Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1201 Sycamore Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 07724
Phone: (732) 542-2700
Website: https://tasteofitalymarket.com/tasteofitaly1201?utm_source=google
Related Web Results
Taste of Italy | Best Italian food in Tinton Falls, NJ | Italian food near me
Your Home for Authentic Italian Cuisine! If you’re looking for fresh, homemade Italian food, visit Jimmy Pecci’s Taste of Italy! With two locations in Tinton …
Jimmy Pecci’s Taste Of Italy (@JimmyPeccisTasteOfItaly) – Facebook
Yusby Mendez-Pecci is in Tinton Falls, NJ. Nov 30, 2025 . ✨ Buon … Taste of Italy | Best Italian food in Tinton Falls, NJ | Italian food near me.
Jimmy Pecci Taste Of Italy (@tasteofitalymarket) – Instagram
851 followers · 223 posts · 2 locations in Tinton Falls | 4060 Asbury Ave | (732)922.9393 | 1201 Sycamore Ave | (732)542.2700 |
Reviews
Valerie Tucker
Today I came in for the first time with my mom, the guy behind the counter was nice and he suggested some items and said everything was great. I said I needed a second to figure out what I was going to get, I ended up going with a a chicken roasted pepper and spinach sandwich with extra provolone.
The service was great and the sandwnich was absolutely fantastic. I have a super sensitive stomach so im hesitant with new places but im glad i tried this place!
It tasted fresh, all of the ingredients are top tier. Their cheese is very strong so you know it’s good quality. Their bread roll was soft and fresh. The store smelled so good. It is a little pricey but honestly it’s so good it’s worth it. The quality of the food is INSANE.
I’m gonna come back and try a variety of items like the vodka lasagna , potato salad and a variety of other items next time I come in.
… moreThe service was great and the sandwnich was absolutely fantastic. I have a super sensitive stomach so im hesitant with new places but im glad i tried this place!
It tasted fresh, all of the ingredients are top tier. Their cheese is very strong so you know it’s good quality. Their bread roll was soft and fresh. The store smelled so good. It is a little pricey but honestly it’s so good it’s worth it. The quality of the food is INSANE.
I’m gonna come back and try a variety of items like the vodka lasagna , potato salad and a variety of other items next time I come in.
Nicholas Gkionis
Small little italian shop in a plaza in Tinton Falls. All your typical fare on the counter. I went with the eggplant parm and just an fyi the eggplant is made with egg and flour not bread crumbs. Always give it mushy when they do it that way. They also warm it up in the microwave in a plastic container which makes it worse. The chicken cutlets were good though. Not sure I am dying to come back since there are many of these types of places in the area but wouldn’t be upset if I did.
… moreBruce Mazzarelli
Stopped in to grab a sandwich, I ate half in my car and it was so good I literally went back in to tell them! Fantastic bread, great provolone, and loaded with delicious meat. I will be back!
… moreAfterhours Fabrication
We had a great time here, it was truly a taste of Italy. The food was excellent and the staff were very accommodating, thanks for a good lunch guys
… morePatrick McEvoy
The food. The menu. The cheese. The desserts. The bread. The Pasta. The chicken. Employees are the best! They know you there like you’re family. Support local businesses!
… moreBonnie Nadolny
Delicious food and great atmosphere! We sat down to eat and felt very comfortable. The staff was fabulous! Bob and Bonnie from NY
… moreRita Kondoleon
Ordered a sub on the app. It was ready to go on time. Taste of Italy is our “go to place” for subs. Their bread is delicious and the quality is superbe.
… morePaul
The service is excellent. The food is reheated, but the quality is a notch above other takeout deli’s. This is not a usual deli. This is above the usual fanfare. The food is bursting with flavor. They have a few tables outside, but you should consider it a “to go” place.
… moreKristina Gradzki
Buffalo chicken wrap was a big portion and pressed for an added crunch. Not too spicy and great as-is with the blue cheese dressing.
… moreJan Waple
I love the food at Jimmy Pecci’s. His staff are like friends and shop at the two stores at least twice a week. Never disappoints, always delicious!
… more