Connie White
Wow blew me and my family away! Home made fresh and good quality made with expensive ingredients not cheap ingredients and made with love ❤️! She a very small business like ne i have a very small nail salon on greentree rd called polish me pretty.Iam so excited to support her. please just try her baked goods you will know what iam talking about. She just earned a life time customer. Her cookies are so fresh they melt in your mouth like butter. ty and excited to place my nexted order.
… moreTiffany Ivery
I’ve been here multiple times and love everything I get! My favorite is the sugar butter cookie! They are so delicious. I’ve also ordered peanut butter blossoms for wedding cookie tables before, and they are perfect! The cupcakes and pepperoni rolls are so good too!
… moreCassidy Gerhardt
Sooo good! The cinnamon rolls, banana bread and sweets are amazing.
… moreNichole W
I love this bakery!! Ang and her family are so wonderful. They are welcoming as soon as you walk in the door. She has made several cakes, cookies and cupcakes for my boys birthdays they are always outstanding and exactly what I need. Her M&M cookies are by far my favorite cookies, and her tiramisu is to die for!
… moreAlly T
Angie is the most amazing person & baker I have ever met. I am beyond happy with the cupcakes and cake she made for my wedding. We received so many compliments about how beautiful everything was and ever more compliments about how delicious it all was. I will forever suggest this bakery to all my friends and family. Thank you sugar butter bakery!
… moreChase E
This is just the cutest little bakery, everything was so delicious and sooo affordable I couldn’t believe it. Can’t recommend enough. staff are so sweet and welcoming they definitely made my morning.
… moreArlene Murphy
Run, don’t walk to this made from scratch fresh bakery in Carnegie. They have a good variation of products ranging from pepperoni rolls, strawberry pretzel salad, quick breads such as pumpkin or banana chocolate chip, as well as cookies, cupcakes including Hostess style, danishes and even coffee. They have reduced prices on day old items.
Everything is take out and very reasonably priced. Since refrigerated items are baked fresh without preservatives they do have a short shelf life. Found myself getting the cinnamon coffee cake muffin-literally one of the best coffee cakes I had in a long time.
They do handle special orders if you call ahead. For the best selection it pays to arrive early. They do have extended hours on Fridays and Sats until 4.
Am very pleased with my purchases and looking forward to visiting them again in the near future.
… moreConnor Fleck
I’ve stopped into this bakery a few times over the last months, and wow! everything I’ve had has been fresh, delicious, and clearly made with real care. The woman who runs the shop is genuinely one of the sweetest, most welcoming people you’ll meet, and you can feel how much she appreciates every customer who walks in.
The prices are always incredibly reasonable, especially considering the quality. The only thing to keep in mind is that the hours can be a little limited — which I was reminded of the last time I had a craving for something sweet. I ended up stopping at Leo Greta instead and paid almost triple the price for a dessert that wasn’t even half as good as what you get at Sugar Butter Bakery.
If you want to support a truly wonderful local business, this is the place. You can tell there’s so much personal passion poured into everything she makes.
… moreChocobo Chica
Stopped in for some treats- the owner is lovely, & all the things I got were tasty! Lovrd the carrot cake cupcake & the oatmeal bars. Will definitely be back.
… moreTaylor White
Got my 30th birthday cake custom ordered. She did an amazing job and I got exactly what I asked for. The cake and cupcakes were beautiful and I got told nothing but amazing things about how it tasted from my party guests. It was delicious! Would absolutely support this business again!
… more