Emma “Fcemma” Nwa
Papa Johns at this Elkridge location is your classic reliable chain—hits the spot for cheesy, saucy comfort when you’re not chasing gourmet. The fresh ingredients shine in a well-loaded supreme or BBQ chicken pie, and portions (especially sides like cheese sticks) keep it family-friendly without breaking the bank. Staff’s usually upbeat for in-store orders, and the strip mall setup makes it a breeze to grab and go near other errands.
That said, it’s no artisanal standout—delivery can drag (plan for 45+ mins), and crust quality varies (sometimes chewy, not crispy). Prices crept up ($15+ for medium), but app deals help. Worth it for casual nights; skip if you’re after thin-crust innovation. Pro tip: Call ahead or use the app to avoid lines.
… moreCharlie Dav
I don’t doubt the bad reviews here now. I made the mistake purchasing from you today 12/14/2025. I paid $36 including tips to driver to receive a completely different pizza from what I ordered. I ordered the meats pizza with Buffalo sauce well done but received a normal chicken pizza with garlic sauce. I’ve never ever seen something like that before. This is bad customer service. I’ll not order from you again.
… moreKarina M
Had pizza here last month. Not impressed. Figured I would try again then again since I earned papa bucks on my order. Forget it. Pizza is still a saucy mess and soggy! All 5 pies ordered, the same slop. I used default sauce on the order page.
This time we had to put it in the air fryer to crisp it up. Otherwise it was a limp mess and barely edible.
Don’t waste your money on toppings. Some slices had none, even though you pay extra for them.
Go to Dominos around the corner. Much better pies and consistently good. Plus you can taste and see your topping.
… moreJermone Calloway
I’ve ordered here several times. I have ordered here on the weekends in the evening. They are quite busy then but I order ahead and my order has always been ready on time. Service has always been great. On Le of the guys there even gave me some recommendations on different sauces to try with my cheese bread.
… moreSheree M
I order from this place quite a lot and I can honestly say this place needs improvements. If your order delivery, they don’t seal your order every time and the order can take a long time to be delivered. Today, no seal (sticker) on the pizza box and as the driver hands me the pizza, the box is open. Then, the order was freezing cold. Everything was cold and cheese was solid. Now, why would any food service think this is acceptable. It’s not.
… moreAngelina Unchupaico
I ordered at 3:11pm they told me it was arriving around 30-50 minutes, it was already getting suspicious. I called again at 4:05 because the pizza hasn’t arrived yet. They told me it was arriving in 7 minutes. I called 3 times at 4:27 and no one answered. FINALLY the pizza arrived but it arrived cold and ugly. This is a bad place to order if you want to deliver. Please don’t order for delivery waste of time and money
… moreJose Martin
Toppings were less
Decent Pizza
Neat and clean place
Timely delivery
Placed and online order and it ready as committed. The food was pretty decent but the toppings were far to less.
… moreShakirah Johnson
Food was horrible. Asked for my wings to be “well done” and they weren’t, AT ALL. Wings were slimy and were barely coated in sauce. Asked them to make my pizza square and they still gave me regular slices. I will never order here again. 0/10.
… moreDeShonda Smith
I order all the time never had this issue maybe the new $6 special. My one pizza barely had any toppings. The second pizza said no cheese instead no sauce and ton of cheese. The cinnamon pulls are over cooked, no icing, and it looks like someone threw it in a box or picked at it.
… moreLiam Davis
If I could give zero stars, I would. When I picked up my pizza it looked like one of the workers with glasses threw my pizza across the store! The manager looked at the pizza and made a joke about it. PLEASE TRAIN YOUR EMPLOYEES BETTER. Please Stay away from this location.
… more