Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Laid-back pizza joint with and cool vibe and nostalgic decor. Lost Pizza Co. offers pizza, pasta, sandwiches, wings, Mississippi Delta Hot Tamales & desserts. We make every pizza with pride using only the finest and freshest ingredients! Almost everything is made fresh, in-house, every day. So come early because when they sell out of something, they are OUT (until tomorrow!) GET LOST…
Laid-back eatery with quirky decor offering pizza, pasta & subs, plus wings & other appetizers.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2600 College Ave Ste 100, Conway, AR 72034
Phone: (501) 585-9045
Website: https://www.lostpizza.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Conway, AR – Lost Pizza Co.
Reviews … We had a wonderful experience here! Everyone is extremely friendly and helpful. You won’t find a better pizza! … Great food and great service!
Lost Pizza Co. | Where Pizza Dreams Come True
Born in the Mississippi Delta, we serve up fresh ingredients and funky vibes daily. View locations, menus, and order online.
Lost Pizza Co. in Conway, Arkansas – Reviews and Experiences
I can say good food is not lost but found here!!!! The tamales were FANTASTIC, the Pizza was delish, thin and crispy with plenty of toppings …
Last Updates
Reviews
Sydney Lovell
This was my first time trying Lost Pizza Co!
All of the staff were very kind and hospitable. Even when my food was taking a little longer in the kitchen they were very kind to communicate what was going on and even offered me a cheese dip while I waited.
They were very attentive and made sure my friend and I had everything we needed during our dining experience. I got the bee keeper pizza (size small), their house chips (with chipotle ranch), and my friend got the tamales and the olive bread. Everything was so delicious and cooked to perfection! One last thing I must note was how affordable everything was. My entire dining experience was a 10/10. I will most definitely be returning. Thank you Lost Pizza Co!
… moreAll of the staff were very kind and hospitable. Even when my food was taking a little longer in the kitchen they were very kind to communicate what was going on and even offered me a cheese dip while I waited.
They were very attentive and made sure my friend and I had everything we needed during our dining experience. I got the bee keeper pizza (size small), their house chips (with chipotle ranch), and my friend got the tamales and the olive bread. Everything was so delicious and cooked to perfection! One last thing I must note was how affordable everything was. My entire dining experience was a 10/10. I will most definitely be returning. Thank you Lost Pizza Co!
Jesse N
Barely had the chance to make it deep into the restaurant and love the decorations. The pizza was good, and there are a few pizzas on the menu I would like to come back and try. The in-house ranch is delicious too.
There is also outside seating, which is awesome.
… moreThere is also outside seating, which is awesome.
Ashley Sweeney
Fun vibes, quick and friendly service, and delicious thick crust pizza with a buttery crust. We loved it! We ordered a large Kujo with no olives or mushrooms and large house salad with their homemade ranch. The food came out quickly even though it was a busy Saturday night. My picky eater even got seconds. The pizza dough had the best flavor and could withstand all the toppings without flopping. The large was big enough for my family of 3 to take half home for later. The staff was friendly and attentive and even offered my child Rice Krispie treat after his dinner. It was really sweet. We will be back!
… moreNoah Brooks
My wife and I are huge Hideaway Pizza fans, but we decided to try out the new pizza place in town. I was so surprised by Lost Pizza Co.! The location is super cool. It’s in the first floor of an apartment/condo building. The interior is decorated with all sorts of signs, posters, and fun things. It’s a great way to keep kids entertained or even yourself! The best part… was the pizza!! We ordered the Lucille and the flavor was so good. The thick crust is also great. Reminds me pan style pizza almost.
The only thing that caught us off guard, is the restaurant is not a sit down and order. You walk in and you have to place your order first, grab a number, and then find a table. Not a bad thing at all! We just expected a host stand with a wait, so it was a pleasant surprise! The place was moderately busy and still the food didn’t take long.
We will definitely be returning! Now we will have to flip a coin to decide between this or Hideaway!!
… moreThe only thing that caught us off guard, is the restaurant is not a sit down and order. You walk in and you have to place your order first, grab a number, and then find a table. Not a bad thing at all! We just expected a host stand with a wait, so it was a pleasant surprise! The place was moderately busy and still the food didn’t take long.
We will definitely be returning! Now we will have to flip a coin to decide between this or Hideaway!!
Josh Shockey
First visit to Lost Pizza Co.
The restaurant was clean and had a nice atmosphere, and the front counter employees were friendly. Unfortunately, the service really missed the mark.
We waited over an hour for a medium pizza. By the time staff noticed the issue, my family had already finished eating and was ready for to-go boxes. We were then told the pizza had never been started. After another 30 minutes, we finally received the pizza and were refunded—but the pizza was still incorrect.
I also noticed a male manager in a blue shirt at the front who avoided our table while checking on larger tables nearby. When I asked to speak with a manager, someone from the kitchen was sent out instead.
Nice environment, but the long wait, poor communication, and management response made this a disappointing first experience.
… moreThe restaurant was clean and had a nice atmosphere, and the front counter employees were friendly. Unfortunately, the service really missed the mark.
We waited over an hour for a medium pizza. By the time staff noticed the issue, my family had already finished eating and was ready for to-go boxes. We were then told the pizza had never been started. After another 30 minutes, we finally received the pizza and were refunded—but the pizza was still incorrect.
I also noticed a male manager in a blue shirt at the front who avoided our table while checking on larger tables nearby. When I asked to speak with a manager, someone from the kitchen was sent out instead.
Nice environment, but the long wait, poor communication, and management response made this a disappointing first experience.
Mary Robinson
We ordered a pizza some boneless wings and some bone in wings. The wings were pretty good but the pizza was terrible. Not cooked all the way through and about 2lbs too much cheese. Plus it had a strange/ bad taste. This is the 2nd time we have had a bad experience with them. Last time they never started the order till we got there and then dropped the pizza on the floor. They were honest about it and did their best to quickly make another. This was probably the last time we will eat there.
… moreChris Shroyer
The staff here are spot on great!! The pizza however, left much to be desired. I ordered a Large Pepperoni, Mushroom, and Onion Thick Crust. They were stingy with the toppings. Little Caesars puts more toppings on their pizzas. I may try their thin crust and see if it’s any better. Off this experience alone I just don’t see the superiority over other pizza joints like Papa John’s or Hungry Howies.
… moreDuncan MP
Took the kid got cheese sticks, a kids cheese pizza, and a deep dish large Otis. The pizza was great and the folks were nice! The kid loved his pizza and the cheese sticks. The Otis was larger enough I had leftovers for supper. Two could eat it and be full. Would def recommend!
… moreJulie Olson
We enjoyed a delicious take-out pizza last night… crispy-chewy crust, plenty of toppings… and the Christmas-y box made us smile! The crew at Lost Pizza always seems friendly and happy! Thank you!
… morekrystle neese
Ordered a pizza there yesterday and got really really nauseous because the pizza was too raw and toppings wasn’t cooked throughly and italian sausages were so raw!!! Pizza dough wasn’t cooked long enough that there were raw dough in the pizza. You guys messed it up big time. I took videos of my pizza instead of photos for proof. I’m genuinely disgusted by it. Will find a way to contact the corporation too.
Update: I still haven’t heard from you guys and still am waiting on my refund. The email addresses you gave me bounced. Seems sketchy to me.
Update: Charles and I haven’t gotten our refund each. We both checked our bank account and got no refund. Please show me proof that you guys sent us both refund.
… moreUpdate: I still haven’t heard from you guys and still am waiting on my refund. The email addresses you gave me bounced. Seems sketchy to me.
Update: Charles and I haven’t gotten our refund each. We both checked our bank account and got no refund. Please show me proof that you guys sent us both refund.