghetti in the same container as the chicken when they melted the cheese so the spaghetti was totally overdone. Way too soft. The chicken cutlet look like it was from frozen dinner it was not great. And yet they charge $17 for this monstrosity. I called to complain and of course the guy on the other end could barely speak English and couldn’t give a rat’s behind either way. Never apologize about it. Apparently this place is going downhill
… moreRobin Cusumano
Best pepperoni garlic Sicilian pie I have ever had!
… morePaul Richard
They are usually on point with the service they provide and the pizza they make. I called and ordered a well done plain pie ahead of time for pick up.. when I arrived, it quickly became apparent that they forgot about me.. meanwhile, they have an entire fresh pie that just came out of the oven, and instead of offering me the pie, they cut it up for two slices for a different customer and made me wait 20+ minutes to make what they forgot! I will say that I frequent this shop and will continue to do so but I hope you take this criticism and make adjustments if that should ever happen again. Your pizza Is cromulent
… moreTanvi Gohel
What to say about the pizza at Martinsville – I have ordered 2 times in 2 months and both times I ordered Margherita and it looks different both times- first time slight different than what other stores or even in Italy ,the restaurant serve margherita. Second time it was a layer of cheese and hardly any sauce. I like cheese but not the way it was on pizza that we ordered.
Also I have ordered from Bernardsville pizza brothers and their Margherita looks different than Martinsville store.
They say that we all are same store. Not sure what happened here. But I will think twice now to order the margherita here at Martinsville which is kind of sad as we only like Margherita pizza.
… moreAlso I have ordered from Bernardsville pizza brothers and their Margherita looks different than Martinsville store.
They say that we all are same store. Not sure what happened here. But I will think twice now to order the margherita here at Martinsville which is kind of sad as we only like Margherita pizza.
Anonymous Person
Tastes and feels like cardboard.
Don’t order from here. …
… moreDon’t order from here. …
judy lopes
Cari is your greatest asset! She understands what excellent service means. Today I ordered the Cobb salad unfortunately the lettuce was half frozen and wilted had to discard all. This week I had spaghetti side and it was very good. We need fresh salads! Ty
… more