Monica Sterk Kurek
We hosted our twins’ 5th birthday party at the O’Grady Castle and I couldn’t be happy with our decision. The space was perfect, the staff was so kind and accommodating, and the food was very good. It was a fantastic experience and I would recommend this venue for anyone looking for a place to host a party of any kind!
… moreGianni DD
We went here for the first time because they had a Beef Wellington special that my lady really wanted. Initially we couldn’t find the entrance so we walked all around and finally found the bar dining area. The place was nice but had a more of a sports bar feeling than a sit down restaurant feeling. The bartender was our waiter and was great! Excellent service… tho there weren’t many people in the place. We got the Welly and the French onion burger. She was asked a temp and said Med Rare. I ordered the burger Med. Hers came Medium and mine Med well. Flavors were good but the burger wasn’t very warm. Her wine was good and my Black Velvet Pint was good too. Not sure we’d go back for specials as the Welly was $38 but maybe to try some other things on the menu now that we know what the place is.
… moreBruce Budkofsky
We had our high school reunion at the Castle last night (9/13/2025). What a great night we had! Michelle was extremely helpful in guiding us on the menu and the space for our event. Debbie was a great host, Sarah a great server, and Joe an outstanding bartender in the Speakeasy bar. The second floor layout was perfect for our group of 85, with plenty of space to mingle, sit and eat, or dance. It was very comfortable with the DJ and photo booth in their places of the room. They were extremely accommodating and willing to stay open for us for as long as our party wanted to go on. I highly recommend this venue and staff for any event you plan. We’ll definitely be back for another reunion and I wouldn’t hesitate to plan another party or event at O’Grady’s Castle.
… moreMargaret Brauer
We just had my baby shower of 90 women here and it was Fabulous! The food was delish, the staff was friendly and on top of everything & the room was so beautifully decorated for the holidays! My mom said everyone was so accommodating from the start of booking the party, to picking the menu and so on! Thank you so much Michelle and Bridget for such a beautiful day!
… moreDDelilahM
We had our wedding reception here and it was absolutely perfect. The food, the atmosphere and the staff were wonderful and it really brought my vision alive for my wedding… the price was good too!
… moreBrian Scherer
Went for lunch with my kids, all the food was great. Oscar our server was excellent and attentive. Beautiful views. Easy to locate, look for the castle on blue hill road!
… moreLauren Fox
We just had our son’s first birthday party here. Everything was wonderful! The staff was amazing and really friendly. Fiona was professional, accommodating and so easy to work with. We will definitely go back soon!
… moreMonika T
The menu is similar to any bar in Pearl River. Nothing special about the food. Nice location with nice views. Service is fair to poor. Their taco specials aren’t great, small portions. They really should consider changes to their menu to make the food more appealing.
… moreBrian Miller
I like my burgers almost raw and most places won’t do that for you,However I order my burger almost raw with blue cheese and bacon and they nailed it,probably one of the best burgers I’ve had in a long time,Already been back for a second,and again perfect,this time I met the chef,because I said I was here a couple of days ago and ordered the same pretty much raw burger and it was perfect so the chef came out to meet me,told him to keep up the good work a keep your customers happy the way they like it.My wife and I will be going on a Monday nite to try the prime rib special,more to come.ENJOY
… moreshawnessy fitzpatrick
Weather you just want to hang out with some friends at the bar, or bring your family to dinner. You can’t go wrong at O’Grady’s Castle. Great place to have your next event. The bar tenders and Staff are great!
… more