Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5790 Transit Rd, Depew, NY 14043
Phone: (716) 685-0005
Website: https://www.doordash.com/store/37182030?utm_source=mx_share&aw=W8YNW8k04cfuWjUK
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
57 Ninety Restaurant – Order Online
Banner image. 57 Ninety Restaurant. 5790 Transit Road, Depew, NY. Delivery. Pickup. Pickup from 5790 Transit Road, Depew, NY. Schedule your order for later.
57 Ninety Restaurant Reviews | Top Dining in Depew, NY
57 Ninety Restaurant is a cozy eatery in Depew, NY that offers a delightful blend of American cuisine with a modern twist. With a focus on fresh ingredients and …
57ninety Restaurant and Catering – Step Out Buffalo
Thu, Mar 19 +more dates • 4:00 pm – 9:00 pm. 57 Ninety Restaurant • 5790 Transit Road Depew, NY 14043. Cheektowaga and East. Eat & Drink · Fish Fry Fridays. Fri …
Reviews
Kevin Brooks
Im partial, but this is only second to my mother in laws italian cooking(she’d kill me lol) food was fantastic friendly staff, HEALTHY portions fair prices. First place around I’ve seen with actual stuffed mushrooms, which were AMAZING. A meatball the size of your fist! Food was hot fresh and delicious. Only down side, it seemed a bit chilly inside we were at a bar top by the front window where we asked to sit, so maybe thats on us. Stuffed peppers, garlic bread with cheese baked spaghetti parm mmmmmm
… moreTodd Fiore
I take my dad and bro here all the time. We loved it when it was a different Italian joint, and it still delivers excellent American Italian cuisine at great prices, but with a much larger menu selection of food. Can’t go wrong with everything I’ve tried. I usually do the lasagna, it was delicious. Fresh bread and a huge tasty side salad to start.
… moreM. Klein
I recently visited 57 Ninety Restaurant, a spot we frequented previously but had also been curious about, since they opened and took over the space that was formerly La Costa Verde. Since they’re celebrating their first anniversary, it felt like the perfect time to give them a try.
On this visit I went specifically for their Tuesday Pizza special and was happy I did. The pizza was so tasty, I’ll absolutely get it again.
The menu has a lot of variety, so I’m already looking forward to my next visit to try some of their other dishes, perhaps for a sit-down meal.
One thing I love is that they offer two different sauces: a sweet one reminiscent of the previous restaurant’s sauce, and a more seasoned option.
The staff was wonderful, delightful and incredibly helpful. They made placing my order a seamless and efficient process. Inside, the restaurant has a much more modern and comfortable feel than before. Everything was very clean and organized, though I did notice a persistent, slightly off smell that was also present with the previous owners (so it may be building related).
For a local, non-chain meal, 57 Ninety is certainly worth checking out!
… moreOn this visit I went specifically for their Tuesday Pizza special and was happy I did. The pizza was so tasty, I’ll absolutely get it again.
The menu has a lot of variety, so I’m already looking forward to my next visit to try some of their other dishes, perhaps for a sit-down meal.
One thing I love is that they offer two different sauces: a sweet one reminiscent of the previous restaurant’s sauce, and a more seasoned option.
The staff was wonderful, delightful and incredibly helpful. They made placing my order a seamless and efficient process. Inside, the restaurant has a much more modern and comfortable feel than before. Everything was very clean and organized, though I did notice a persistent, slightly off smell that was also present with the previous owners (so it may be building related).
For a local, non-chain meal, 57 Ninety is certainly worth checking out!
Jamie Pauly
Great food, perfect portions. Had the shrimp scampi pasta was cooked perfect shrimp was not overcooked. Bread is fresh out of the oven with a delicious dipping oil. Side salad was crispy and fresh. Our waitress Jennifer was great made sure we had what we needed let us know about daily specials.
… moreMarissa Marek
I ordered take out and was very pleased with my order. I got an eggplant Parmesan dinner and a large cheese and pepperoni pizza. The eggplant dinner was crispy and had layers of ricotta in between. The pizza was cooked to perfection! Highly recommend ordering take out or dinning in.
… moreNara Brooks
This Valentine’s Day, we chose to visit 57ninety, and it was our first time dining there. From the moment we arrived, everything felt special and thoughtfully prepared for the occasion. The atmosphere was romantic and beautifully set up, making it the perfect place to celebrate.
The food was absolutely amazing — every dish was flavorful, well-presented, and clearly made with care. You could tell that quality and attention to detail were a priority. The service was just as impressive; the staff was welcoming, attentive, and made sure our evening was smooth and enjoyable.
Overall, our first experience at 57ninety exceeded our expectations. It truly made our Valentine’s Day memorable, and we will definitely be returning. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a wonderful dining experience!
… moreThe food was absolutely amazing — every dish was flavorful, well-presented, and clearly made with care. You could tell that quality and attention to detail were a priority. The service was just as impressive; the staff was welcoming, attentive, and made sure our evening was smooth and enjoyable.
Overall, our first experience at 57ninety exceeded our expectations. It truly made our Valentine’s Day memorable, and we will definitely be returning. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a wonderful dining experience!
Sandra Kostelny
Very nice atmosphere, food is delicious! The homemade sauce is amazing! Staff is very kind and friendly! Nice place for date night
… moreNancy Shaw
Our first time trying a fish fry here. It was delicious. Beer batter was nice and crispy, fish was fresh. It came with sides of coleslaw, macaroni salad, fries, and a side of pasta. Our server Jennifer was awesome.
… morehear & listen
Dinner tonight at 57 Ninety was wonderful. My husband and I celebrated our 20th anniversary, and the evening felt relaxed and special without being overdone. The food was excellent, the atmosphere was comfortable and welcoming, and the service made it easy to enjoy the night. Sharing a cannoli at the end was a perfect way to finish our anniversary dinner. We’re already looking forward to coming back.
… moreMaggie May
Really clean and food was delicious, lot of good choices. Friendly staff, def go again, photo is eggplant bomber on foccacia bread
… more