David Otto
This was first experience here and I just want to say that it was Awesome. We ordered the pizzaboli which was like having the best of both worlds. The pizza was great and so was the boli. The pizza was some of the best I have had in a long time. I saw them making subs for other customers and can’t wait to try one. I would definitely go here if you are in the area and want some good pizza.
… moreZachary Wolfe
Amici has become our go-to pizza joint. They have a very welcoming and friendly staff that create delicious pies and hoagies.
The prices are very reasonable. The food is delicious. I’d highly recommend getting your pizza “blessed”. You won’t regret it! If you like a grandma pie, this is THE PLACE to get it. Amici grandma pie is great and probably one of the best in the area.
I can’t speak much for the atmosphere because we tend to order to-go but the dining area looks very clean, is well lit, and normally has some sports playing on a TV or two.
The environment feels inclusive and welcoming as well.
… moreN M
Second time ordering from this place and the second time the pizza came like this. Figured the first time was a fluke and a friend really recommended the first location so tried again. This is disgusting. Completely liquid in the middle and you can see how terrible it looks. Never again.
*edit: whether it was the “handling of the pizza” or not, clearly they were rushing and threw the pizza in a box and closed it while it was way too hot. The fact that this has happened with two different orders (and the first time we got two pizzas and both were like this) is a bad sign. I can’t speak on the delivery of this pizza but the first time we picked the pizzas up and they most definitely left the store looking this terrible but I didn’t review/gave them the benefit of the doubt.
… morerobert richardson
Really good food and an amazing and friendly staff.
Must try the new signature burgers.
All Angus beef and good ingredients for toppings.
… moreDawn Jay
Don’t ever make the mistake of calling in an order to the wrong location, you will be embarrassed and treated like a criminal. I called in a order. I have alot of friends from work that order at the Mechanicsburg location. I had a busy day and called in a order on the way home from a sick visit at the pediatrician’s office. It was for a small pizza. I arrived and the cashier told me she didn’t see my order, she asked me if I called the other location by mistake. I actually apologized for the mistake once I realized the error. I asked if I could put in another order, or grab slices instead. I was told you can just drive to Mechanicsburg and pick up the one you ordered. I asked could place an order again. This time the cashier called over a man who I believe was the manager at that location. He again told me to drive over and pick up the pizza. I was trying to explain I would not be able to, but he began rudely talking to the cashier telling her to call the other store, then says either way we’re out money. Then he told me again it’s only 7 minutes away. Seven minutes on the other side of town in rush hour traffic is alot with a sick child. I ordered a small pizza less than $15.00. As a manager in the food industry for many years, I can say for certain mistakes like this happen all the time, but to tell a customer to go to the other location an pick up the pizza then argue about losing money all while refusing to let me place an order is completely ridiculous. It’s completely unprofessional and pretty much a place I would never visit again. One would think I had placed an order for 15 large pizzas. The funny thing is the owner which I have met many times at the Mechanicsburg is very pleasant. I have no idea what is going on with Camp Hill but I have never experienced anything like this. Ridiculous and a terrible experience.
… moreTricia M
They say we have too many pizza places, and maybe that’s true, but Amici’s isn’t competing with anyone. It’s in a category of its own. Franky and the team bring the kind of friendly energy that keeps you coming back, and the pizza backs it up every time. Our family can’t pick just one favorite (Hawaiian, Grandma’s, AND Chicken Parm, thank you very much). No photo to share because, well… it didn’t last long enough. That should tell you everything.
… moreVigilans Skopos
We’ve been ordering from Amici for quite some time, and they never disappoint. Having tried most of the pizza spots around Camp Hill, Amici stands out for their traditional thin crust—it has that perfect New York-style fold and the right amount of crispness.
Beyond the pizza, their strombolis and hot subs (especially the cheesesteaks) are excellent and always packed with fresh ingredients. It’s clearly a family-run operation that cares about quality and service. Whether we’re grabbing a quick lunch or ordering dinner for the family, it’s always consistent. Definitely a top-tier choice for authentic Italian in the West Shore area!
… moreRebecca Weist
My mom and I were in Camp Hill today shopping, we are from York, and decided to stop in here today to pick up dinner to take home and wow! The staff were so friendly as soon we entered, the place is clean and the food was fantastic! We got a pizza boil (pictured) and a California cheesesteak and we were extremely impressed with everything! Can’t wait to come back and worth the drive from York!
… moreAshley Ocker
Pizza is good, but all my requests were not followed. I requested a Vinny style blessed crust, uncut cheese pizza. I got a normal cheese pizza that was cut and didn’t realize till I was home and didn’t want to drive back.
… moreCorey Hawk
This place is amazing! Friendly fast service, excellent food and great atmosphere. There isn’t anything else I’d ask for. It’s pretty close to perfect keep it up!! I’m usually very harsh on pizza reviews because I’m from NY and worked at pizzeria’s so I hold it to a high standard and Amici’s crushed it!
… more