Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Dallastown, PA, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Dallastown pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Dallastown or stop by 857 E Main St for carryout to order the best pizza in Dallastown, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 857 E Main St Unit B, Dallastown, PA 17313
Phone: (717) 246-7272
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Papa Johns E Main St | Papa Johns Dallastown, PA
Call us for pizza delivery in Dallastown or stop by 857 E Main St for carryout to order the best pizza in Dallastown, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
papa johns stores in dallastown, pa
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Dallastown, Pennsylvania to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa Johns Pizza, 857 E Main St, Unit B, Dallastown, PA 17313, US
Get more information for Papa Johns Pizza in Dallastown, PA. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Last Updates
Reviews
Jesse Hollinger
I LOVE pizza. I always liked Papa John’s sauce and their cheese. We ordered two pizzas. One pan garlic parmasean crust and one with with stuffed crust. The parmasean crust was waaaay too strong and the crust was soggy. I don’t think its a service issue such as overcooking, I believe its a bad product. The other pizza also was soggy. Honestly the garlic parmasean crust sounded great but it was overwhelming. Also the cheese got crispy-ish but it left the crust soggy. The service was pleasant but honestly I’d rather go to little Ceasars for a pan and the local mom and pop pizza place. Don’t waste your money on these products in my opinion.
… moreBrian Stankiewicz
I ordered tonight’s dinner for the family in a pinch because I didn’t have the chance to grocery shop today (Busy).First thing the food was made lightning quick so always a good start. The food was ON POINT, Also want to mention it was made exactly how I ordered it. Light sauce was actually light sauce and cooked well done as asked also. I would have taken better pictures for the review but the food didn’t survive long. A+ keep up the good work. Btw the pick 2 for 6.99 each is killer it your not trying to kill your wallet.
… moreSandra Smith
Ordered a stuff crust pepperoni and sausage. The pizza was as thin as paper. Ordered cookie bites and came without dipping cream. We order from here alot and am very dissatisfied.
… moreCrystal Vickers
It isn’t much of an eat in, more pick up and go. There were only 3 employees working when I went and it took a few minutes until someone could assist me but they were cooking so I understood. Obsessed with the cinnamon bun dessert.
… moreMagic Mas
If you’re gonna order from here make sure you order with the day shift. After 5 you get pizzas with half cheese off and one side super thin. Day shift is excellent! Evening crew needs HELP!
… moreJennifer Gregg
Steven or Stephen (don’t know the spelling) was awesome and a sweetheart. Patient and professional and will start ordering from here again for the service alone….he deserves if not a raise then a solid visa gift card or bonus!
… moreBella Keller
I made a phone call order and Sebastian answered the phone. He was providing great service and answered many of the questions I had. His customer service is great and he showed no attitude when I asked him the same question five times! I love Papa John’s, and after this experience, I will definitely be ordering again!!! Props to Sebastian for providing me the correct store to order from, but still taking my order!! Great service overall 10 out of 10 experience from Sebastian. Give that man a raise!!!!
… moreNathanial Renoll
Papa John’s has completely won me over with their delivery service! My order consistently arrives before the estimated time, which is such a pleasant surprise and a rarity these days. The delivery drivers are fantastic—always so kind, courteous, and professional.
And let me tell you about the food—it’s phenomenal. Every bite is fresh, flavorful, and exactly what I’m craving. From their perfectly baked pizzas to the mouthwatering wings, I’ve never been disappointed. It’s clear they care about quality, and it shows in every order.
The only downside is that it can be a bit pricey to order frequently, but honestly, the quality, service, and reliability make it absolutely worth it. I wish I could give each of their staff a high five for being so awesome! If you’re looking for top-notch delivery and delicious food, Papa John’s is the way to go. Highly recommended!
… moreAnd let me tell you about the food—it’s phenomenal. Every bite is fresh, flavorful, and exactly what I’m craving. From their perfectly baked pizzas to the mouthwatering wings, I’ve never been disappointed. It’s clear they care about quality, and it shows in every order.
The only downside is that it can be a bit pricey to order frequently, but honestly, the quality, service, and reliability make it absolutely worth it. I wish I could give each of their staff a high five for being so awesome! If you’re looking for top-notch delivery and delicious food, Papa John’s is the way to go. Highly recommended!
Jon
Just wanted to shout out Stephen his service over the phone was awesome and professional. – Nicole F
… moreK “Smeary” T
Ok, so the day we went here we needed a quick bite to eat while we were driving through… We wanted to try the new stuff crust… My husband LOVES Pizza, like all the different kinds… SERIOUSLY, so he KNOWS his pizza VERY well.
First off, the guy didn’t have change to give us. He said “no change you want I go to bank”. It wouldn’t be a big deal but we’re penny pinchers, we hardly ever buy food out unless we need or really want to and He owed us $4 and some coins, so instead we gave him smaller bills closer to the amount we owed…
Anyways, whatever, no biggy, the VERY ODD thing is we opened the pizza box and we’re like “hmmm smells so good”, and we’re like, “it kinda smells like pizza Hut”. We start eating it and I kid you not.. “IT TASTE JUST LIKE PIZZA HUT!”
Of course we’ve had Pizza Hut stuffed crust, they were the only ones that had it for years and years.
We have tried Papa John’s stuffed crust twice since then and each time we’re like, “yeahhh, now this is Papa John’s”.
So we aren’t accusing this location of pulling a quick move and pulling a little switch-a-roo but it is extremely ODD…
Papa John’s just came out with their own stuff crust, it’s the very first time we tried it and instantly it smelt and tasted familiar, Pizza Hut or not, the mystery will always remain…unless someone else has had the same experience?
… moreFirst off, the guy didn’t have change to give us. He said “no change you want I go to bank”. It wouldn’t be a big deal but we’re penny pinchers, we hardly ever buy food out unless we need or really want to and He owed us $4 and some coins, so instead we gave him smaller bills closer to the amount we owed…
Anyways, whatever, no biggy, the VERY ODD thing is we opened the pizza box and we’re like “hmmm smells so good”, and we’re like, “it kinda smells like pizza Hut”. We start eating it and I kid you not.. “IT TASTE JUST LIKE PIZZA HUT!”
Of course we’ve had Pizza Hut stuffed crust, they were the only ones that had it for years and years.
We have tried Papa John’s stuffed crust twice since then and each time we’re like, “yeahhh, now this is Papa John’s”.
So we aren’t accusing this location of pulling a quick move and pulling a little switch-a-roo but it is extremely ODD…
Papa John’s just came out with their own stuff crust, it’s the very first time we tried it and instantly it smelt and tasted familiar, Pizza Hut or not, the mystery will always remain…unless someone else has had the same experience?