Larry Dorsch
Our waitress gets a five-star rating. She was pleasant, polite, patient, and arrived at the table on a timely basis throughout the meal. Our party of 4 each had a different entrée and all gave their meal a five-star rating. Who would have guessed that the chef could make butternut squash into a tasty side, but he did. The desserts were brought out on a tray for viewing which only made the selection process more difficult. They looked and tasted delicious. The cost for 4 dinners and 4 desserts with only water to drink was $297 + tip.
Street signage at the restaurant is not prominent so make sure you know where you are going. Parking is ample. The tables are widely spaced, but I suspect a loud group would be a problem for the other tables in the small dining rooms. Mobility challenged residents should check with the restaurant about access.
… moreJohn Farrar
Welp, my sister and brother-in-law have been talking about Andrew’s for months, coming from Chicago, and the food we typically get, I’m usually not impressed with food elsewhere.
I am taken back!
The environment, the atmosphere, the delicious old fashion, the wine, the filet!!! THE FILET!!!!
Literally the most tender, best tasting filet I think I’ve ever eaten!
Sad to say I was done several minutes than the rest of my table, and I had thoughts of just taking the rest of their fillets off their plates. I withheld knowing I’m soon receiving desert.
And my wait was well worth it!!!
You will love the dinner. Price is well worth the gift.
… moreMadelyn Holstein
Our group had such a wonderful experience tonight. Between the 6 of us, we ordered most of the menu items and there was nothing that did not taste superb. Service was great as well!
… moreJason Garner
This is my favorite restaurant hands down. I’m telling u, u have to go. That is the waiting room. It’s a mansion turned into a restaurant. The owners are getting older and u better go before the retire. I’d give it 10 stars if I could.
… moreEunice Champion
This was the first time we have been and had great service. Our waiter was Shawn and he was awesome! The atmosphere is quaint and the food was delicious! We will definitely be back!!
… moreJake Pschirrer
Andrew’s is the best, most gourmet restaurant in central and southern Illinois. It’s a destination restaurant. We’ve been going there for over 20 years and have always had amazing food and service. The mansion is beautiful and comfortable. It’s a great place for parties, family gatherings, and date nights. Call a few weeks in advance for reservations because they are very popular! You won’t be disappointed.
… moreMarian Tomblin
We ALWAYS treat ourself to an evening at Andrew’s whenever we are in Central Illinois.
… moreMatt Forcum
Fantastic restaurant concept great for small group or intimate dining. Attentive staff in a casual atmosphere. Superb kitchen creations matched with an even more impressive wine list and bar selection. Certainly a must try for locals looking to upscale dining experiences or travelers seeking a truly unique experience. As of this review reservations are required, open Fri & Sat, and not accepting credit cards.
… morethia
This is so delicious and super classy. My husband took me here for our Anniversary and although it is a little pricey the experience is well worth every cent. I can’t wait to go back. From the outside of this establishment it is a little underwhelming since it looks like an old farm house, but once you go inside it becomes part of the appeal. Out in the middle of nowhere, beautiful countryside & cozy decor. The food was perfectly cooked. Wonderful! Absolutely wonderful! I can not say enough good things about this place. I can’t wait to go back. 🙂
… moreC Gleck
Great dining experience and worthy of every penny
Service: …
… more