Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony’s Pizzeria – Welcome
Classic NY Pizza! Order Online. Great … Address: 170 Broadway Port Ewen, NJ 12466. Phone: 845-331-2001. To add this …
Review of Tony’s Pizza in Port Ewen, New York – Facebook
The Sicilian just tastes right to me, lots of cheese, flavorful sauce and chewy dough. Some Sicilians you bite into and it just crumbles into …
Tony’s Pizzeria Delivery Menu | 170 Broadway Port Ewen – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Tony’s Pizzeria in Port Ewen! View Tony’s Pizzeria’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Reviews
Heather Dammer
We ordered from them twice. I should’ve learned my lesson the first time.
The first time they had an elderly delivery driver from Greene county doing deliveries with no access to gps or a map so he was an hour late to our house and called me no less than 5 times for directions.
Tonight we decided to pick up instead of deliver.
Two pizzas , garlic knots and 20 wings. The prices online did not reflect the price of my total so when I called just to confirm I was met with the out of control owner who called me crazy and said “if you don’t like the prices on my menu, then merry Christmas” whatever that means.
I was happy to pay my bill but I just wanted clarification. He was rude and made little attempt to be professional.
The food was alright. Definitely not worth the trouble.
I’ll be ordering from toscos in rosendale. Waaaay better food anyway.
I would NOT recommend this place. I highly suggest taking your business elsewhere.
Seriously. Do yourself the favor.
… moreThe first time they had an elderly delivery driver from Greene county doing deliveries with no access to gps or a map so he was an hour late to our house and called me no less than 5 times for directions.
Tonight we decided to pick up instead of deliver.
Two pizzas , garlic knots and 20 wings. The prices online did not reflect the price of my total so when I called just to confirm I was met with the out of control owner who called me crazy and said “if you don’t like the prices on my menu, then merry Christmas” whatever that means.
I was happy to pay my bill but I just wanted clarification. He was rude and made little attempt to be professional.
The food was alright. Definitely not worth the trouble.
I’ll be ordering from toscos in rosendale. Waaaay better food anyway.
I would NOT recommend this place. I highly suggest taking your business elsewhere.
Seriously. Do yourself the favor.
Nolan Palmer-Smith
Fantastic pizza! The slices were thin and crispy and I love it how little and thin the crust was. The flavor was on point and the crunch in the crust was dynamite!
The owner, Tony I guess was there making pizzas. He was super friendly and made me feel welcomed.
I will definitely come back for a slice
… moreThe owner, Tony I guess was there making pizzas. He was super friendly and made me feel welcomed.
I will definitely come back for a slice
Jason Portney
Tony’s did an amazing job catering the food for my son’s first birthday party. They were responsive, on time and the food was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend trusting them with any large order or catering.
… moresavanna rose
Came to Tony’s pizza with a couple friends. Came in and got greeted by Tony, he is a very nice guy and made all the accommodations that we requested.. The pizzeria is very well lit and has plenty of space. The food was amazing the best I have had in a long time. Was quick to come out very delicious. Will definitely visit Tony’s pizzeria again when in the area
… moreFrancis morelli
The pizza is awesome. Individual slices in the case are huge. Their dinners are also great. The Penne alla vodka is a go to for my family.
The owner makes you feel welcome every time you go in. I can’t recommend this place enough.
… moreThe owner makes you feel welcome every time you go in. I can’t recommend this place enough.
Ty Collins
Tony is creating MASTERPIECE’S. THANK YOU ALWAYS, YOU NEVER MISS!!
Customer service always special. I well continue supporting my local neighbor!
… moreCustomer service always special. I well continue supporting my local neighbor!
Free Child
Pizzeria was nicely decorated according to the season. You can tell they really care. Pizza was delicious. We enjoyed sitting outside. Overall excellent place for a quick bite.
… moreBen Schneider
I picked up an almost $90 order for 2 orders of BBQ wings, 2 Buffalo wings, mozzarella sticks and calamari. Upon inspecting the order we noticed there was hardly any sauce on the buffalo wings and we were missing our mozzarella sticks. After refusing to make it right via phone I drove the wings back and the owner added sauce onto my (now cold) wings.
When I asked about the mozzarella sticks he insisted he gave them to me. He refused to give me my order or do anything to make it right. The conversation ended with him screaming across the restaurant at me until I left. This is by far the worst customer service I’ve ever received and will not go back after being a faithful customer for years. Super shady and disrespectful all around. Nothing like the previous owner.
… moreWhen I asked about the mozzarella sticks he insisted he gave them to me. He refused to give me my order or do anything to make it right. The conversation ended with him screaming across the restaurant at me until I left. This is by far the worst customer service I’ve ever received and will not go back after being a faithful customer for years. Super shady and disrespectful all around. Nothing like the previous owner.
Larissa Alvarado
Horrible!! We ordered two pies for our community center kids. It was never delivered. We called to confirm and they delivered it to the wrong place. Had a random person sign the receipt and argued with us about trying to get a free pizza. They didn’t offer to replace the pizzas or refund our money back. Horrible customer service. The owner is messed up. Ww had hungry kids. Never again!!
… morepatrick saddoris
Pizza is outstanding every single time, guys behind the counter are extremely outgoing and kind even when slammed. Best pizza in Port Ewen
… more