Jared Fudurich
I love to try pizza everywhere I go. Was a little skeptical here for some reason, but the pizza was excellent and definitely did not disappoint. Sauce was very tasty, good amount of cheese, and a nice, crisp crust! I’m new to Sea Isle, but will be back to Phil’s for pizza. (side note, my gf got a Greek salad and that was unfortunately really, really weak – iceberg lettuce, barely any “Greek” topping to it). But, this place is a pizza place and this is a pizza review…so it gets 5 stars for their pie!
… moreCraig R
Never order from this restaurant
They got my order wrong and blamed it on me. I ordered a Chicken Stromboli and the were rude and said I ordered a cheese Stromboli and asked me multiple times. Why would they ask me multiple times if I ordered cheese? This doesn’t even make sense.
They were rude when I politely asked if they could address. They told me they only charged me for cheese so it shouldn’t be an issue.
I suggest you order elsewhere unless you are desperate for food.
I also waited 30 minutes longer than they told me.
… moreEd Miller
Best Pizza in South Jersey, won’t disappoint. Order early!
… moreTucker
Stop what you’re doing. You think the wait is long? Order anyways. Downright incredible pizza. The Swirl ™ is what you have to get. Lets start with the sauce. Its sweet. Its tangy. Its balanced perfectly with a thin layer of cheese that does not overpower the freshly made sauce. The ratio is perfection. And now for the crust. It has to be the best crust I have ever had. Crunchy without being burnt, flakey without falling apart, and seasoned to perfection.
This pizza is so good you will eat and eat beyond your fill until it has been incinerated off the table.
Also Cheesesteaks come with great sesame seed rolls with friendly servings of beef.
5/5 must come here
… moreThomas
Really enjoyed their sausage and meatball pizza. The crust is crisp and the way they do their sauce on the cheese seems to make it taste even better. Would recommend trying it! (Sorry for the missing pieces in the photos lol it went fast)
… moreConnie Remar
Rude. They put down an order of Cheese Stromboli when we ordered Chicken. They said the young lady has worked there 10 yrs who took our order…as if she never makes a mistake. They said they didn’t care if I left a bad review.
… moreJolie
Worst service experience I have had in many years. They were so mean to me when I let them know that I ordered at steak Stromboli but they only gave me cheese. They said that their staff have been there 10 years so it couldn’t be their mistake. Wow! How about that they are sorry for the misunderstanding and that they by will fix the issue and make things right. No. They could care less!
… moreMarcelo Agudo
I was excited to try after the pizza Review Portnoy gave this place a 7.8 ? Not even close the sauce is ok the crust is not . I was even more disappointed when I saw they added $15 to my credit card .
Check your card charges people !
… moreConnie Remar
Pizza is actually decent, but the staff is AWFUL!!!! Very rude! Our order was wrong and they said it was our fault. I don’t even want to give them 1 star. Will never eat here again.
… moreBob
I’m here now having their pizza for the first time. It’s awesome!!!! Fast service and great food.
… more