Chelsea Patton
If you’re looking for great New York–style pizza, this is THE place! They also have strombolis, calzones, wings, heroes, and delicious pasta dishes (the baked ziti is my favorite!). Great food, great service, fun atmosphere, and the owners are amazing! Give them a try, I promise you won’t be disappointed.
… moreDeirdre Creamer
This was my 1st time trying this new spot here. I started with 2 by the slice. Omg, it was phenomenal!! I wished I’d purchase a whole pizza. The ingredients were fresh and very, NY style. It was amazing!! The crust is super thin!! Crunchier and crisper to my liking, but you can eat around it. A male behind the bar waited on me. He was so, hospitable and welcoming. I was the only spot in that place lol!! Thank you for that. I’ll be back
… moreAngie R
We had the stuffed pizza and it was Amazing! We will definitely be back and bringing family. My new favorite pizza for sure! They have a great outdoor area with TVs and heaters for when it’s cold.
… moreTom Walsh
My wife said let’s have pizza tonight, I went to get the mail and there was a Pappy’s Pizza mailer. We haven’t lived here long and only have tried one other pizzeria here. So we looked over the ad and made our choice, called in the order.A very friendly person took the order and help me with the the extras and 17 minutes later I was picking up dinner.
Well when I walked in I was greeted warmly and genuinely. And as I was being rung up we have a friendly chat about the place and their pizza.
I paid cash saving 3.5% credit card fee, and also received a veterans discount.
The pizza was great, tasty crust with crispy edges. So much topping on the Nanny’s meat lovers pizza. The sauce was perfect and we got a side order of the red sauce for dipping.
Overall a wonderful experience and a great meal. I love to shop local when the owner takes care of you and has skin in the game .
BTW bonus, the pizza was delicious cold for breakfast the next morning.
… moreRachel Earl
Our first time trying Pappy’s – and it was such a great visit. Everyone was so friendly – we felt invited, welcome, and that they genuinely cared about our experience. It was early on a Saturday evening (around 6) with the games on – lightly busy but not crowded or slow at all. All food was tasty and we look forward to returning!
… moreCasey
First time ordering here. Spent 70 bucks get home and didn’t get 2 orders of fries. Called back very friendly and said it was fine then drove back up and they called the manger when we got there. They made a big deal and said we got it. And was annoyed to get what we ordered. Why would I drive all the way back for a lie? Then after arguing getting it he gave it to us. Do not order the chicken Alfredo. It’s the same as the freezer Michelina’s from Walmart. I love a local place but this whole experience was awful. Bad food and worse treatment.
… morePaul Willis
We went there for lunch today. I have been on carnivore diet for a year and wanted pizza, salad, and cake for my yearly cheat day. All was great but for some reason the salad tasted the best to me. Customer service from the lady that was working was perfect. I love living in a small town with a local pizza shop!
… moreBilly Patton
Excellent food! A great variety of pizzas and tasty wings! Staff is super friendly and treat you like family. Even with the hectic rush of orders coming in they still maintain a friendly atmosphere. Glad we decided to stop in. It has become our first choice in restaurants to go eat.
… moreteresa hardeman
Small dine in area, but there is plenty of bar seating, as well as outdoor seating for nice days
We had a calzone and the chicken parm hero, both were absolutely delicious! The fries were cooked to perfection
The table.next to us had a pizza that looked absolutely irresistible. Can’t wait to try that next time!
… moreJesse Whited
This was my first time coming to Pappy’s and I’ve gotta say, it was impressive! Even in a crowded environment, the service was great and the food even better! I had the NY deluxe specialty pizza and it was phenomenal! Definitely will be coming back and with more people. The menu has many more delicious varieties to choose from, and I will definitely be trying more of them in the future!
… more