Michaleno’s pizzeria is family owned and operated. Mike and Debbie Herbert, along with our four sons (Mike, Ryan, Greg and Daniel). This was our dream, to open a restaurant run by the family. We have brought on other family members and friends to ensure the best customer service. We have been serving Kewaskum, Saukville, West Bend, and the surrounding areas since 2008. We appreciate your continued patronage, and if you have not tried us before we hope to see you soon. We look forward to having the opportunity of serving you. Call ahead or just stop in and give us a try
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 234 E Dekora St, Saukville, WI 53080
Phone: (262) 235-4842
Website: http://michalenos.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Michaleno’s Pizzeria: Home
Michaleno’s pizzeria is family owned and operated. Mike and Debbie Herbert … Saukville, WI 53080 · (262) 235-4842 · Order Now. Powered by Menufy © 2026.
Michaleno’s Pizzeria West Bend, Kewaskum, and Saukville
Michaleno’s Pizzeria West Bend, Kewaskum, and Saukville, West Bend. 226 likes … Great Pizza – Review of Michaleno’s Pizzeria, West Bend, WI – Tripadvisor.
Michaleno’s Pizzeria – Saukville – Restaurant.com
Michaleno’s Pizzeria – Saukville. Pizza, Italian. 5. $. Localization. 234 E Dekora St , Saukville WI, 53080. Michaleno’s pizzeria is proud to be a family owned …
Last Updates
Reviews
Paul
This was our first visit. They only have carryout at this location. The staff and owner were very friendly. The food was ready on time.
When we arrived at home we dug right in and the food was fantastic. The pizza was cooked perfectly, as was the canzone! The Italian sub sandwich was very good, but I would have liked a little more red sauce. That’s just me and I will order it next time.
We will be ordering again.
If you are looking for quality Italian food at a very affordable price, order from Michaleno’s!
… moreWhen we arrived at home we dug right in and the food was fantastic. The pizza was cooked perfectly, as was the canzone! The Italian sub sandwich was very good, but I would have liked a little more red sauce. That’s just me and I will order it next time.
We will be ordering again.
If you are looking for quality Italian food at a very affordable price, order from Michaleno’s!
Toby Tarrant
My favorite Italian to date and you can’t even go in and sit down. These guys are not fooling around. Gourmet ravioli is just that. Perfect al dente, fresh and abundant mozzarella. Deep flavor from the sauce. I also tried the lasagna and I will definitely relive that experience once my love affair w the ravioli takes its course. Any of their pizzas won’t miss either.
… moreJanice Stadler
You were the only business that would accept online orders Saturday night and the food was amazing. Even better you said delivery time between 9:00 p.m. to 9:15 p.m. delivery person was there at 8:30 p.m. wow!!! Definitely will be ordering again thank you!
… moreBen Sobotta
This was our first time trying this place for pizza and we were not impressed. We order the specialty chicken Sicilian as seen below, we were quit confused when we opened the box the see what appear to be canned green beans… which they were not of course but I was taught to eat with my eyes and this through me off a bit. We added onions to this same pizza and at first glance you can’t distinguish onion from chicken chunk, same bland white color and taste. This pizza was surprisingly okay, my first impression of the it set me back but the flavor was okay the garlic Parmesan was good chicken was bland and as my wife said “ it looks like they just through the onions on, they didn’t even give them time to cook.” Not my number one choice. Pizza 2 cheese pepperoni and sausage, nothing fancy, was also okay. Sauce was good I liked how it wasn’t too sweet. Crust was a good mixture of crisp bottom with a pillowy edge crust. To me there was nothing that stood out or spoke to me about these pizzas, think it’s good for a late dinner when you get back from up north and the kids are hangry on a Sunday night.
… moreDebbie Retzer
Again food arrived on time and pizza was hot and cold food was cold- I SO appreciate it when restaurants make the effort to get our food to us at the proper temperature, so thank you thank you!! We really enjoyed the pizza- have not had pizza in a while because we have limited choice of who will deliver to our house. So glad to have found you!
… moreTom Wellnitz
The first time I tried Michelano’s Pizzeria in Saukville was shortly after they opened. I thought that the pizza was good but nothing special.
However, the second time I ordered their 16” Deluxe pizza, I was hooked! It was loaded with toppings, the thin crust was excellent and the premium mozzarella cheese was gooey, and not burned, like at a lot of other pizza places.
Since then, I’ve probably had five or six other pizzas and I’ve never been disappointed. I weighed my last 16” Deluxe pizza on my kitchen scale and it weighed a full 30 ounces, most of which consisted of cheese and six meat and vegetable toppings.
The pizza cost was $22.50 and it was well worth it. If you have any leftovers, scrape off the cheese and other toppings, and make a pizza omelet! Fast, simple, delicious and nutritious.
And when they say “20 minutes” they mean 20 minutes. I’ve yet to have had to wait for my order. They’ve always been fast and efficient.
Once you’re hooked like I am, you’ll want to get Michelano’s punch card – buy 10, get one free!
… moreHowever, the second time I ordered their 16” Deluxe pizza, I was hooked! It was loaded with toppings, the thin crust was excellent and the premium mozzarella cheese was gooey, and not burned, like at a lot of other pizza places.
Since then, I’ve probably had five or six other pizzas and I’ve never been disappointed. I weighed my last 16” Deluxe pizza on my kitchen scale and it weighed a full 30 ounces, most of which consisted of cheese and six meat and vegetable toppings.
The pizza cost was $22.50 and it was well worth it. If you have any leftovers, scrape off the cheese and other toppings, and make a pizza omelet! Fast, simple, delicious and nutritious.
And when they say “20 minutes” they mean 20 minutes. I’ve yet to have had to wait for my order. They’ve always been fast and efficient.
Once you’re hooked like I am, you’ll want to get Michelano’s punch card – buy 10, get one free!
Shannon Matthews
Gross! The picture is not fries…their wings. The calzone sauce tastes like expired burnt basil. I had to spit it out. The spicey wings are bland and very dry. Tried the 4 appetizer. Mozzerella sticks are not great, the fried mushrooms are very wet and uncrunchy, the spinach artichoke was okay and the fish bites were good. Raspberry cheesecake were good. Never again though.
… moreBrian Fisher
An interesting place. I ordered a meat lovers pizza and a side of mozzarella sticks. Didn’t check the pricing but it was 34.99 out the door
At first felt a bit sticker shocked. I wish I knew what the mozz sticks cost on their own because they were so so. Well cooked but I think they were made from frozen in a bag. I’d definitely pass on those next time.
On to the pizza…The meat lovers is absolutely loaded with meat. Good sauce. The crust was interesting, something in between a cracker crust and a tossed crust. Nicely done although I wish it was in the oven maybe a minute or two longer.
The guy who took my order and gave me my food was super friendly and no complaints there for sure.
I’m still unsure if it’s worth the value but they did well enough to make me want to try more items on the menu. I think the only reason I can’t give five stars is because of the value proposition.
… moreAt first felt a bit sticker shocked. I wish I knew what the mozz sticks cost on their own because they were so so. Well cooked but I think they were made from frozen in a bag. I’d definitely pass on those next time.
On to the pizza…The meat lovers is absolutely loaded with meat. Good sauce. The crust was interesting, something in between a cracker crust and a tossed crust. Nicely done although I wish it was in the oven maybe a minute or two longer.
The guy who took my order and gave me my food was super friendly and no complaints there for sure.
I’m still unsure if it’s worth the value but they did well enough to make me want to try more items on the menu. I think the only reason I can’t give five stars is because of the value proposition.
Michael Schell
Best Pizza in ozaukee co. Mike on Montgomery st. And very friendly people .
… moreTroy Petroske
I had the Italian Sausage patty sub w/fries and an order of Onion Rings.
1st the positives.
Very nice and pleasant younger man at the counter to deal with (reason for 2 stars) and the onion rings are breaded and thick cut.
2nd the bad parts.
The Onion Rings were both 70% crispy and 30% oily this usually happens in my experience when the oil is either not up to temp or is a bit older and needs to be changed soon. I ate these in my vehicle on the way home. So they were pretty much right out of the fryer and me eating them within 3 minutes. The fries where the same way, just not as hot as I waited to get home to eat them. (15min drive)
The worst part of this was the Italian Sausage patty sub. Most pizza or Italian places use the sausage from the pizzas to make this type of sandwich. This place uses a pre made frozen oblong shaped patty. Almost like a McRib but of very plain and bland tasting Italian Sausage. I have never tried the pizza and I will be giving this establishment another go at it from a pizza perspective. I hope they use real ground Italian Sausage on the pizza and not frozen sausage bits like the chain pizza places use. EX: Dominos, Pizza Hut, PaPa Johns etc….
… more1st the positives.
Very nice and pleasant younger man at the counter to deal with (reason for 2 stars) and the onion rings are breaded and thick cut.
2nd the bad parts.
The Onion Rings were both 70% crispy and 30% oily this usually happens in my experience when the oil is either not up to temp or is a bit older and needs to be changed soon. I ate these in my vehicle on the way home. So they were pretty much right out of the fryer and me eating them within 3 minutes. The fries where the same way, just not as hot as I waited to get home to eat them. (15min drive)
The worst part of this was the Italian Sausage patty sub. Most pizza or Italian places use the sausage from the pizzas to make this type of sandwich. This place uses a pre made frozen oblong shaped patty. Almost like a McRib but of very plain and bland tasting Italian Sausage. I have never tried the pizza and I will be giving this establishment another go at it from a pizza perspective. I hope they use real ground Italian Sausage on the pizza and not frozen sausage bits like the chain pizza places use. EX: Dominos, Pizza Hut, PaPa Johns etc….