Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Authentic Italian Pizza in Columbia, SC | Schiano’s Old Tyme Pizzeria
When you think of New York-style pizza, you don’t have to hop on a plane to get it here! Schiano’s brought Brooklyn’s best slice to Columbia over 35 years …
Schiano’s Fast Casual Italian – Columbia, SC
This place is a Jewel. Small feel of a local pizza parlor, with excellent Italian dishes. You order at a counter to eat in like an old school pizza parlor.
Schiano’s Olde Tyme Pizza Restaurant in Columbia, SC, a favorite …
They’re located on 560 Lakehurst Rd. in Toms River, just off of Rt. 37 West next to Cluck-U Chicken. At top is a bruschetta balsamic slice, with …
Reviews
A Wash
Delicious brick oven baked pizza! reminds me of old Italy. love it! Great service every time I come. Highly recommend!! Just look at that pizza YUMMMY .
Side note the building is not appealing. The interior definitely needs remodel. But if we buy more food from the then maybe they can get one!!
… moreSide note the building is not appealing. The interior definitely needs remodel. But if we buy more food from the then maybe they can get one!!
Little Red
This location is a walk in and order. You can choose to dine in or take out. We choose to dine in. The food came out separately target than together. I needed to confirm that my food was in fact ordered as the waitress offered a second plate for only 1 item brought to the table.
The supremr pizza was good. They calll it NY, but as a NY’er.. the pizza was OK. The crust held the toppings bit did lack some flavor. It could have used a bit more sauce as it was dry. NY didn’t use alot of sauce so that’s saying alot. Supreme had peppers, onions, olives and mushrooms.
The meatball sub was good. Meatballs were tender and had flavor. The bread was soft and the sauce was just right. The cheese was melted. This was 5 stars by itself.
I will go back again for another visit.
… moreThe supremr pizza was good. They calll it NY, but as a NY’er.. the pizza was OK. The crust held the toppings bit did lack some flavor. It could have used a bit more sauce as it was dry. NY didn’t use alot of sauce so that’s saying alot. Supreme had peppers, onions, olives and mushrooms.
The meatball sub was good. Meatballs were tender and had flavor. The bread was soft and the sauce was just right. The cheese was melted. This was 5 stars by itself.
I will go back again for another visit.
Matthew Hart
Coming from out of town… didn’t have high hopes for SC pizza joints…. Man was I wrong. This place had very friendly customers service, great atmosphere, I ordered the medium pepperoni lovers, under $20, and man is this delicious! Very good food and will definitely be coming back.
… moreAaron Lee
I understand if I didn’t know what I was looking at. I would have needed assistance because the lady up front at the cash register was definitely a little bit off. I don’t know what it was. If it was a long day or something else, but one of the closest to New York style and northern Pizza. Taste and uh, everybody knows what i’m talking about when I say that that good mozzarella…… it is the water yaw, but nonetheless, it was great food
We got the steak Stromboli, without mushrooms and the supreme without mushrooms, special
I hope y’all enjoy. This is a good spot to eat. I have been here maybe 10 times and only 2 times it was subpar. Food, the other 8 have been delicious. Thank you to the owner. He is awesome. He seemed busy this time so I didn’t say much
… moreWe got the steak Stromboli, without mushrooms and the supreme without mushrooms, special
I hope y’all enjoy. This is a good spot to eat. I have been here maybe 10 times and only 2 times it was subpar. Food, the other 8 have been delicious. Thank you to the owner. He is awesome. He seemed busy this time so I didn’t say much
Chris Griffith (cgriff1030)
Columbia does not have many good pizza places, this one is included. The dough, the cheese, even the toppings taste pre-bought and unfresh.
My pizza tasted like cardboard with sauce (and the sauce was light)
I can understand cutting some corners but if you want to keep your restaurant running, you need food that makes people want to come back. My pizza had the taste of the cheap 3$ pizza you grab out of a freezer from Walmart and im not okay with that for 18$ for a medium pizza.
Make your own cheese blend, flavor and toss your own dough and cook with some love and fresh ingredients.
… moreMy pizza tasted like cardboard with sauce (and the sauce was light)
I can understand cutting some corners but if you want to keep your restaurant running, you need food that makes people want to come back. My pizza had the taste of the cheap 3$ pizza you grab out of a freezer from Walmart and im not okay with that for 18$ for a medium pizza.
Make your own cheese blend, flavor and toss your own dough and cook with some love and fresh ingredients.
Michelle Carantit
I can’t believe a place you order from weekly and support had the nerve to say they would charge me for some garlic powder because it’s on the table and I’m not dining in. I just asked for a side of it as I was under the impression it was a free item. The pizza is the best but Gezz guys a side of garlic powder??!! I guess it’s safe to say we will be looking for a new pizza spot.
… moreNaomi Phoenix
Pizza was made amazingly! Love the linguine marinara mussels wish it had more marinara but tasted amazing. The salad still had olives and peppers in it when I requested it to be taken out and also they forgot my bread sticks but after I told them they handed it to me. Both girls working service didn’t know the menu appropriately and the one answering the phones and running the register/phone orders had nothing but attitude and temper. Didnt appreciate the other girls rudeness when I arrived to pay and wait for my order. Definitely would come back for the food if the service gets better without the nasty attitude.
… moreAmanda
When we started going to Schiano’s a couple years ago it was great. Our pastas and pizzas were always hot and tasty with no issues. Last several times (really should have called it quits after the second time) we have ordered pizza Togo it has been a wide variety of bad. Crust would be burnt, wait would be super long with no other customer in site, or it would be rushed and under done. This time is our last time though. Called in an order, husband leaves the house as soon as I hang up and tell him 25 minute quoted time. We live 10 minutes away. As he gets there they say they are just then taking it out of the oven and boxing it up. He gets home and the pizza is cold, crust rock hard, cheese and toppings look like they haven’t seen the oven for at least 2 hours. Enough is enough I guess. Later Schianos of Forest Drive!
… moreJen Lynn
After being in Columbia for around 3 years, I have tried multiple Pizza Joints…
Schiano’s has Amazing Everything!! I just recently started trying out their pizza, and I am addicted!
The service is Great, All Food (so far) has been Great!! The kitchen staff definitely knows what they are doing, unfortunately the younger gt the
… moreSchiano’s has Amazing Everything!! I just recently started trying out their pizza, and I am addicted!
The service is Great, All Food (so far) has been Great!! The kitchen staff definitely knows what they are doing, unfortunately the younger gt the
Andrea Moses
I really wanted to like this place. I’m from New York state and spoiled when it comes to great pizza and subs. This was pathetic! I’ve had frozen pizza that tasted better and the three dried meatballs was a crime. Over priced for poor quality and I’m super pissed at myself for leaving a tip. This excuse of a sub was $9. I’m not sure where the positive are coming from but don’t waste your money or time. Truly disappointed.
… more