Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Papa Johns Pizza in Mount Sinai, NY, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Mount Sinai pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Mount Sinai or stop by 152 NY-25A for carryout to order the best pizza in Mount Sinai, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Papa Johns Ny-25a | Papa Johns Mount Sinai, NY
Call Papa Johns Ny-25a at (631) 928-6666 for more information or to place a catering order today. How do I join Papa Johns Rewards? Earn Papa Dough to use …
papa johns stores in mount sinai, ny
Browse all Papa Johns Pizza locations in Mount Sinai, New York to order pizza, breadsticks, wings and more for delivery or takeout near you.
Papa John’s Pizza | Mount Sinai NY – Facebook
Use promo code PAPA to save on your pie and eat it too. Get 50% off regular menu price ! Valid thru 6/25. · · . Papa John’s Pizza. Jun 7, 2017 .
Last Updates
Reviews
Sal Sayed
I placed a takeout order at the Mount Sinai Papa John’s location and ordered four pizzas of mixed sizes. Based on the menu and pricing, the total came to approximately $66, which felt reasonable for the quantity and variety ordered.
Starting with the positive, the food itself was very good. All four pizzas were cooked properly, tasted fresh, and were enjoyable. The crust, cheese, and toppings were consistent with what you expect from Papa John’s, and from a food-quality standpoint, there were no complaints at all. The menu is clearly laid out, prices are transparent, and vegetarian options are labeled, which makes ordering easier for different preferences.
Unfortunately, the service significantly impacted the experience. One staff member working on pizza preparation was openly rude, unprofessional, and disrespectful toward another employee in front of customers and was constantly on video call and talking to someone in forigen language. This created an uncomfortable and hostile environment. Another employee assisted me only after I repeatedly insisted on getting help, and even then showed little interest in providing customer service. The overall service felt dismissive and unwelcoming.
Because of this behavior, the atmosphere was not pleasant despite the store being otherwise clean and organized. Customer-facing interactions matter, and this location would benefit greatly from improved professionalism and basic courtesy.
They accept online orders, credit cards, and cash. There is a private parking lot, which is free, though parking can become limited during peak hours.
In summary, the food was great and worth mentioning positively, but the poor service and negative in-store interactions ultimately brought the experience down.
… moreStarting with the positive, the food itself was very good. All four pizzas were cooked properly, tasted fresh, and were enjoyable. The crust, cheese, and toppings were consistent with what you expect from Papa John’s, and from a food-quality standpoint, there were no complaints at all. The menu is clearly laid out, prices are transparent, and vegetarian options are labeled, which makes ordering easier for different preferences.
Unfortunately, the service significantly impacted the experience. One staff member working on pizza preparation was openly rude, unprofessional, and disrespectful toward another employee in front of customers and was constantly on video call and talking to someone in forigen language. This created an uncomfortable and hostile environment. Another employee assisted me only after I repeatedly insisted on getting help, and even then showed little interest in providing customer service. The overall service felt dismissive and unwelcoming.
Because of this behavior, the atmosphere was not pleasant despite the store being otherwise clean and organized. Customer-facing interactions matter, and this location would benefit greatly from improved professionalism and basic courtesy.
They accept online orders, credit cards, and cash. There is a private parking lot, which is free, though parking can become limited during peak hours.
In summary, the food was great and worth mentioning positively, but the poor service and negative in-store interactions ultimately brought the experience down.
Margarita
I love pizza Papa John’s!. It’s office always clean and friendly, the staff is great, and the pizza is always delicious and hot! They cook it quickly and don’t keep you waiting long.
… morevamshikrishna patel
Papa John’s in Mount Sinai is my absolute favorite! The pizza is always fresh and tasty, and the staff are really friendly and quick. They never miss a beat — always a great experience!
… moreBatuhan Karadağ
Customers and delivery drivers are not treated well. The woman working the evening shift is shouting, talking on her phone, and being rude and unhelpful to the drivers.
Please speak more politely and treat people better.
… morePlease speak more politely and treat people better.
Engin As
When u compare with really busy other pizza stores they have stabil good quality of food , delivery and service very reliable.
… moreEli Recupero
DONT DONT eat here if you have an anytime of nut allergy! If there’s a India lady and u are allergic don’t because she was cooking my food and she was eating a nut mix and they don’t use gloves!
… moreLindsey Zuniga
Quite literally the WORST pizza I have ever had and the order was completely wrong in every way. Somehow, even with 4+ people behind the counter, they were taking and making orders incredibly slowly. I ordered one large pepperoni pizza. I wanted half of it to have black olives and the other half to have green peppers and onions. Not only did the pizza only have like 10 pieces of pepperoni in total, but half of it was plain and the other had raw onions and peppers, sausage, and mushrooms WITH stuffed crust which was essentially just a stick of cheese inside of some really floppy dough. Our pizza was lukewarm and it just seemed undercooked. My friend and I both took one bite and agreed it was the worst pizza we’d ever had.
… moreP Sinram
So far so good ..food is always hot and good’ they be on time with delivery. Forgot soda with order n made sure to bring one to me asap did not wait long..very nice on the phone. If you like papa John’s this location seems to be very well on point
… moreSalvatore cascio
Always friendly staff . Fresh food ! Great place !
… moreBecca Barnoski
We love all the staff here and look forward to our Friday nights. The pizza is always fresh and hot!!
… more