Mary Bauer
love the potato salad. whenever I m
in the area I stop and get it
… moreKaren Heighton
Their salads are the best. Whenever I’m back in my hometown, I stop and pick up my favorite potato salad and if it’s Friday, fish cakes and potato pancakes are the best! Karen from Maryland
… moreHonest Reviewer
Absolutely love coming here. Besides the excellent salads (potato salad and coleslaw are neck and neck for fav) the store itself has such an enjoyable old school feel. Kind of like walking back in time. I hope they keep that nostalgic feeling.
… moreRoberto Buccianti
Best deli for potato salad. Seriously, I have yet to find a better recipe…anywhere…and I travel overseas. The rice pudding is outrageous. However, friendly is not a word I would use to describe the staff.
… moreLucille Hrychynszyn
My favorite deli for most of my life! ALWAYS. Freshly made food and delicious! BUT…..a few days ago went to by salads an was shocked!! For 3 two lb. Containers of salads my bill was over 30.00!!
I know prices have increased all over BUT NOT THAT MUCH!! NEVER AGAIN!! ILL go back to making my own!! It’s way cheaper!!
… moreJoseph Tizio
A little mom and pop store that I have been going to for over 20 years. Open 5 days a week closed on Monday and Tuesday every week. Different hot items specials every day.. The best home made rice pudding around made with a merange topping very creamy. Comes out fresh every day around 10 to 10:30 daily.
… moreGerri Gely
Old, old and needs a good cleaning. Only salads, roast beef and a pasta dish that did not look fresh. However, there was a line so their salads may be good. I opted no to try them.
… moreJoe Gallagher
Old school deli. Been a Bayonne staple for over fifty years, so they must be doing something right. Best potato salad in town. Roast beef is outstanding. Yummy rice pudding.
… moresski66
The Fifth Street Deli is a Bayonne/ downtown institution. It’s been there well over 50 years & I’m glad.
They bake there own ham, turkey, roast beef, & roast pork for sandwiches. There potato, macaroni, & cole slaw salads are a must as is there rice pudding. It’s our traditional deli of Bayonne & I hope they’re there another 50 years with the same recipes.
… moreFrank Fontana
Decent macaroni and potato salad. Very good rice pudding and shrimp salad. Awesome store made cold cuts! Terrific Mac and cheese! Fresh breads.
… more