Maria Mongiardo
** Off Track Pizza – Portland, ME **
If you’re craving a solid slice in Portland, **Off Track Pizza (15 Exchange St)** is definitely worth a stop! We tried a mix of slices and their **$14 CHICKEN PARM** sandwich, and here’s the breakdown:
**CHICKEN PARM** – A beauty! The **chicken cutlet, house vodka sauce, mozzarella, basil, and sesame seed bun** came together perfectly. The vodka sauce was flavorful, and the sesame bun was a nice touch. The only thing I’d change? The **chicken could’ve been crispier**! But overall, it **hit the spot**. **8/10**
**SLICES:**
✅ **VODKA BURRATA** – Creamy burrata, basil, and vodka sauce? Yes, please. This was a standout!
✅ **TRUFFLE MUSHROOM** – Earthy roasted mushrooms with **black truffle, scallions, and white sauce**—great for truffle lovers.
✅ **THE MOOTS** – **Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, olive oil, garlic, and sesame seeds**—I loved the sesame seeds and, honestly, I’m a sucker for **ricotta**.
✅ **BUFFALO CHICKEN** – Fried chicken, mozzarella, **blue cheese crumbles**, and scallions. A good take on a classic.
** FAVORITES:** **The Vodka Burrata & The Moots**—both were cheesy, flavorful, and the sesame seed crust on the Moots was a game-changer!
**Affordability:** **7/10** – Slices range from **$4-$6**, a fair price for the quality.
**Ambiance:** **7/10** – **Cute grab-and-go spot** with **upstairs seating and an old arcade** for a fun retro touch!
**Overall:** **8/10** – A solid slice shop that satisfies your **pizza cravings**. Definitely recommend stopping in if you’re in **downtown Portland**!
… moreMelissa Lunetto
Although they don’t have many choices on their menu, they keep it small and simple. The pizza is amazing, the guys at the counter are super nice, clean and the price is affordable!! I wish I lived in the area to be able to come every week, I know I’ll be craving it when I go home and will definitely be visiting this place whenever I come back!
… moreAdrianna Pirini
This is easily the best pizza slice in Portland. But the real show stopper was the raspberry cheesecake. That cheesecake is the most delicious thing I’ve ever eaten, and I’m not even exaggerating. It’s a last meal kinda cheesecake
… moreTara Konya
Best NY-style pizza in Portland! Just what this town needed. Perfectly foldable slices! We popped in for a couple of slices and will definitely be back once full pies are available. We also added on the dirty ranch dipping sauce, which was exactly what the crispy crust needed. Enjoy extra seating upstairs or savor Maine’s perfect summer with patio seating on the sidewalk.
… moreVincent
This place has cool vibes and you can get High Life Ponies. The crust is so dang good, a really nice crisp to it with a lot of flavor. I love how you can get pizza by the slice to which is always helpful in a pinch. The sauce wasn’t fully for me but everything else about it made up for it.
… moreDoug
If you’re from NY, and missing a slice from home.. or if you’re not from NY but you like pizza in any capacity… this is the place for you. Friendly staff, convenient location, tons of seating, and most importantly…. The best slice of pizza available in the State of Maine. Thin crust, perfectly crispy bottom, doesn’t flop. Sauce is delicious and the perfect sauce/cheese ratio. I plan on living here until I keel over and die. Thank you Off Track Pizza!!
… moreKathleen Menounos
Recently spent the day in Portland. This place was great. We were drawn in by their 11 dollar shot and pizza slice special . Headed upstairs to hang at upstairs bar. Bartender/mixologist actually was on spot and made me an off the charts Mai Tai. Cool atmosphere old vintage pictures old school pinball games dark wood, great location. I did not have pizza but my husband did and said it was delicious. When I get back to Portland I m coming back and trying the pizza.
… moreMarylou
Pizza is unreal… Service was phenomenal. Get the pepperoni and dip it in the ranch. If it’s late go upstairs and don’t listen to the chooches with the bad reviews.
… moreNat B
Great new pizza place in Portland! Seems like they’re doing a soft launch right now so all they’re doing are slices and some salads in the fridge. The pizza was great, real New York style.
… moreJeff Morgan
Undercarriage 5/5
Buffalo and vodka burrata slices were amazing. In my top 5 slices ive had anywhere in mew England.
… more