Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4189 Manchester Ave, St. Louis, MO 63110
Phone: (314) 899-0444
Website: https://pieguystl.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pie Guy Pizza
Hand-tossed New York style pizza in The Grove, St. Louis. By the slice, or get a whole pie! Open late-night.
Pie guy closed : r/StLouis – Reddit
That’s disappointing, loved their pies. Two very good pizza joints shuttered in the last few months that I liked, Pie Guy & Hot Pizza Cold Beer.
Pie Guy Pizza (@pieguystl) · St. Louis, MO – Instagram
Hand Tossed Sourdough NY & Detroit Style St. Louis, Missouri – The Grove Call or text 314-920-6451 to place order.
Reviews
Kay L
Best pizza ive ever had my husband and I love going here to get our favorite pepperoni and roasted garlic with a salad.
My only criticism stems from the fact that they are never open. Ive tried so many times to get my favorite pizza and today being my only day off ive planned everything with rewarding myself and husband with our favorite pie. So I drove and after the gym and the doors are locked, ive called, and tried to order online and nothing worked. This is not the first time this has been our experience.
I understand that they are going through a hard time so I give you all the grace I can muster. Being loyal a loyal customer I would love to support you and the business. I would hate for such a wonderful business to disappear but I need a little help in that support. Please give me, if you can, the operating hours so me and every one of my friends, that I won’t shut up to when discussing pizza, can come and experience the greatness of your business.
Thanks and I hope to see you soon.
… moreMy only criticism stems from the fact that they are never open. Ive tried so many times to get my favorite pizza and today being my only day off ive planned everything with rewarding myself and husband with our favorite pie. So I drove and after the gym and the doors are locked, ive called, and tried to order online and nothing worked. This is not the first time this has been our experience.
I understand that they are going through a hard time so I give you all the grace I can muster. Being loyal a loyal customer I would love to support you and the business. I would hate for such a wonderful business to disappear but I need a little help in that support. Please give me, if you can, the operating hours so me and every one of my friends, that I won’t shut up to when discussing pizza, can come and experience the greatness of your business.
Thanks and I hope to see you soon.
Mike Mclaughlin
Ordered a pepperoni and pineapple pizza and enjoyed it. The crust was crispy, and the flavor was good.
The staff is friendly and helpful.
The only negative was that the pie was overly greasy for my taste.
EDITED TO ADD: There was a double charge to my card that was caught by the restaurant and refunded. Thank you for catching that.
… moreThe staff is friendly and helpful.
The only negative was that the pie was overly greasy for my taste.
EDITED TO ADD: There was a double charge to my card that was caught by the restaurant and refunded. Thank you for catching that.
Joshua D
I’m torn because this place truly has amazing pizza, but the business operations are a total mess. We tried to order for pickup after a SLU game on the 7th. The online ordering process is confusing with too many redundant platforms, and the wait times are extreme—even 5 minutes after opening, the ‘custom’ wait was 90 minutes.
We settled for a ‘standard’ topping order to get it in 45 minutes. Despite receiving a text saying it was ready, I went inside to find an employee goofing off with a friend. He hadn’t checked for the order, couldn’t find it, and then couldn’t find his phone to look it up. When I asked for a refund, he couldn’t find his phone for that either, nor a pen and paper to take my name.
We used to love getting this at City SC games until they stopped showing up there. Great pizza isn’t worth this level of unprofessionalism. Hard to justify going back.
… moreWe settled for a ‘standard’ topping order to get it in 45 minutes. Despite receiving a text saying it was ready, I went inside to find an employee goofing off with a friend. He hadn’t checked for the order, couldn’t find it, and then couldn’t find his phone to look it up. When I asked for a refund, he couldn’t find his phone for that either, nor a pen and paper to take my name.
We used to love getting this at City SC games until they stopped showing up there. Great pizza isn’t worth this level of unprofessionalism. Hard to justify going back.
Greg James
Best Pizza I’ve had in had, lived in Vegas, LA, Tampa. Missouri might not offer much exciting but this Pie Guy joint will be one I miss when I move! Great everything!
… moreSierra
I’ll start off with saying that this is a great pizza joint. I am typically very satisfied, but this time not so much.. I feel I am being very generous giving 4 stars after I got this pizza delivered.
It looks like it was sitting in a heating window for too long. It could also be that the driver took a long time to deliver, too, as I’m pretty sure they partner with door dash or someone else of that degree. That’s likely while it was lukewarm at best when I got it. The pizza tasted “just ok.”
… moreIt looks like it was sitting in a heating window for too long. It could also be that the driver took a long time to deliver, too, as I’m pretty sure they partner with door dash or someone else of that degree. That’s likely while it was lukewarm at best when I got it. The pizza tasted “just ok.”
Sweetteeness
Loved it !!!! Reminded me of New York style pizza. Thin , crispy crust with just the right amount of everything . We put leftovers in the oven and they baked up perfectly. We plan to go again. Great neighborhood and it was attached to a great beer pub (name in the photos ) that offered small glasses at a great price… we tried a pineapple and a pink guava … both were great ♥️
… moreOctavia Thomas
I visited this restaurant for the first time on April 6, 2025. Brandon took my order and was very polite. He handled the heavy crowd with ease as well. The one veggie slice ($6) and 6 garlic Parmesan wings ($14 – $1 for garlic parm -no fries) was very filling. They do not toss the wings in the sauce. That was perfect because then I can put on exactly how much I want. The Sangria ($) was poured perfectly.
Heads up – there are several taxes on the bill. There is a St. Louis City Tax, MO Tax and Grove Tax. It didn’t look to be a charge for using my card.
I will definitely be back.
… moreHeads up – there are several taxes on the bill. There is a St. Louis City Tax, MO Tax and Grove Tax. It didn’t look to be a charge for using my card.
I will definitely be back.
Heather Fielder
Cool vibes and delicious pizza by the slice.
My son loved the classic cheese slice and I enjoyed the veggie slice. The polite guy who served us said the veggies change daily. Today was spinach, mushroom and sun dried tomato
… moreMy son loved the classic cheese slice and I enjoyed the veggie slice. The polite guy who served us said the veggies change daily. Today was spinach, mushroom and sun dried tomato
Caitlin Freund
Been coming next door for a little now but never had the pleasure of getting to try this fantastic pizza! I finally visited last night and everything was on point! I love the little late night door window and sign all the best vibe. Happy to see them open on Tuesday’s. Chefs kiss !
… moreChris Hammiel
Just ate here with my wife. Friend of ours gave us this recommendation and it did NOT disappoint. We had the green pepper and bacon pizza as well as the garlic knots. All I can say is—WOW! We also had red red hot honey and a chocolate chip cookie. Again—wow! The service,
especially the lady whom greeted us, we ALL very friendly. Connected to this place is a cool place to hang and order many, many different types of beers and wine. All in all truly wonderful meal. Oh!!! And that allow dogs! #bonus We’ll definitely be back!!
… moreespecially the lady whom greeted us, we ALL very friendly. Connected to this place is a cool place to hang and order many, many different types of beers and wine. All in all truly wonderful meal. Oh!!! And that allow dogs! #bonus We’ll definitely be back!!